Re: Is this true?
Brother ZeeshanParvez
I’ve searched and searched and keep finding prohibition on mudaari’ with jussive verbs and references to negation is prevalent when the mudaari’ is mutaharrik. Both Volume 2 and Madinah book 3 say this … I understand that in various Sharh books they may “interpret” the above to prohibition but that would be interpretation and not translation.
Like I can say … “It is not from Islam to get angry quickly and remain like that” and I could interpret that to “We should not get angry quickly and remain in that state if we do” … But by translation the meaning is open for other understandings.
Certainly the Hadith being weak cannot be a criterion for ruling in Aqeedah and secondly until you show otherwise I don’t even read it’s direct translation as prohibition anyway
Read below we will discuss weak Hadith for Aqeedah and related issues later. The above shows you have not read ANY of the references I gave you. Now we shall go through them one by one!
