kia Muslman apnay culture main Azaad hai ?
kia Islami taleemat ka culture main ammal dakhal nahi hota
ager aysa hay to phir islam zaabita-e-hyaat kaysay hoa ?
Re: Islam and Culture
jab Islaam ayaa thaa, tou kya oos ne Arab ka culture badal diya thaa (siwaaye gunah kee baaton ke) ya khud ko oos culture ka hissa banaa liya thaa?
Re: Islam and Culture
^ islam nay jin cheezon ko baaqe rakha us ko hum jaaiz or ji ko khatam ker diya un ko hum Najaaiz ya Na pasandeeda kehtay hain
sawal yeh k kia hum cultur ko islam say alag ker saktay hain ya nahi ! agar yes to phir
what is the meaning of zaabita-e-haayat >
Re: Islam and Culture
culture hai kiya? kiya kisi ilaqe ka makhsoos libaas (jo ke uske mosam ke hisab se tarveej pata hai), uska culture nahin? Islam se pehle bhi Sindh main Ajrak aam thi , aaj bhi hai. Islam ne isse mana nahin kiya ke Sindh ke log Ajrak na pehne.
waise Islam ye bhi nahin kehta ke her Muslaman Arabic bole ya Arbon wale naam rakhe.
to Islam to baRa flexible lagta hai, Muslaman itne flexible nahin lagte. wajah? kiyunke maftooh qomen hamesha apne purane fatehon se marghoob rehti hain. hamen Sikandar Yunanai aaj bhi pyara hai. Goron ki Angrezi ke bagher hum aaj bhi taraqi ka tasawwur nahin kar sakte. waise hi hum Arab culture ko apnate huwe fakhr mehsoos karte hain halanke Islam main aisa koi jabr nahin. jab deen main jabr nahin hai to jis ilaqe main wo deen pala baRha, uss ke culture ko apnane main kaisa jabr?
Re: Islam and Culture
islam culture ko khatam nahi karta, na hi culture kay khilaf hay. haan culture ki kuch batoon ko napasand zaroor kar sakta hay jesay aapnay ooper likha hay
islam main culure aur rasm-o-riwaj aur tajarbay ko bhi kuch ehmiyat haasil hay. kuch sharaee masail main hamara deen riwaj/ culture/ social status kay mutabiq amal karnay ko bhi encourage karta hay (jab tak wo deen kay mukhalif na ho)
Re: Islam and Culture
culture hai kiya? kiya kisi ilaqe ka makhsoos libaas (jo ke uske mosam ke hisab se tarveej pata hai), uska culture nahin? Islam se pehle bhi Sindh main Ajrak aam thi , aaj bhi hai. Islam ne isse mana nahin kiya ke Sindh ke log Ajrak na pehne.
waise Islam ye bhi nahin kehta ke her Muslaman Arabic bole ya Arbon wale naam rakhe.
to Islam to baRa flexible lagta hai, Muslaman itne flexible nahin lagte. wajah? kiyunke maftooh qomen hamesha apne purane fatehon se marghoob rehti hain. hamen Sikandar Yunanai aaj bhi pyara hai. Goron ki Angrezi ke bagher hum aaj bhi taraqi ka tasawwur nahin kar sakte. waise hi hum Arab culture ko apnate huwe fakhr mehsoos karte hain halanke Islam main aisa koi jabr nahin. jab deen main jabr nahin hai to jis ilaqe main wo deen pala baRha, uss ke culture ko apnane main kaisa jabr?
culture ko asaan zaban main URF kehtay hain... or ISlam main is ki ahmiyat hai bulkay sahrayee masaail main URF ka aytbaar kia jata hai
fiqaah main ik masla hay k kissi nay qasam khaaye k main ANDA (egg) nahi khaaon ga or phir us nay Chirya ya kabooter ka anda khaa liya to fuqaha-e-karam nay kaha is ki Qasam nahi tootay gee kion k URF main andha khana say muraad murghe(hen) ya Battakh (duck) ka hota hai
lakin sath main yeh bhi batya k agar Qasam khaanay wala aysay Ilaqay main rehta hay jahan chirya ya kabooter ka Anda khaaya jata hay to is AB is ki qasam toot gayeee ..Kaffara ada kerna ho ga
Look ...Culture ki kitnee ahmeyat hai ...Islam is ka layhaaz kerta hai
Mera sawal yeh hay k ISLAM humain Cultur main bhi GUIDENCE to day hee raha hay ...k humain kahan tak AZADI hay ...
phir is bat ka kia mutlub hai k hum kahain k yeh Cultur ki baat hay is main ISLAM dermiyaan main na laaao ?
bohat bareek say fark hay yahan ,,, k kia Cultur k nam per hum un cheezon ko apna saktay hain jo Islaami Ahkaamaat say mutasadim hon ..chahay us ka level makrooh ,napasandeeda hee k derjay main ho ?
