Is wife beating against the quran?

[Mughal1]

Re: Is wife beating against the quran?

@Jolie

Pardon my ignorance guys, but I’ve heard that Hazrat Aisha used to play with dolls even after her marraige to Prophet pbuh. And I reckon its not very usual for 19 year olds to play with the dolls? I’m not asking for hadiths to varify Hazrat Aisha’s age, I’ve read Hareem’s post, just want to ask how valid is the incident of Hazrat Aisha playing with the dolls and what does it ultimately suggests about her age?

Thank you dear Jolie, as for the hadith reports I have already explained the rule, so if there is no other explanation of the report you are refering to then it is probably problematic. I need to see the full report before I could comment on it but dolls on their own do not necesarily prove young age of the player with them It depends on the purpose eg in kids nurseries usually such adults are employed who like playing with kids because they love kids. It is possible that the said wife of the prophet was such a person so she got some dolls for kids so that they come and play with her and may be learn some things from her as well. It is nature of people that when they do not have kids of their own they especially love kids of other folks. Since the prophet had kids but some of his wives did not so that may explain the extra attention kids will get from these ladies. May be thers is some other explanation as well of which I am not aware. I too am here to learn of others. It is a mutual exercise.

But thanks again for raising the question may be some one knows some hadith that explains such like ahadith. Regardless the rules must always be kept in mind when studying the quran or ahadith otherwise things can become very confusing. There is a rule that for ahkaam=commandments and directives very solid and clear hadith are used not the ones that cannot be understood or explained in light of accepted common sense rules.

regards and all the best.