is music haraam in islam???as far as i noe it is haaram…but thn y dont ppl avoid it??..every1 noes tht it is haraam rite???someone once also told me tht Hazroor :saw: used 2 have some kind of instrument for music…is tht really true???
plz clear my doubts regardin this…thank you..
You get scholars who say it’s haraam, and you get scholars who say it’s not haraam.
Those scholars who say it’s haraam point to certain hadiths that exist, and those scholars who say it’s not haraam question the authenticity of those hadiths.
Try this link for a more detailed explanation of the disagreement amongst scholars:
http://www.islamonline.net/fatwa/english/FatwaDisplay.asp?hFatwaID=40116
prophet :saw: were said to have said musical instruments r haraam, music is made with instruments so yeah althought not directly stated it’s believed to be haram.
Rasulullah :saw: said,
There will be a nation from my Ummah who will make music their lot one day while enjoying their music and alcohol they will awake with their faces transformed into swine. In fact, Rasulullah :saw: said,
I was sent to destroy all musical instruments.
^ yea so tht means it is haraam.....but still muslims seem 2 enjoy music as if nothin is wrong w/ it..infact muslim countries themselves r promotin it and no1 seems 2 b doing anythin 2 stop it...
Why are you judging Islam by the actions of some Muslims? There is no real Islamic country out there so whatever they do shouldn't suprise us.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by pardesi kuri: *
^ yea so tht means it is haraam.....but still muslims seem 2 enjoy music as if nothin is wrong w/ it..infact muslim countries themselves r promotin it and no1 seems 2 b doing anythin 2 stop it...
[/QUOTE]
In most Muslim countries the scholars responsible for determining what the government should ban and what it should permit tend to follow the opinions that question either the authenticity of those hadiths or question the way they have been interpreted.
That is why, for instance, countries like Saudia Arabia consider pornographic magazines as being illegal contraband, but take no action against music cds or tapes.
^ right said maggy…!
Here is another link which talks about it being haraam or not…!
Everything u ask, including the instrument, Prophet Muhammad (SAWW) permitted has been answered here.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by mAd_ScIeNtIsT: *
In most Muslim countries the scholars responsible for determining what the government should ban and what it should permit tend to follow the opinions that question either the authenticity of those hadiths or question the way they have been interpreted.
That is why, for instance, countries like Saudia Arabia consider pornographic magazines as being illegal contraband, but take no action against music cds or tapes.
[/QUOTE]
yea ur rite about tht....i live in saudia..and its like nothin is wrong w/ music here...i mean even the saudis have music blarin out of their cars...so yea it figures...
thnx 4 the link malik…it really helped…
ur welcome dear
mal1k even from that link u provided i conclude it's haram, y did u say "it is haram or NOT!" ????
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by #let uz chat#: *
mal1k even from that link u provided i conclude it's haram, y did u say "it is haram or NOT!" ????
[/QUOTE]
my dear friend......
I didnt question da thread, & neither da user who posted this thread...read carefully, if u didnt, here Im posting it again
Here is another link which talks about it being haraam or not...!
& there is an Xclamation mark at da end not a question mark...!
i seek ur pardon bhai' mistake acknowledged