Is this allowed in Islam!!!

Indian Shias rest in hope
By Ram Dutt Tripathi
BBC correspondent in Lucknow

**Iftkhar Fatima’s body has been lying in the northern Indian city of Lucknow, waiting for burial for the past 12 years. **

It was her last wish to be buried in the Iraqi holy city of Karbala - like many Shia Muslims around the world.

But the situation in Iraq prevented her final wish being fulfilled.

**So Fatima continues to lies in state, preserved in chemicals and stored in a steel trunk at the Karbala Malika Jahan graveyard in Lucknow. **

But with the fall and capture of Saddam Hussein, she may yet find the final resting place of her choice.

Family tradition

Her son, Maulana Hameedul Hasan, a prominent Shia Muslim clergyman in Lucknow, says it has been a tradition in his mother’s family to bury their dead in Iraq’s holy twin cities of Karbala and Najaf.

“My mother made a will that her body should be taken to the holy city for burial. Her father and mother made similar wills and their bodies were taken to Iraq for burial,” Maulana Hasan told BBC News Online.

“But the burial of my mother has been delayed. Every time I made an effort, I found that the situation in Iraq was not conducive.”

Najaf and Karbala, located deep in the Shia heartland of southern Iraq, traditionally opposed the Saddam Hussain-led Baathist rulers in Baghdad.

For years, the annual pilgrimage by Shia Muslims to these holy cities was banned.

Nobody is sure how many such bodies are waiting for their final journey to Iraq.

Some 300,000 residents of Lucknow, a city of three million people, are Shia Muslims.

**Mohammed Khalil, a caretaker at the graveyard where Iftkhar Fatima’s body is stored, says he knows of other bodies awaiting burial in Karbala and Najaf. **

Other caretakers at other graveyards in Lucknow say the same thing.

**Mr Khalil says one body at his graveyard was stored in a trunk for years, before the family buried it in Lucknow after giving up hope. **

Maulana Hameedul Hasan recalls taking the body of one of his relatives to Karbala for burial in 1954.

**He remembered that the authorities there had built multi-storey graveyards to accommodate bodies from all over the world. **

Hopes rise

Things have improved now for Iraq’s Shia Muslims.

Last year thousands of them performed one of their key rituals for the first time in nearly 30 years - the pilgrimage to the great Shia martyr Imam Hussein bin Ali’s shrine in Karbala, 80 kilometres (50 miles) south of Baghdad.

A grandson of the Prophet Muhammad, Imam Hussein died 1,323 years ago and was thus denied the leadership of Muslims that Shia believe was his right.

The return of religious freedom in Iraq gives some hope to Maulana Hasan that his mother’s last wish will be fulfilled.

He says he contacted a Delhi-based travel agency to arrange for the body to be airlifted to Iraq, and was told to wait a while.

“I will make fresh efforts after the holy month of Muharram, and Inshallah [God willing] I will be able to perform my mother’s last rites in the holy city,” says Maulana Hasan.

pic of “The Karbala Malika Jahan graveyard in Lucknow”

I think prompt burial of the deceased should be the first priority. Otherwise it is a "behurmati" of the body.

Wallah o Aalim

Agree Faisal but talking in terms of religion.... I always thought both the Sunnys and Shias usually bury their deads the place they die but to chemically perserve loved ones in order to bury them some where else.. never heard of this before.

Allah Ke Waste Islam ko grave worshippers ka Madhab na
banoyoo.What is the point of giving the picture of Kabrs.

Tauba.

I know a lot of people make arrangement for the dead bodies to be buried at a place different than where they have died. For example, expat Pakistanis try to fly the bodies of their parents back to Pakistan to be buried in ancestoral graveyards etc. But this has to be reasonable. To hold a body for 12 years, is quite excessive, IMO.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Faisal: *
I know a lot of people make arrangement for the dead bodies to be buried at a place different than where they have died. For example, expat Pakistanis try to fly the bodies of their parents back to Pakistan to be buried in ancestoral graveyards etc. But this has to be reasonable.

[/QUOTE]

Agree

It is not allowed in islam...

aqeedat ki bhi had honi chaheye.........mohabbat ki bhi had honi chaheye......

and that goes for all....

yeah.

i doubt she consulted with an aalim on that one.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by ravage: *
yeah.

i doubt she consulted with an aalim on that one.
[/QUOTE]

Seems her son is one. And he's planning on taking her body there....

it doesn't even look as though there's really much religious motivation behind it.. the article suggests that she only wanted it done cos it's her family tradition....

It seems some muslims in India (also Pak) have very ignorant perspective. If you are buried in the Ka'ba itself, it will not help if our Amaal are not correct.
We don't hear of Irani shias storing bodies to bury in Karbala, or Arabs doing so to bury in Haram shareef ...
I have also found North indians (same in Pakistan) to be more in conflict - i mean Shia-Sunni friction. This has been nothing but politics since the beginning. Use divisive racist tactics to incite people and use them.