Is playing a guitar really unislamic?

Re: Is playing a guitar really unislamic?

Some people here are oozing of typical desi-ness by acting like they're the national Saudi mufti just to find a piece of evidence (regardless how authentic) to suit to their likes; I will just say what I know. It is very obvious that any kind of music that promotes a negative message (rap and metal fans, caution) is not allowed. Others say that any kind of music is not allowed, and a commonly quoted hadith is:

[quote]
Sayyiduna Abu Malik al-Ash’ari (Allah be pleased with him) reports that he heard the Messenger of Allah (Allah bless him & give him peace) say: “There will appear people in my Ummah, who will hold adultery, silk, alcohol and musical instruments to be lawful” (Sahih al-Bukhari)
[/quote]

Take notice of the "and" in there, it might have some importance; musical instruments that are used in any of these combinations are haram. And let me bring up some practical examples: there's almost always music playing in bars, silky dresses are the most popular with dancers (who bare body), and no brothel is complete without music. And please make sure that the transmission chain of any hadiths posted in here is strong and authentic.

Another case is where music becomes an addiction, and drives you away from priorities (religion included). I know of such a case in Dubai, where a young man was driving his car and had music playing (he was very likely an addict), and had a horrible accident. The police deemed his condition to be severe and asked him to say the shahadah; instead, swear words and song lyrics came out of his mouth, that was scary. Unlike many others here, I won't conclude whether music is actually allowed or not, although it is always best to stay away from what is suspicious.