Is this even allowed in Islam??

[redvelvet]

Re: Is this even allowed in Islam??

@Harappan

Well if the Saudis and other mid east countries permit it, that means they believe Islam allows it(according to their interpretations), so I guess views vary from various schools of thoughts; many Gulf arab states and Iran even allow contract marriages, and there is even a halal brothel in europe.

I don’t know if it’s right, but I can’t say it’s wrong because there’s a lot about Islam i don’t know; I’ve read that during the Prophet’s time, concubines were common and were permitted, and an Islamist friend of mine believed it was true.

Anyways, humans are sexual creatures and they will find a way to screw around, if it’s halal it’s better.

In more stricter Arab countries, many vices take place under cover. In others, it’s more open. Neither of the two necessarily mean that the actions are allowed in Islam. You look at references in Islam to determine the validity of the actions. What you’ve assumed is a simplified approach that leads to the development of stereotypes.

And before you decide to use my former post as a contradiction, let me clarify that the average Muslim is fully aware of the basic rulings on zina and what kinds of relationships are halal/haram, so basic knowledge is enough to conclude that what the OP has enquired about isn’t halal; deep research isn’t required.