I always wonder if it’s allowed(not gunah) to commit suicide if you have no other way out like if someone’s getting raped and she kills herself somehow before that, will she still die a haram death and will go straight to hell? Maybe there comes a time where you have no other way out but to take your life away. Plus if our death is already written by Allah(even the people who commit suicide) then why are they going to hell and the ones shaheed are going straight to jannah? A person who dies as a “shaheed” and a person who commits “suicide” both have to die at that time because their death is already written by Allah and they can’t do nothing about it. It’s so confusing!
Re: is suicide allowed if you have no other way?
Basis of human knowledge is aqal so people must use it or they will keep making fools of themselves.
Re: is suicide allowed if you have no other way?
I always wonder if it's allowed(not gunah) to commit suicide if you have no other way out like if someone's getting raped and she kills herself somehow before that, will she still die a haram death and will go straight to hell? Maybe there comes a time where you have no other way out but to take your life away. Plus if our death is already written by Allah(even the people who commit suicide) then why are they going to hell and the ones shaheed are going straight to jannah? A person who dies as a "shaheed" and a person who commits "suicide" both have to die at that time because their death is already written by Allah and they can't do nothing about it. It's so confusing!
Peace ParizayBabz,
Seen similar topics in other threads too. However, answer is not straight-forward same as the question. To know the core of cause, we need to know/discuss each and every single points from beginning till coming to the end i.e., to the decision of suicide.
Let me explain by giving an example: "Suppose today, at Maghrib time, I heard 'Adhaan'. I have choice either I go to the Masjid and offer Maghrib Salaat, or continue doing what I was doing and neglect the Salaat.
If I offered the Salaat then I obeyed Almighty Allah's order and if I don't, then whom I'm going to blame? Should I blame Almighty Allah that HE didn't wanted to me to go and offer Maghrib Salaat? and because HE already written this in my destiny?
Simple answer is 'No' we can't, we can't blame Almighty Allah, we have to blame ourselves because we didn't obeyed HIS order and due to whispering / misguidance from Shaitan (Ibless), we didn't offered Maghrib Salaath.
Almighty Allah is all knowing and HE knows about future of all of us. HE knows that on so and so date and during Maghrib time, my servant (mean i'm) have a choice either to offer Salaath or not and HE also knows that either I'm going to offer Salaat or not, So it is already written in my destiny, that on so and so date and time, I'm going to this or that, and that is why it is already written as being All Knowing.
Re: is suicide allowed if you have no other way?
Plus if our death is already written by Allah(even the people who commit suicide) then why are they going to hell and the ones shaheed are going straight to jannah? A person who dies as a "shaheed" and a person who commits "suicide" both have to die at that time because their death is already written by Allah and they can't do nothing about it.
good question.
Re: is suicide allowed if you have no other way?
Exactly just like I said once if Allah is taking azmaishay then what is the fault of that person who got raped & that person who did the rape ? ….. just because Allah wanted to take an exam from someone hence that girl got raped (her azmaish is rape which is zulm but … anyways ) & that person will get a punishment for doing the rape? .......why ? .....
Re: is suicide allowed if you have no other way?
Peace unknownnn,
Please inform us 'where it is written that Almighty Allah is taking azmaishay'?