Is Hinduism monotheistic at its heart?

I was reading through an earlier thread and found this reply from a hindu. What do you guys say about it and also if somebody does believe that Hinduism is monotheistic at its heart, what are your opinions about the other sub-gods worshipped by various sects?

At its heart, Hinduism is also monotheistic. Unfortunately, a large part of the Hindu scriptures is written in parables (without any warning that it is a parable). When a “normal” person reads the scriptures, they tend to take them literally, and that tends to cause a lot of confusion. However, when a truly wise and intuitive person reads the same, they are able to discern the true meaning.

ps. source of the thread is not required as it is a personal opinion of a guppie.

Galaxy,

You are showing a profound understanding of the issue. Yes I was brought up as a Hindu but there was no doubt in minds of my parents that there is ultimately only one God. We thought of other deities somwhat similar to Sufi Pirs. In fact we worshipped Sufi Pirs also for intevention on our behalf as we considered them closer to God than us imperfects.

Galaxy,

As another example of what I am saying, this story is well-known in classical music circles in India altho I cannot vouch for its truth. When Ustad Bismillah Khan who was a devout muslim, did his riyaz in Benaras (Kashi) one morning at 4:00 am while he was playing raag Shankara, he played it with such devotion, that Balaji himself (another name for Shankara) appeared in front of him and commanded him to do his riyaz in Balaji's temple. It is clear to me (whether this story is true or not) that God shows himself in any form in which you worship him. It just depends on how profound is your devotion.

This is by David Frawley …

If you have ever wondered, if Hindus worship one God or many Gods, why do Hindus worship images and icons, why does the God in Hindu dharma have multiple names and multiple forms of God, then this is the where, we hope, you will find answers. Dr. David Frawley has answered many of these commonly asked questions quite succinctly. For example,

Why Do Hindus Worship Many Gods?

Human beings through history have formulated many different names and forms for the Divine or Eternal. Just as we have many names and forms for other things, whether it is foods, or types of art, so too, in religion a similar great diversity has been created.

The Western world has prided itself in monotheism, the idea that there is only One God as the highest truth. Western religions have said that only the names and forms which refer to this One God are valid but those which appear to worship another God, or a multiplicity of divinities, must be false. They have restricted the names and forms they use in religious worship, and insist that only one set is true and correct and others are wrong or unholy.

As a universal formulation Hinduism accepts all formulations of Truth. According to the universal view there is only One Reality, but it cannot be limit ed to a particular name or form. Though Truth is One it is also Universal, not an exclusive formulation. It is an inclusive, not an exclusive Oneness - a spiritual reality of Being - Consciousness - Bliss, which could be called God but which transcends all names. The different Gods and Goddesses of Hinduism represent various functions of this One Supreme Divinity, and are not separate Gods.

Having many names for something is not necessarily a sign of ignorance of its real nature. On the contrary, it may indicate an intimate knowledge of it. For example, Eskimos have forty-eight different names for snow in their language because they know snow intimately in its different variations, not because they are ignorant of the fact that all snow is only one. The many different deities of Hinduism reflect such an intimate realization of the Divine on various levels.

Or, Why Does Hinduism Portray God as a Woman?

Hinduism contains many feminine forms of the Divine like Kali, Durga, Lakshmi and Sarasvati. These represent different feminine qualities and functions of the Divine which contains both male and female energies. For example, Kali portrays the destructive energy, Lakshmi the nourishing, and Sarasvati the creative, while Durga is the Divine Mother in her protective role. Hinduism also has many dual male-female forms like Radha-Krishna, Sita-Rama, Uma-Mahesh, and Lakshmi -Narayan in which the female form is usually addressed first. The different masculine forms of the Divine in Hinduism have their feminine counterparts.

As Sanatana Dharma or a universal tradition Hinduism recognizes that the Divine contains both masculine and feminine attributes. Without giving proper honor to the feminine qualities a religion must be incomplete and one-sided, which must result in its teachings having negative consequences. Without recognizing the feminine aspect of Divinity one cannot claim to know God. To recognize the feminine is necessary to restore wholeness, completeness and universality.

Hindu Gods
“God” and the universe
For Hindus, the entire universe is part of the Divine- everything is part of “God”. And so “God”, for Hindus, is present in everything.

“God” and the “Soul”
Hindus believe that each soul is an individual, and yet is also a part of the Divine; is part of “God”.

“God” and gods
Hindus acknowledge and worship various gods, but these are all aspects of the one supreme “God”.
The gods Vishnu, Shiva and Brahma are different forms and names of the one God. Vishnu in particular has appeared on earth in various forms. Among these, Krishna and Rama are especially loved and worshipped.

Most Westerners think that Hinduism is polytheistic-which means worshipping many gods, but in fact Hindus actually believe in only one supreme God, called “Brahman”.

Brahman is a supreme spirit that permeates everything.

BUT: Brahman is not a being in the sense that Christians think of God as a being - Brahman is entirely impersonal, and entirely impossible to describe.

Everything in the universe is part of Brahman, (including each one of us), but Brahman is more than the sum of everything in the universe.

So what about all those Hindu gods you see in the temples? Read on…

One God and many Gods
There is only one ultimate reality, Brahman. But that ultimate reality shows itself in many forms, and some of those forms are called Gods.

