Is playing a guitar really unislamic?

[Dr_Sufi]

Re: Is playing a guitar really unislamic?

@khanbabax

Brother just common sense, Prophet s.a.w have used all 4 things in one sentence, adultry, wine, silk and musical instruments. How can you seperate one from the other 3? Its clear that all 4 are haram and Prophet s.a.w is saying people will make these things permissible near Qiyamat. So if they will make these things permissible, what does that mean? Means they were not considered permissible before.

Dear Brother,
Apart from common sense, please also try to find som relativity. If your point is considered to be valid, then how come Silk is Hallal for women and Haram for men?

@khanbabax

At that time there were no laws regarding these things, even alcohol was halal. Music was prohibbited later on like alcohol and other things.

Yes I admit and agree that Intoxicants, gambling, dedication of stones and divination by arrows was made Haram vide verse 93 of Surah-e-Almaida but where is the Hurmat of Music in Quran. Regarding Ahadith, the evidence can be tilted according to ones liking, but still, there is no Muttafiq Alleh hadith declaring music to be Haram.

@khanbabax

They were preparing for a war, as far as I remember.

Agreed! That is what I was saying i.e., Relativity!

@khanbabax

http://www.daruliftaa.com/question.asp?txt_QuestionID=q-12513589
A detailed answer.

What about the Fatawas stating it be otherwise?

Wassalam.