This is yet another discussion where falsehoods are being propagated in the name of religion.
Just remember the BASIC fact.
100% of Islamic scholars (of national stature) were AGAINST the formation of Pakistan and all of these Islamic scholars considered Jinnah as Kafir (or at least a Muslim of the lowest level of belief).
So the fact is that
Either
#1 --------all those Islamic scholars were WRONG
Or
#2 ------ Pakistan was never meant to be a theocratic Islamists’ state.
#1 is not true. Because all the big names scholars like Madoodi cannot be wrong. They had done their research and homework to figure out their ANTI-Pakistan position.
Thus #2 must be true.