Re: Islam and Culture
islam culture ko khatam nahi karta, na hi culture kay khilaf hay. haan culture ki kuch batoon ko napasand zaroor kar sakta hay jesay aapnay ooper likha hay
islam main culure aur rasm-o-riwaj aur tajarbay ko bhi kuch ehmiyat haasil hay. kuch sharaee masail main hamara deen riwaj/ culture/ social status kay mutabiq amal karnay ko bhi encourage karta hay (jab tak wo deen kay mukhalif na ho)
culture ISLAM say alag nahi ho sakta ... libas zaban rehan sehan in sub k basic Keys ISLAM day chuka hay un Asoolon per in ki shaklain to badal saktee hain lakin buniyaad to wohee rahay ge jo islam nay batayee
LIBAS > main islam ka asool Satar ka mukammal cover hona ..ab chahay koi Jubba pehnay ya qameez shalwar ya pant shirt lakin ASOOL to wohe rahay ga kay sattar dhanpa ho ..koi cultur k Nam per is main kammi nahi ker sakta
SHADI > islam ka asool ijaab quboool do gawah..... ab koi 4 logoo main baith ker nikah keray ya marraige Lawn main ..lakin ASOOL k sath
KHANA PEENA > HALAL MEAT ho ab koi shorba banayee ya Brbq ya roast ...Asool ik hay HALAL ho
Cultur jin jin cheezon ka naam hay us ki Buniyad ISLAM k Asool kay sath Attach hona Zaroore hai
or yaheen say mera sawal paida hota hai ..K is bat ka kia matlub reh jata hai ..yeh Culture ki bat hay MAZHAB ki nahi ?
Re: Islam and Culture
I think this reply 'ye Culture ki baat hai mazhab ko beech main na lao' comes when someones tries to term different customs (mostly neutral ones) as unislamic. Like celebrating 'Basant' wearing yellow, flying kites, cooking some meetha, etc, how come this goes against Islam which lead to taggg Basant as unIslamic?
Re: Islam and Culture
culture ISLAM say alag nahi ho sakta ... libas zaban rehan sehan in sub k basic Keys ISLAM day chuka hay un Asoolon per in ki shaklain to badal saktee hain lakin buniyaad to wohee rahay ge jo islam nay batayee
LIBAS > main islam ka asool Satar ka mukammal cover hona ..ab chahay koi Jubba pehnay ya qameez shalwar ya pant shirt lakin ASOOL to wohe rahay ga kay sattar dhanpa ho ..koi cultur k Nam per is main kammi nahi ker sakta
SHADI > islam ka asool ijaab quboool do gawah..... ab koi 4 logoo main baith ker nikah keray ya marraige Lawn main ..lakin ASOOL k sath
KHANA PEENA > HALAL MEAT ho ab koi shorba banayee ya Brbq ya roast ...Asool ik hay HALAL ho
Cultur jin jin cheezon ka naam hay us ki Buniyad ISLAM k Asool kay sath Attach hona Zaroore hai
or yaheen say mera sawal paida hota hai ..K is bat ka kia matlub reh jata hai ..yeh Culture ki bat hay MAZHAB ki nahi ?
you have explained what i wanted to write. is sawal ka koi background? is it what muqawwee123 mentioned above (below?)
I think this reply 'ye Culture ki baat hai mazhab ko beech main na lao' comes when someones tries to term different customs (mostly neutral ones) as unislamic. Like celebrating 'Basant' wearing yellow, flying kites, cooking some meetha, etc, how come this goes against Islam which lead to taggg Basant as unIslamic?
objection yellow pehennay, patang uranay aur meetha pakanay par nahi hoti. objection un deegar kharafaat par hoti hay jo kuch khaas moqoon par khaas cheezon kay sath juRi hoti hain.
