Islam has Indian origin

NOTED SCHOLAR and Sarva Dharma Ekta Manch secretary Abdullah Tariq claimed here on Sunday that Islam was a religion with an Indian origin.

He said, “The first Prophet Hazrat Adam was born in India, according to belief, and the last Prophet Hazrat Mohammad was born in Mecca.” He also said the study of the Vedas was the need of the hour.

Tariq was expressing his views in a symposium organised by the UP Rabta Committee at Islamia College of Commerce entitled ‘Ved and Quran: How Near How Far’.

He denied the charge that any particular community was responsible for the division of India. He said Partition of Greater India was not a new thing. There was a time when Cambodia, Burma and Afghanistan were part of India. He raised the question: “Who will you blame for separation of these parts?”

Tariq highlighted various points to elaborate the close relation between the Vedas and the Quran. He said various means of worship of God had similarities.

hastang was closely associated with namaz in which eight parts of the body touched the ground. Abdullah said namaz was a Sanskrit word, while the Arabic term was salwaat. Abdullah called upon people to study the text of the Quran and the Vedas instead of blindly believing and heedlessly following the explanations and discussions of pandits and the ulema.

Expressing his anguish, he said God was one, but people had sought to divide Him for their vested interests.

Expressing his views on the occasion, noted cardiologist Dr Jamil Ahmad shed light on the philosophy of the soul and the body. He said it was the nature of a human being to worship the Almighty and the Quran encouraged it.

He said misconceptions regarding the Quran and the Vedas should be removed to sideline the forces spreading hatred among people.

Presiding over the symposium, scientist Prof Maheshwar Mishra highlighted the crisis of belief, which he said was the main problem before society.

He said, “We do not have firm belief in God. This is the root cause of our various problems.” Dr M Gyasuddin and Manuwar Husain also expressed their views. Shahbuddin coordinated the programme

http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?id=824aa01d-e504-4d94-804c-13dc3993fe77&ParentID=4251278b-5d81-4884-92fb-fe28e1c45434&&Headline=Islam+has+Indian+origin%3A+Scholar

Re: Islam has Indian origin

THE PROPHET ADAM A.S. AND HIS WIFE EVE A.S. WHICH R REALLY OUR MOTHER AND FATHER COZ EVERYHTING STARTED OUT FROM THEM. SO THEY WERE BORN MEANING GIVIN A SOUL IN HEAVEN. THEY DID SOMETHING WRONG LIKE I THINK ATE THIS FRUIT FROM THE TREE AND ALLAH S.W.T. GOT MAD AND KICKED THEM BOTH OUT. SO THEY GOT SEPERATED AND ROAMED ALL AROUND EARTH WICH WAZ NEWLY MADE LOOK FOR EACH OTHER,THEY PRAID TO ALLAH S.W.T. TO LET THEM MEET AGAIN AND FINALLY AFTER YEARS ALLAH S.W.T. EXCEPTED THERE DUA AND THEY BOTH MET ONCE AGAIN ON A MOUNTAIN IN INDIA. :)

Re: Islam has Indian origin

wow..they should make a movie out of this story...

Re: Islam has Indian origin

hmmmmmm!!!!!

Re: Islam has Indian origin

[QUOTE]

Presiding over the symposium, scientist Prof Maheshwar Mishra highlighted the crisis of belief, which he said was the main problem before society.

He said, “We do not have firm belief in God. This is the root cause of our various problems.” Dr M Gyasuddin and Manuwar Husain also expressed their views. Shahbuddin coordinated the programme

[/QUOTE]

Religious nuts! The biggest problem in today's world is religion- the cause of terrorism, honour killings, stonings, homophobia.....

Re: Islam has Indian origin

Do you have anything better to do then to provoke religious people and bash religion ?
As I see it this thread is about whether the theory that Islam originated in India is a valid theory or not.
And you are bashing religion. If you want to bash religion open a new thread and you will find many people who agree or disagree with you.
You are behaving like a dog who barks at every passing car thinking this is another dog trying to invade my territory.
There are other things in the world which need attention of an intelligent person like you designed so intelligently by and intelligent being.
Do you get out of the bed every morning thinking " ok let me go to GS and use some abusive words against religion and feel good." ?
Do you have anything to say about global warming , nuclear weapons, nuclear power plants, rising prices of petroleum, deforestation, hunger , poverty , AIDS, SID, prostitution, corrupt politicians ? No ?

