Is it blasphemous?

Arts & Culture Poetry ( Intikhaab & Sho'ra-e-Gupshup)
41

Re: Is it blasphemous?

It all depends how 'buton' is taken..

42

Re: Is it blasphemous?

nope, may chahta hon aap khud is ko explain karain....every body has done 60K+ posts so they should understand poetry....

baki jaisay ishq haqeeqi bhi hota hai or mijazi bhi, aisay he shairi k maani zahir bhi hotay hain or chupay howay bhi.... :)

43

Re: Is it blasphemous?

karain aap is ki explanation :)

44

Re: Is it blasphemous?

lols. 60K is not from Poetry. :)

Its not about hidden meanings if you know the life styles of poets. The question also arises that when poets write for masses, why they use language which create confusion in the mind of readers. This particular shair can be referred / used by a communist / atheist in his conversation, but a religious person won't openly use it to create confusion and attract fatwas of Kufr.

45

Re: Is it blasphemous?

If 'but' is considered as 'Adam' then its ok, God loves human beings, so following Him in loving fellow Human-beings is a good virtue, but if 'but' is taken as 'idols' then its misleading.

46

Re: Is it blasphemous?

surface explanation is correct, still a very deep meaning is waiting inside this shair...

47

Re: Is it blasphemous?

it is because in schools urdu is not properly taught

48

Re: Is it blasphemous?

do the needful. jo bole wohi kundi khole :hehe:

49

Re: Is it blasphemous?

yaar i want you to go inside pay your ownself…is shair ki explanation may even apnay bhai ko bhi bari mushkilo say samjha paya tha, coz i think yeh woo chez hai jisay insan khud samjhay tu us ki ankhain bheeg jayien…give it a try, think think all night all day and you will come to know what a master piece these two lines are…

50

Re: Is it blasphemous?

aap ne apne bhai ko jo samjhaya uski summary / hints den. I already tried my level best :p

51

Re: Is it blasphemous?

:fatee:

52

Re: Is it blasphemous?

:eek: yani saaf chupte bhi nahin, samne aate bhi nahin

53

Re: Is it blasphemous?

hmmmmm :slight_smile:

54

Re: Is it blasphemous?

I never learnt Urdu.Ab tou aap mujhe explain kr sakte hain without expecting me to ans myself :@:

I would really want to know the deep meanings behind these asha'ars which seem kufriya at a glance.

55

Re: Is it blasphemous?

ok, jo tumay samjh aye hai woo explain karoo pehlay...

56

Re: Is it blasphemous?

:no:

57

Re: Is it blasphemous?

jo bhi chahay bachon ki tarhan explain kar doo…jaisay what is bekaar meaning..one kid say a man without car…pehlay step uthaoo

58

Re: Is it blasphemous?

I have another one, its even more challenging

Nikaal de mujhe apni khudai se bahar
khata muaaf k ye kaam teray bus ka nahi

59

Re: Is it blasphemous?

now let cutenice62 explain how its not blasphemous :chai:

60

Re: Is it blasphemous?

yeh tu shair apnay mahboob ko keh raaha hai…Khuda ko thori keh raha hai… :smokin: