Jinnah, Islam, and British Envy

read this at various places about Mrs Rutti Jinah’s dress:

I was thinking on various aspects about Mr Jinah’s personality, his political career which revolved around a state which was being demanded on the basis of religious identity and then this instance. I thought it was more about Mr Jinnah’s love for his wife and support her personal choice. So, I thought to google and here I find a new dimension:

She Would Not Be Wrapped | Outlook

[TABLE=“width: 100%”]

[TABLE=“width: 100%, align: center”]

                                   [TABLE="width: 100%"]

                     [TABLE="width: 100%, align: right"]

[TR]
[TD]

[/TD]
[/TR]

                                                                                                                                                            For  the British, **anxious to distinguish themselves from the natives,  nothing was more galling than Indians in European attire. The elite  women, especially, in their transparent chiffon saris and plunging  necklines, were regarded with a mix of suspicion and envy.** 

One of the most daring dressers of her time was Ruttie, Jinnah’s young wife. Regarded by most as one of the best-dressed women in Bombay, she was a regular at the exclusive Emile Windgrove tailor’s shop, where the Europeans went to buy their clothes. As one of the richest lawyers in Bombay and a rising political star, the Jinnahs were invited to all the parties thrown by governors and viceroys. Ruttie invariably caused a sensation at these formal dos in her tight dresses of brocade “cut to the waist back and front, no sleeves, and over it, a chiffon sari”. As Lady Alice Reading wrote about her: “She is extremely pretty, fascinating, terribly made up. All the men raved about her, the women sniffed.”

But it wasn’t until Lord Willingdon became Governor of Bombay that her dress became a political issue. As a close associate of Jinnah’s, Hector Bolitho, later recalled: “Mrs Jinnah wore a low-cut dress that did not please her hostess. While they were seated at the dining table, Lady Willingdon asked an ADC to bring a wrap for Mrs Jinnah, in case she felt cold.” The haughty Jinnah rose from the table, saying, “When Mrs Jinnah feels cold she will say so.” Then he led his wife from the dining room, and from that time, refused to go to Government House again.

The incident sparked a political battle between Jinnah and Lord Willingdon that eventually led to the latter’s departure. It ended in a public brawl, with Jinnah and his supporters breaking into the Town Hall and disrupting a farewell party hosted for Lord Willingdon by the Sheriff of Bombay. **It has gone down in Bombay’s history as perhaps the first battle caused by a dress.
**

Re: Jinnah, Islam, and British Envy

Looks too far fetched to me.

Re: Jinnah, Islam, and British Envy

Where's the historical source of this incident?

Re: Jinnah, Islam, and British Envy

quite famous incident and quoted in many biographies of Mr Jinnah and Rutti Jinah. I think it was probably portrayed in one of the movies/ dramas made on Mr Jinnah's life

Re: Jinnah, Islam, and British Envy

some references:

Chronicling Ruttie Jinnah - - DAWN.COM

The woman Jinnah loved – The Express Tribune

Great Indians: Surendranath Banerjea to Gandhi - Balraj Krishna - Google Books

https://www.google.com.pk/?gws_rd=ssl#q=lady+wellington+ruttie+jinnah

Re: Jinnah, Islam, and British Envy

His Islamic personage emerged only later due to politcal reasons.

Re: Jinnah, Islam, and British Envy

Probably, yes. As per some accounts, he highly discouraged Ruttan Bai to accept Islam just for the sake of marrying him. On the other side, Jinnah's family was conservative when it comes to dressing of ladies, which is evident from family photos of their family and public appearance of Miss Fatima Jinnah.