Re: Javed Ahmed Ghamdi
If he denies some ahaadith, he must have some understanding of them.
Must you do his blind taqleed, man?
Is he very pretty or looks like a princess that you prefer him over the whole world?
[quote]
Obviously I do not have that much knowledge but I can tell that certain ahaadith actually seem fabrications. You've said this yourself too so there is some part of you that feels it as well.
[/quote]
SubhaanAllah! You don't have knowledge still you know some hadiths are forged. It's a miracle. Isn't it?
Well, if you feel bad about some hadiths then that might be because you don't have sufficient knowledge or you follow your desires. Isn't it the best way to gain knowledge yourself and stop doing blind taqleed of those who belong to an Isolated Block.
[quote]
I will spend some time and read his books, Miizaan and Burhaan to form an appropriate opinion.
[/quote]
Come on! You shouldn't read his books, first read Quran and Hadith then read books of Ghamidi or Hamidi, then only you will know who is who and shoe is shoe.
[quote]
You should do the same rather than asking others... as you have clearly seen, most people here have not even read his works and are forming an opinion based on their pre-conceived notions.
[/quote]
Well, personally, I haven't read any books AGAINST Ghamidi, my views about him are because I have myself seen him on tv many times, he behaves like a Jahil to keep talking like a parrot. Once Dr Shahid Masood from ARY channel (in the past) asked him about Jihad that if it can be started without the permission of Goerge Wa*ker Mush or Agha Hamid Kargai, you know what Chacha Ghamidi said?
He said Jihad cannot be started without the permission of the Head of the State, and Shahid Masood asked even if a foreign force attacks you will wait for the permission of the head of state against the foreign forces, and he didn't reply to the point and said
Only the head of state can announce Jihad.
which means if Hamid Karzai (the American Puppet) doesn't announce Jihad against Americans, all those who are fighting Americans in Afghanistan are not doing Jihad, but they are terrorists.
This is why I hate your Chacha Ghamidi and I will be quite happy if such a Munafiq dies of a Rabies.
[quote]
Dear sister, I was too upset last night by binAdam's post. How can one expect to have a conversation with a person who says, in essence: Kill anyone who disagrees... what kind of Islam is this??? Is this how Ara'ait an-Naas yad khloon-a fii diin Illah-i afwaajaa?
[/quote]
I didn't say kill anyone who disagrees, I said Kill the Apostate (of course through an Islamic State) and if Ghamidi denies this punishment of Apostacy, he becomes an Apostate also.