Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

i came across this question in sistani’s web site about blood transfusion

http://www.sistani.org/html/eng/menu/4/?lang=eng&view=d&code=165&page=1

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

and answer to that question was:

There is no Ishkaal (objection) in it.

So??????

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

i found it funny since blood banks in hospitals go by blood groups not by race/religen.

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

rvikz, people like to ask questions when unsure about something in particular. There's no harm in it. Besides, Anwaar has already posted the answer for your clarity.

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

You can get a blood transfusion from anyone, and you can provide it to anyone, as long as your A-B-O blood groups match, and there is no infection in the blood, and other medical guidelines.

Race and religion are not factors, in medicine, nor in Islam.

We muslims don't have this silly notion in our head that there is something materially different and unique about a muslim's blood. Its pind mentality.

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

the Untouchable concept exists in Hinduism, not Islam. What a pathetic mentality to even think this.

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

In my understanding, certain issues do arise.....

1) This kind of transfusion depends solely upon the petient preference. If the patient or the surrogate decision maker wants it, it can be undertaken. If the patient denies it, NO MATTER WHAT, it cannot be done, be it a reason of Muslim-nonMuslim's blood.

2) It also depends upon the urgency of the need. How urgently a particular type of blood is needed.

3) Using the common sense, now a days when there are multiple donor centers, and knowledge of the blood groups and donor registry and so on, what do you think how often this situation would arise? In my understanding, it is one of those exceptionally rare circumstance we are talking about. There are so many options that exist today in the field of blood banking that make this issue totally irrelevant.

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu’s blood to our body permissible?

Question : If blood is seen in the yolk or the white part of the egg, does it make the egg impure and haram for us? Is there a solution for it?

§ Answer : The clot of blood inside the egg is pure, but it is haram [for consumption]. Therefore, the egg can be eaten by removing the blood from it, provided it not very minute and been absorbed in it. [In the latter case, is not removable, then the egg becomes haram.]

Where do eggs have blood in em??? :konfused:

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

Lahore981, you yourself mentioned how your last point was sort of off-topic. Therefore, I removed it and I also removed all the corresponding responses.

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

^ No problem. You are intellegent to ignore the useless comment. :)

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu’s blood to our body permissible?

This is a contradiction. The only reason these cases would be exceptionally rare (especially in a diverse society) is if a Muslim specifically requests blood from another Muslim. Otherwise it is left up to chance. So while you indicate it may be permissable, you imply it is not reccomended. Same thing really.

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

^ I don't know which society this question pertains to. If you live in a DIVERSE society, as you said, the situation would be different. If you live in not a diverse society, the situation would be different (I undersand you mean here by Muslim and non-muslim society)

Let me open this up a little for you. This situation is not rare in the manner you wrote here. There are many situations that can arise. In clinical practice, any scenerio is not limited to one dimension.

1) It is possible that a Muslims shows NO PREFERENCE

2) It is possible that a Muslims REFUSES a blood transfusion from a non-Muslim

3) It is possible that a Muslim ACCEPTS a transfusion from a non-Muslim.

4) It is possible that the wishes os a Muslim are NOT KNOWN.

5) Usually, the transfusion issues are discussed in advanced with the patient and the need of blood transusion in todays time is not a common occurance as it used to be in the past (Relatively)

Each situation is dealt in its own way. Now my point is that how often the blood of a Hindu would be needed? How often such situation would arise that there is no way out except a Hindu's blood?

Advanced donory registry. Yeah, we already know of the blood groups of millions of blood donors already. And it also depends upon what the blood group is and how rare it is?

--------- At the time of draught when you don't have anything else to quench your thurst, even Wine is allowed? What do you talk of in terms of yes or no.

My whole point was about "PROBABILITY" :) and not "EXCEPTION"

You tell me what is the probability of a Muslim to specifically request a Hindu blood???????????? And refuse a Muslim blood??????????

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu’s blood to our body permissible?

I hope I have not created confusion for anyone :frowning:

Good question. Here is the answer in a short and easy manner for you.

There are cells in the egg that are called Pleuripotent Stem Cells. They are the most primitive cells that start dividing and “differrentiating” towards different body tissues. Some differentiate to form bones, some muscle, some blood etc. At this stage the cell are called “committed” stem cells.

What you see as blood is derived form the further expansion and division of these cells into hematopoietic (Blood forming) elements and the development of hemoglobin in them…

I hope this answers your question Sara516 ji…

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu’s blood to our body permissible?

You tell me, what is the probability of requesting the religion of the donor since it would never even enter my mind. Do they automatically match the religion of the donor and recipient?

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu’s blood to our body permissible?

What is the probability that you will be told by responsible medical staff…“hey here is muslim blood, and you’re muslim - would you prefer this muslim blood?”

:rolleyes:

This topic is going to go unnecessarily to 10 pages, resulting in everyone saying essentially the same thing in different words.

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu’s blood to our body permissible?

The whole world does not think like YOU think. And not everybody holds the same opinion as you.
Come to some constructive argument rather than argument for the sake of argument.
You belive that a non-muslim blood can be given to a muslim and you want to prove it right and project as if it is the rule and happens everywhere.
I am saying something different that you did not understand. Still you want to oppose me. Go ahead, bang your head in the wall.

What are you trying to say? Jahil, this is not the way anyone would ask. If this is what you think, I am talking among fools who just want to oppose for something that is above their comprehension.
Doing the same thing again. Trying to prove your point and refuting the other just to project yourself more important and more knowledgable without any idea of what I said.
About you, I’d only say, “Usless to make argumentds with a stupid and jahil person” You have a problem, an attitude problem as I said earlier many times. This is not your fault, this is the fault of the culture where you have been brought up, which teaches being “Moun Phat” and “Big mouthing”

Over and out…

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

Did you just call someone jaahil?

Shows how jaahil you really are.

The initial poster's question has been answered, and much of what you're saying is nothing more than rambling.

People don't enter a hospital and ask "hey, I'm muslim, I'd like muslim-only blood", and nor do hospitals offer blood categorized by religion. From what I remember, no one ever asked me my religion when taking my blood. I dont know of any place that really does, unless you care to enlighten us on specific examples.

If you can't, then much of what you say is mere speculation.

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

^ funny but fussy !

Lahore bhai jaan i agree to the part says UR POST WAS NOTHING BUT SOME XTRA INFORMATION AND LITERELLY HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THE TOPIC but sure was some USE-FUL knowledge .. thnx for sharing!

actually there is a religion cant remember the name who never do blood transfusions, no matter if the patient dies in need. and like LAHORI bhai said its true u got every right to refuse ur medicals .. all you have to do is sign an A-M-A paper !

p/s: yesss ! now everybody can die in peace after knowing PCG donated blood :p jots it down as some use-full info

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

So a Kafir is Haram to you, not his blood?

Re: Is transfusion of Hindu's blood to our body permissible?

and what about the other way round..
Would a muslim knowingly donate blood to a kafir....
Or to make the question more general..
Does a muslim donate blood...Coz you can never be sure if the bloood is going to a muslim or not ???