Justifying your career decision

Or, known in other words, as the Great Rishta Turn-off. This happens to me usually at 75% of the desi functions i attend, or when i meet some new Auntie/Uncle from the community. i know a few Guppies around here are pursuing non-conventional fields of study. i would like to know which ones those are and have you felt the pressure to justify it to your family/friends/relatives, etc.

“BeTi - kia parh rahi ho?” is the question every student gets asked. My eyes averted to the floor, i respond quietly, “International Development Studies”. There’s a pause, usually followed by an extremely polite, “Kia?” The Auntie leans in closer towards me to hear me better. A bit more loudly this time, my eyes still glued on the floor, wishing i could get swallowed up by a black hole right about now, i repeat, “International Development Studies”, fidgeting with my fingers, playing with the edges of my dupatta, anything to avoid having to look her in the eyes. Poor Auntie pauses, not quite sure what to say next to me. There’s an awkward pause in the air. At this point, whatever self-esteem you had, is 90% gone. “Oh acha,” and Auntie smiles very kindly, not quite sure what to make of this rebellious girl who is wasting her life studying something so trivial. Then she says, “Uss sai kia job milay gi?” Now i love this question because the thought of what job positions you can get with this, are extremely self-satisfying for me. i explain i would like to work overseas, do “development work”. i leave out the Africa part, because i don’t want to give her one shock too many in such a short period of time. The next question is usually preceded by a nod, and then, “Laykin beTi, uss mai zaida paisa tau nahin ho ga?” This is the most depressing question, and if there was a black hole around somewhere, i would jump in it wishing to be swallowed by it for a few years. “Nahin,” i nod my head in agreement, replying truthfully, “Uss mai zaida paisa nahin hota.” The Auntie nods sympathetically, perhaps feeling sorry for my parents. To be fair, i have had these experiences more often with my long-time friends than Aunties - and it’s with well-intentioned friends who think they are stating these things out of justified concern for my future.

So - is anyone else studying something perceived of as ‘unconventional’? How long does it take before you are able to justify it to your family/friends. Which fields of study are you pursuing (just out of curiosity). i get the same reaction (above) as i get from most of my friends, minus one or two so to be fair, it’s not Aunties i am pointing fingers at. It’s my friends who can be so darn discouraging… it gets to you after a while, to the point now where if i am discussing studies/careers with some of them, i will change the topic so i don’t have to hear disparaging remarks. Their niyat may be excellent, but the end result is always that i end up feeling massively discouraged. To any Guppies who are studying non-conventional fields of study, what are those (out of curiosity) and how have you justified it to your family, friends, et al?

these aunties dont know jack..

I went through a similar situation when i changed my major in collge from engineering to marketing..it was assumed by some that i flunked out of engineering university.. it was hard as hell to explain that it was by my own choice and that actually our business dept was much tougher to get in compared to the engineering one.

People ask all kinds of questions and have no basis of understanding anything. I was confident of my choice and stood by it to the point of arguing with uncles.

now this is just about the time when business was beginning to get some respect in pakistan..partially due to that dude in drama tanhaiyaan who was an MBA..but it was still relatively unkown.

here is what I heard..

baita pakistan mein marketing ka kya scope hai
reponse: uncle i am planning to stay in the US or go to UK from a career perspective

iss mein paisay toh acchay naheen miltay hongay
response ( thats where i make them feel like morons) ..response, uncle it depends on how hard you try, where u go to school and where you work.

agar commerce hi parrhni thee toh pakistan mein parrh laitay
response: uncle studying commerce here vs being in a good business program is just as different as getting an engineering technician diploma here vs an engineering degree overseas.

then ofcourse they dont know anything about any universities except those that their bhanja bhateejas have told them is a good school.

baita kahan parrh rahay ho.
answer: University of ABC
acchi university hai..
answer: ji its a good school

mera bhateeja xyz state mein parrhta hai, woh toh bohot accha school hai
answer: uncle XYZ state is a decent university in some areas, but ABC Uni is better for business

accha tum kehtay ho toh maan laitay hain
(now I am not the one for rankings but i really want to smash uSA today or princeton guide to colleges and universities on their head then)

of course teh funniest story i have is some aunty ji who inquired about my fraternity shirt and asked what it was, when i told her what it was, her and her husband did some digging and told my parents I was member of a satanic sect of free masons..sigh and these ppl were not even back in Pakistan but in canada :)

My advise, be confident of your choices, if they cant understand it that is really not your problem. let them be kunwain kay maindakk and stuck on daaaktaaar, anja neyar

:).

I know what you're talking about..

I spent 6 months in Pakistan with "Intelligent Robotics" as the major of the masters program i was admitted to.

I am unconventional as they come according to my family. I did International Relations and Economics and i want to join the International Trade field. It is extremely small and totally unknown. I dont have to do the whole desi function thing as i avoid them like the plague.

But look you really want to shut them up. Throw out some names. Like what are you doing International Development Studies. When they ask you for a job desciption, say well all the UN agencies have a section. UNDP, UNEP, UNHCR etc etc. Just mention the name UN and their eyes will light up. That will shut them up. Of course you really want to hit it in their head. Say its the latest thing to take teh world by storm. Every organization has division (which is true) and the Western Govts are establishing divisions as well.

Tell them its like IT, but i am getting in ahead first.

yeh ,
our desi people have never been able to step outside the 'injeeniear' or 'daaktar' phenomenon. And if we look at it this attitude may have a lot to do with our countinued backwardness; we don't produce enough professionals dealing in other areas of work.

I used to get funny looks for doing a batchelor's in Chemistry & Management.

But now that I'm working in IT, I've been redeemed :D

Glad to see that so many desis are into unconventional stuff. I salute you all. I am a victim of very conventional career. But I do get funny looks too...they all think I make tons of $. But I don't as I work to live & enjoy. My aim is not making tons of $. Life is too short.
I wish I had guts to change my line!

Politics. What else is there to say. You can imagine the responses I get. smile

Be happy with what you chose, when you are, you wont be sad when others complain. hugz

Nadia :hug:

i know its tuff but the solution to this is that u just have to have a confident front and believe in yourself and ur career decision…thats the most basic thing…

logon ka to kaam hi hae doosron ko dikhana k jee we r so sorry for u this that…i mean no matter what u do some ppl will be unhappy…

when someone asks u what u plan to do with a degree in ur field, just answer with the correct answer and explain exactly why u r in that field and what opportunities u see for urself and why u chose it…just be confident abt it and show that in ur heart u r satisfied with it…dont allow anyone to pity u or make u feel down…kasam se…

if others know u r confident in what u r doing n like it, n do have some idea about it and are not just taking some fuzzy major coz its easy but u have a good idea abt it and know of the opportunities avlbl in that field and plan to take advtg of them then they’ll be less likely to give u that respnse and make u feel like u r wasting ur time or something…

and if they still do, mitti pao n be happy

personally i think this major suits u well and u’ll do great inshallah, i’m with u :k: