ISLAMIC LAW

[Mindstorm]

@hanibal

Infact their are few who would agree with me, Dr. Israar Ahmed are amoung the few, on the second note, this is what now majority of Muslim youth talk about.. no sect, Just Islam as per Quran and Sahi Hadees, i don’t know about ur social circle but the more i meet the youth of today, the more i get the feeling that sooner or later, Islamic Shariah would be the only answer…

Okay…

I have particular respect for Dr. Israar as he is the least hypocrite amongst the religious scholars.

But really what you have been posting and what Dr. Israar preaches is totally different to your idea of sharia. For example Dr. Israar is totally against religious freedom and advocates death for apostasy. While you are far too liberal to endorse his views. Dr. Israar wants death penaly for Qadiyanis to be implemented in Pakistan, while I don’t think you are such a radical that you would like to kill all the Qadiyanis.

Yes, other religions are controlled by their religious doctrine, same applies to muslims, they need to be diciplined and controlled by their religous doctrine.. their will be a particular ministry which will look after all these affairs and a stronger and Just judiciary will make sure that no body is crossing the line.

Again your reasoning is nothing but a circular reasoning. Now you want to have a ministry of religious affairs over looking the people’s collective wisdom. Please inform us who is going to choose the all powerful Minister of relgious affairs.

yes, show me one country/society in this world which is sharia-based? can you show me model of it ( mulla omer and company does not fall it one), why would i trust a aalim who have only one ambition in his life and that is to prove other cult KAFIR, this kind of mindset have turned 2/3rd of muslim world Kafir or confused. I think you do fall under the category of confused ones ( I am basing this argument on the assumption that you are a muslim and is not qadyani, christain or others)

The reality is that every other muslim who has ideas other mine is a kafir. This is general mindset in the uslim world.

I told you in the beginning that your idea of democratic sharia has no example in the history and must be invented. Infact you have also shunned some of the ideas from quranic sharia which you don’t like. For example you are against jazya tax although it is prescribed by Quran. I think you will not reintroduce slavery in your democratic sharia inspite of quran endorsing clearly the captives of war being enslaved and instructing people to treat them justly.

Who said it is impossible to achieve, it is possible, only thing is one have to determined and dedicated for it and practise it. I would rather advice you the same, that you must learn about the Islamic Shairah first and then talk about secular systems of all times.. I are being dishonset and are trying your best to prove that Muslims are now looking forward to Secular system, naming it as Islamic Shairah…

I am a student and do not claim to know everything. Neither I am so fixed in my mentality that I am unwilling to change specially like some extra so called relgious people. I know we are trying to suggest a system for our country where we presume that even non-muslim Pakistanis are patriotic and are not against Islam and people’s right to practice Islam. This is the basic difference between us and early islamic society of Holy Prophet PBUH, therefore those laws were time specific and do not apply to our society.

Again you need to learn Islam more, Islam is not limited to praying of five times a day, 30 days of fasting, giving alms to deserving and performing Haj once in life time, Islam is about each and every action of an individual should be according to The Book of Allah All Mighty and instructions/demonstration of Prophet (SAAW). May it a being a father, a clerk, or a Khalifah, everyone have their set of job description which need to be followed…

Read your last sectence again. It is the best sentence I have read from your posting so far. I don’t think that Allah has given us this job that we should impose his religion on others in the name of sharia. I don’t think Allah wants his religion to be hijacked by anyone for political gains or to come in power.

Fasting, praying etc. are means of self cleansing, and more and more people will clean their souls, the better society we will be able to achieve. We can not slap our own personal virtue/piousness on people in the name of sharia.