Re: Islam and Culture
I think this reply 'ye Culture ki baat hai mazhab ko beech main na lao' comes when someones tries to term different customs (mostly neutral ones) as unislamic. Like celebrating 'Basant' wearing yellow, flying kites, cooking some meetha, etc, how come this goes against Islam which lead to taggg Basant as unIslamic?
her woh kaam jis main ibadat ya sawab ki neyat na ho us main hum Mazhab ko hata daytay hain or cultur ya waqt ki zaroorat k nam per apna laytay hain ... agercha bazahir us say ap ko koi Nuqsaan bhi nazar na ayee
for example...makhloot mahfil ( mix gathring ) is ko kitnay log DIL say ghalat samjhtay hon gay ?
you have explained what i wanted to write. is sawal ka koi background? is it what muqawwee123 mentioned above (below?)
objection yellow pehennay, patang uranay aur meetha pakanay par nahi hoti. objection un deegar kharafaat par hoti hay jo kuch khaas moqoon par khaas cheezon kay sath juRi hoti hain.
back ground yehee comment hain k yeh mazhab ki bat nahi cultur ki bat hai
mujhay yeh bat samjh nahi aate k mazhab to humain qabar tak k ahkaam bata raha hai bhala yeh kaysay mumkin hai k hum kisi cheez main yeh keh dain yeh mazhab ki bat nahi ?
Re: Islam and Culture
I quote 'ye sab deen se doori ki waja se hai'. Hazrat KKF AligaRh University.. San 1834
Re: Islam and Culture
I quote 'ye sab deen se doori ki waja se hai'. Hazrat KKF AligaRh University.. San 1834
app is bat ko mantay hain yeh comment ghalat hay ?
Re: Islam and Culture
app is bat ko mantay hain yeh comment ghalat hay ?
main ye mta hoon ke koi bhi comment 100% sahi ya ghalat nahin hota.maine iss comment ko boht jaga use hote dekha.. sahi bhi aur ghalat bhi
Re: Islam and Culture
main ye mta hoon ke koi bhi comment 100% sahi ya ghalat nahin hota.maine iss comment ko boht jaga use hote dekha.. sahi bhi aur ghalat bhi
yeh comment ko us moqa per hota hay jub ik fareeq dosray fareeq ko kahay k islam is cheez ko appreciate nahi kerta
to fareeq-e-mukhalif kahta hay yeh mazhab ki bat nahi
baat ghoom phir ker wahee agyee na ...k ISlam jub qaymat tak k ley hey or zaabita-e-hayaat hay to her her cheez main is ka ammal dakhal ho ga
koi yeh kahay k mazhab is bat ko mana nahi kerta app ki daleel ghalat hay ...woh or point hai
lakin yeh kehna k is cheez ka taluq mazhab say nahi ...yeh comment sahi moqa per sahi ho sakta hai ?
Re: Islam and Culture
her woh kaam jis main ibadat ya sawab ki neyat na ho us main hum Mazhab ko hata daytay hain or cultur ya waqt ki zaroorat k nam per apna laytay hain ... agercha bazahir us say ap ko koi Nuqsaan bhi nazar na ayee
for example...makhloot mahfil ( mix gathring ) is ko kitnay log DIL say ghalat samjhtay hon gay ?
back ground yehee comment hain k yeh mazhab ki bat nahi cultur ki bat hai
mujhay yeh bat samjh nahi aate k mazhab to humain qabar tak k ahkaam bata raha hai bhala yeh kaysay mumkin hai k hum kisi cheez main yeh keh dain yeh mazhab ki bat nahi ?
yeh comment ko us moqa per hota hay jub ik fareeq dosray fareeq ko kahay k islam is cheez ko appreciate nahi kerta
to fareeq-e-mukhalif kahta hay yeh mazhab ki bat nahi
baat ghoom phir ker wahee agyee na ...k ISlam jub qaymat tak k ley hey or zaabita-e-hayaat hay to her her cheez main is ka ammal dakhal ho ga
koi yeh kahay k mazhab is bat ko mana nahi kerta app ki daleel ghalat hay ...woh or point hai
lakin yeh kehna k is cheez ka taluq mazhab say nahi ...yeh comment sahi moqa per sahi ho sakta hai ?
is qisam kay moqay par ye keh dena k ye mazhab ki bat nahi culture ki hay, ya "is baat main mazhab ko mat lao" esa hi hay k "main is maamlay main mazhab ko nahi manta/ti" is say zyada to shaid kuch nahi kaha ja sakta, rawaiyon ki bat hay.
taqareer aur tahareer main to sab yehi kehtay/likhtay hain k "islam aik mukammal zabta-e-hayaat hay".
Re: Islam and Culture
@P_G kiya app aesi tamam cultural practices bata sakti hian jo Islam kay manafi hian?
Re: Islam and Culture
nahi mai un sub ko cover nahi ker saktee … bat sirf itnee see maloom kernee hai k mazhab kissi muamlay main juda ho sakta hay ya nahi !