The gods Brahma, Vishnu and Siva, for example, are different aspects of Brahman:

Brahma reflects God’s divine work of creating the universe ·
Vishnu reflects God’s work in keeping the universe in existence
Siva reflects God’s work in destroying it.

Vishnu has appeared on earth in the past at times of crisis, in 9 different forms (a 10th form is yet to appear).

Islam tells us that they are 10,000 prophets that came before islam and jesus, and moses and noha so mabye, just mabye Buddah was a prophet and so was rama and Vishnu? COuld it be what do you guys think!

But as far as i am concerned as long as you have your faith and you belive in it and loave and respect life and all that it stands for, then god “ALLAH” Loves you! :slight_smile:

INtresting posts!

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by The_Deleted_One: *

Islam tells us that they are 10,000 prophets that came before islam and jesus, and moses and noha so mabye, just mabye Buddah was a prophet and so was rama and Vishnu? COuld it be what do you guys think!

But as far as i am concerned as long as you have your faith and you belive in it and loave and respect life and all that it stands for, then god "ALLAH" Loves you! :)

INtresting posts!
[/QUOTE]

That's what i was coming to and wanted you guys to respond on. Maybe they were prophets but their teaching have changed from their original form.

I can't even claim to call myself religious, but here is my take:

Man's response to 'God' has broadly been on the following:
0) There is no God
1) God is dangerous and evil. If you don't worship/ appease him, he will destroy you.
2) God need not be feared. He will be good to you if you worship him, but he will be evil to you if you don't
3) God is a good being. He will be good to you if you worship him, but you are his child and even if you don't believe in him, he cares for you and will forgive you.
4) God is the compassionate being. He will be good to you irrespective of whether you believe in him or not
5) There is no such thing as god.

At all times in history, including the current, society has people 'subscribing' to all of these, though the above is supposed to be how religion has progressed.

Current 'hinduism' practices have elements of all the five above. You are a hindu even if you don't believe in the existence of god.

An extended view of the article pasted earlier is that, at the very highest level, two concepts remain: a) You are god, and nobody else b) There is no such thing as god. So, in a way- ok, 99.999999999% of the hindus won't accept this - the highest form of hinduism is actually atheism

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by imran dhanji: *
This is by David Frawley ....

As a universal formulation Hinduism accepts all formulations of Truth. According to the universal view there is only One Reality, but it cannot be limit ed to a particular name or form. Though Truth is One it is also Universal, not an exclusive formulation.
[/QUOTE]

It is for this reason, that hindus (ignore the exclusivist minority) generally have no difficulty in accepting other 'gods'. In many parts of India, particularly in the south, it is very common practice for a hindu to visit famous mosques and churches in the vicinity of famous temples.

For the 99.99999% of hindus who have no real knowlege of their religion, it is polytheistic for all practical purposes. But then, it is also intutively understood that god can take any form. That's why a student will worship his pen before an exam, the farmer, his field, the factory worker, his machine, the sportsman, the field, etc. He thus has no major reluctance to worship or pay his respects to Buddha or Christ or Allah, or even Gandhi or his grandfather or his mother.

There is a famous saying the meaning of which is implicit:

Your mother, then your father, then your guru (teacher) and then God.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by cscraja: *

It is for this reason, that hindus (ignore the exclusivist minority) generally have no difficulty in accepting other 'gods'. In many parts of India, particularly in the south, it is very common practice for a hindu to visit famous mosques and churches in the vicinity of famous temples.

[/QUOTE]

Not just in south, anywhere. We went to different Pirs and mother Mary's temple in Mumbai regularly, ususally to ask a favour or two. Hindus (most of them) bindikkat pray to anybody's God as long as it works. On the contray they will not worship even a Hindu God who does not deliver. Example, there are no temples of Bramha the creator in India because the bugger does not deliver or as my Canadian daughter pointed out, usaka to kam (creation of universe) ho gaya. Ab uski pratharna karaneki kya zarurat hain?

^

Just you wait and see. You will probably be born as a dung beetle in your next janam for that.

aishaA,

Dung beetles spent half their life in eating and the half in fornicating. So how bad could it be? Currently, in this janam I am spending half my life in watching what I eat and the second part jab bibiko mood hoga to, once every three months:blush:

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by cscraja: *
I can't even claim to call myself religious, but here is my take:

Man's response to 'God' has broadly been on the following:
0) There is no God
1) God is dangerous and evil. If you don't worship/ appease him, he will destroy you.
2) God need not be feared. He will be good to you if you worship him, but he will be evil to you if you don't
3) God is a good being. He will be good to you if you worship him, but you are his child and even if you don't believe in him, he cares for you and will forgive you.
4) God is the compassionate being. He will be good to you irrespective of whether you believe in him or not
5) There is no such thing as god.

At all times in history, including the current, society has people 'subscribing' to all of these, though the above is supposed to be how religion has progressed.

Current 'hinduism' practices have elements of all the five above. You are a hindu even if you don't believe in the existence of god.

An extended view of the article pasted earlier is that, at the very highest level, two concepts remain: a) You are god, and nobody else b) There is no such thing as god. So, in a way- ok, 99.999999999% of the hindus won't accept this - the highest form of hinduism is actually atheism
[/QUOTE]

Hmm, Not to sure about the "You are God part" ...