ISRAEL: A Terrorist Success Story

[phoenixdesi]

Re: ISRAEL: A Terrorist Success Story

@arshad5

Are you trying to justify the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinians by saying that muslims, hindus and sikhs moved to different areas after the creation of 2 states?

The hindus and muslims and sikhs all lost land and were given replacement land in their new countries. In most of the cases they were given more land than they actually lost. So the net effect was they were not any worse off than before.

Again I don’t see why people have a habit of trying to sidetrack every thread about US and Israel by bring Pakistan into it.

NO…I am not justifying plight of Palestinians…you made a statement that over 800K Palestinians were evacuated from their land and israeli settlers moved in there…and you justified violence by saying that these Palestinians are the actual owners of Israel and that the grandchildren of the people that were forced out of Israel are firing rockets into their own land from where their grandparents were evicted by force. ..

and I am syaing that if we want to live in the past and use such analogy for justifying taking a violent path then let us reference to history a bit more…that is all!

i guess those Hindus and Sikhs should be justified in killing Pakistanis settlers as well …

look at your double standard my friend…in one case, eviction of Palestinians is a horrible and the most brutal thing but forceful eviction of hindus and sikhs from Pakistani punjab is “absolutely fine” as “they were given more land than they actually lost” and “the net effect was they were not any worse off than before”…allah kee shan kaya kehna aap kay insaf ka!

i mean really? they were all well off? you have any idea how many families got destroyed and were never able to come out out of plight… and even if some of them got replacement land what about the emotional pain? after all Palestinians refuse to settle down in different countries ..they want their own “land” back.