Re: Islam has Indian origin

[QUOTE]

You are behaving like a dog who barks at every passing car thinking this is another dog trying to invade my territory.

[/QUOTE]

LOL. I stopped reading after reading this gem. don't try to provoke me using such trivial insults- it won't work.
I think I can comment on any party of the article that has been posted here. My opinion that the main topic is the article posted here is not any less valid.

And YES, today the best thing that can happen to this world is the destruction of religion. The fellow quoted in the article claims atheism is the world's biggest problem( like we are the one's who stone ppl for dubious reasons and carry out suicide bombings). You can not expect atheists to not object.

Re: Islam has Indian origin

Since you stopped reading, this is what goes after that comment. I would request you to respond.
There are other things in the world which need attention of an intelligent person like you designed so intelligently by and intelligent being.
Do you get out of the bed every morning thinking " ok let me go to GS and use some abusive words against religion and feel good." ?
Do you have anything to say about global warming , nuclear weapons, nuclear power plants, rising prices of petroleum, deforestation, hunger , poverty , AIDS, SID, prostitution, corrupt politicians ? No ?

Re: Islam has Indian origin

:salam: Bro

You forgot the drool part.

Re: Islam has Indian origin

You must have a very narrow view of the world if you think these are the biggest problems the world is facing.

Re: Islam has Indian origin

I love indian guys. hehehehe
Evey area was part of india and every ideology has its roots in india.
India is about rap around th planet.
poor souls.:)

Re: Islam has Indian origin

Initially you said I was "close minded". Looks like you are slowly opening up my mind!

Ok...my responses to mirch...

[quote]
There are other things in the world which need attention of an intelligent person like you designed so intelligently by and intelligent being.

[/quote]

ignored...

[quote]
Do you get out of the bed every morning thinking " ok let me go to GS and use some abusive words against religion and feel good." ?

[/quote]

I spend little time here. Recently I have reduced discussing in this forum to a large extent. Anyway, nice too see even few posts of mine grab your attention.

[quote]

Do you have anything to say about global warming , nuclear weapons, nuclear power plants, rising prices of petroleum, deforestation, hunger , poverty , AIDS, SID, prostitution, corrupt politicians ? No ?

[/quote]

Not in a Religion forum. No. I prefer to stick to topic rather than derail a Religion thread with global warming, AIDS, SID, rising petroleum prices, deforestation, etc etc.

Now i have a question to you, why are you so concerned about what i feel and other about than what I write? Arguments are independent of the arguer.

Re: Islam has Indian origin

Such arguments are called Nonsense.

Re: Islam has Indian origin

You are using your brain and your fingers to post these arguments , so how can they be independent. They reflect your mindset.
I am pointing out to your mindset , not at you physical traits like , your height, weight , your looks etc.

Re: Islam has Indian origin

Salamvalekum,

Hope you are doing well. This guy has started with his whimsical comments again. Like i said earlier he is enjoying with such comments so let him enjoy.
If the world is having problems with terrorism and what all BS he has mentioned, this guy has forgotten Islam has been growing behind his backyard.

So let him do his bit to stop it probably he might find NIRVANA.:)

Re: Islam has Indian origin

:wsalam:

:slight_smile:

Re: Islam has Indian origin

Man is there anything which did NOT originate from India? These jokers should be hired by Bollywood ...maybe they'll come up with ORIGINAL scripts then and not Hollywood/Lollywood rip offs!

Re: Islam has Indian origin

Rubbish! A person's virtues/charecter does not affect the truth/falsehood of his argument.

[QUOTE]

You are using your brain and your fingers to post these arguments , so how can they be independent. They reflect your mindset.
I am pointing out to your mindset , not at you physical traits like , your height, weight , your looks etc.

[/QUOTE]

You clearly don't understand me. A logical discussion is a clash of arguments, not of people! Yes, my arguments reflect on my mindset, but my mindset doesn't matter in a debate- all that matters is my argument, not me! Maybe I should have said the validity of an argument is independent of the arguer.

Re: Islam has Indian origin

[QUOTE]

this guy has forgotten Islam has been growing behind his backyard

[/QUOTE]

So...?

Re: Islam has Indian origin

It makes him nothing less of a hypocrite when he speaks something he does not characterize himself.