Dear Mr. Scholar, if someone doesn't reply to your illogical scholarly knowledge, that doesn't mean they're scared of the great wisdom you posses, it only means they have a life beyond GS and may have other better thing to do.
I don't like debating on such idiotic issues, but just in order to provide you with an opportunity to reveal your great knowledge and wisdom to the public, I'm going on with a debate. I will appreciate if you get back to me with a point-by-point logical argument to prove me wrong, rather than coming up with a fatwa with no logical proof. We know you have great religious knowledge, i request you to share it with your muslim brethren on this forum.
(¯`·..· Can Koran be used to perform or cure Magic? ]·..·´¯)
°o.O Those Who say Koran is Magic will be Cast in Hell O.o°
The Koran mentions people who said about the Koran: `This is nothing but magic handed down". For such people, God has said: "Soon shall I cast him into the fire of Hell." (Koran, 74:24,26)
°o.O Those Who say Koran is Magic are Disbelievers O.o°
And those who disbelieve say about the truth when it comes to them, `This is nothing but manifest sorcery.' (Koran, 34:43)
°o.O The Disbelievers allege Koran to be Magic O.o°
"Nay, but I bestowed upon these disbelievers and their fathers worldly provision until there comes to them the truth and a Messenger who makes his Message clear. But when the truth came to them they said, `This is sorcery and we do reject it.'" (Koran, 43:29,30)
°o.O The Koran is a clear Truth and not Magic O.o°
And when Our clear Signs are recited unto them, those who disbelieve say of the truth when it comes to them, `This is manifest sorcery.'(Koran, 46:7)
I had said the same thing in my post that Koran is a message to people, and contains the philosophy of life. Such verses can not do the supernatural. You made it sound like I was passing derogatory comments. Now you know that is what the Koran has said about itself.
°o.O Secrets Arts and Magic? O.o°
Your other scholar brother has quoted the surah's that he claims possess supernatural powers of magic. In all those surah's there was only one verse that gave a slight idea of any supernatural art. That is:
YUSUFALI: From the mischief of those who practise secret arts;
a) This verse seeks refuge from Allah from the practicers of the secret arts. It does not teach us to seek refuge in the verses of the Koran, like you are suggesting.
b) Yousaf Ali in what he calls an ''approximate translation'' has changed the original words of the Koran. The Koran does not mention any secret arts in this verse. Here are some other translations which prove me right.
Palmer: and from the evil of the blowers upon knots;
Daryabadi: And from the evil of the women blowers upon knots,
Ayub Khan: and from the evil of the women who blow on knots,
Qaribullah: from the evil of the blowers on knots;
Shakir: And from the evil of those who blow on knots,
Sher Ali: And from the evil of those who blow upon the knots of mutual relationships to undo them,
Arberry: from the evil of women who blow on knots,
If Yousaf Ali doesn't know what 'women who blow on knots' means, it does not mean he should change the phrase to 'those who practice secret arts.'
c) This verse mentions WOMEN who blow on the knots. The phrase used for them mentions a feminine gender. If this phrase is about pracitioners of magic, then why does it only talk about female magiciains? Does that mean that the Koran can not cure the magic done by male magicians?
Kindly reply point by point rather then making general sweeping statements about the state of my faith. Its time to prove my knowledge is 'little' and yours is 'big'. Its time to share your knowledge with the the rest of us. The public is waiting.