Inviting to Good

On preparation

It is often assumed that Islam is about opinion and variation is wrongly given weight. Rather Islam is about treading the Straight Path and variation is only prevalent in as much as there is concession, or leniency in governance.

The Straight Path is the most arduous path and those who wish to walk it are bound to be tested. Tested for patience and tested for motive. What is the motive for ‘good’? Can it be that we will do ‘good’ when no one thanks us for it? Can it be that we will do ‘good’ when people punish us for it? Regardless of how we are perceived we must strive for ‘good’, but complication enters when we must strive to do ‘good’ without compromising our perceptions.

Muslims are ambassadors for Islam and at the same time there is no glamour in such a role. The highest disposition of a Muslim is slave … a slave unto the laws of God. However, the slaves are subjected to criticism when they are engaged in advice and invitation. This criticism comes from within the ranks.

On Choice and Freedom

Is it true that Islam recognises freedom in religion? Or is ‘no compulsion’ meant to be something else? Islam has defined rights and wrongs and for these there are classifications of priority and context. Is it true that there is no benchmark or solid ground or is the whole of Islam subject to opinion?

Qur’an is indeed the highest scriptural authority in Islam, but it is A Book. Subject to our minds and how we perceive it. There are other authorities! Those are hadith, interpretations of companions, the scholars especially those who have acquired an unbroken tradition of guidance dating back to the earliest times of Islam. The idea of submission to God’s Law does not end at how we choose to interpret the Qur’an. By interpreting the scripture we have already fallen into a state of valuing our own opinion. This is the path towards esteeming ones own mind above the minds of those who have devoted their lives to learning Islam from those who have learned from others, who have done likewise. The final level of authority is compromised and yet by doing so we could actually be compromising all levels of authority should our understanding be utterly erroneous. Very early ijma’ was considered a beautiful means to eradicate variation and was a means towards conformance to the best opinion, as it increases the likelihood of being correct.

We should not look for how we can relax Islam to suit out needs rather should establish an acceptable view point and an exceptional viewpoint. We should find it necessary to be at least acceptable with regards to our disposition of Islamic matters and we should at least have a desire to attain exceptional status. Those who do not wish to better themselves are content. And contentment can lead to dangerous traits such as arrogance.

Our Standards of conduct

It is unfortunate that those who are perceived as religious are the ones criticised for not being ‘nice’ or due to a tone of authority and ‘truth’ in their words these are mistakenly picked up as arrogance. The very advice to others to reflect on actions such as indulgence to prevent traits such as arrogance is the very accusation that is being levelled at those who advise against those precursory actions. Why?

It is because there is a sense of pressure from within the dissenters, a sense of guilt that demands either change or rebellion. Those who rebel are those who have submitted to their own wills, but those who change are those who do so, not under pressure from the adviser, rather do so under their power; wilfully conforming to the Law of God – A truly remarkable submission!

We should work to make excuses for one another and learn to tell the truth, and learn to be nice and if we cross the mark with each other … to seek forgiveness from each other. Rather when a person is seen to admit a mistake they should not be crucified for it. It is also true that no matter how nice someone can be some people will hold it against them for being ‘inviting’ … verily those invite to good only wish for you success in the Hereafter. If you disagree with them and do not need their sincerity you can say it in a nice way. The same standards of conduct are expected from all humans, only just that those who tolerate bad behaviour are often those who are in submission to the Will of God already.

On exposing lies

In the endeavour for truth one cannot ignore lies, be they about religion or otherwise. Lies are a danger to the souls of the liars and are a danger to the trusting servants of God. Exposing lies is a duty and those in power have the greatest duty of all to manage affairs in the best amicable manner. To love one another we need to understand why we are being confronted. Some us could learn how to conduct ourselves in better ways and others could learn that there is more to delights of this world that people who address us are concerned about.

Granted, I am not a scholar and not even a Muslim, but this contradicts everything I have grown to know about Islam in my studies. The Quran is not “a book”. It is the Word of God. The ONLY legitimate, unchanged word of God.

By putting hadith, interpretations of companions and scholars on par with the Quran, you are putting Islam in the exact same category as Christianity and other religions where man is not following words of God, but interpreations of others. By valuing others’ “opnions” (whether they have devoted their lives to learning Islam or not they are just that - opinions) over what YOU can read of what GOD revealed is giving final authority to man rather than God.

How can interpreting scripture be “valuing your own opinion?” They are the words of God! The words are in black and white. If you need others to interpret it for you, it can only mean one of 2 things: 1) You are not smart enough to read or understand it, or 2) The Quran is not the book it claims to be. Surely God would not have sent down his last, final and perfect word in a way that cannot be understood without a thorough study history and thousands of pages of what other (mere humans) have said about it.

It’s one thing to put the words of Muhammad on par with God (never understood that from those who claim to be monotheistic) but now the opinions of scholars? :eek:

Indeed the practice of monoteism is a lost art.

Re: Inviting to Good

[quote]

By valuing others' "opnions" (whether they have devoted their lives to learning Islam or not they are just that - opinions) over what YOU can read of what GOD revealed is giving final authority to man rather than God.

[/quote]

your approach is surprisingly similar to the terrorist which you loath so much....i.e a very literalistic understanding of Quran
if only "words of God" were important he could have had them appear miraculosly on the walls of Kaaba like the ten commandents ...but he didnt
rather he sent down a Prophet as an example for all mankind and had His words revealed through his lips.We know Quran as word of God because Muhammad[saw] said so and the book and his sunnah are equally important to us.Those who seek to minimize the importance of the Prophet are deviants and NOT puritins or fundamentalist as they adhere neither to the fundamentals of the faith nor is their approach consistent with the example of earlier muslims.

Re: Inviting to Good

Interesting and excellent post psyah. Thanks for posting.

Its important to realise that when Islam means submission, it literally means total submission. i.e a sense of slavery to the word of God, with the key difference in that it is a'willing' form slavery and in which you are required to sell your soul completely.

However, to acquire that kinda level with an innate sense of freewill, can be deemed literally impossible for the average person to acquire in thier life time. Islam is afterall a straight and narrow (with various inlanes) paths, and noone said, it would be easy.

Islam though, or God shall i say, fully understands and accomodates by making enough room for humans to err, recognise the err, and sincerely repent. It is only when we forget the last part, we tend to go off track and continue that way.

But yeah, acquire that level of submission over time and you infact will be achieving the spiritual levels and positions similiar or closer to the levels of the great Prophets and Imams in our relationship to God, because that in essence is the true meaning of infallible...i.e. not knowingly or willingly sinning. That is the highest level us folks can set out to achieve.

There are some people in this world who have achieved something simliar, in that minor temptations mean little to them and that Islam plays a huge role in every aspect of thier life. Thier mind is set to succeed in the next life.

Secondly, yes anyone can read the Quran and yes there some things that are pretty much spelled out, but there are others that are required to be explained with in context, for the reason being that, the Quran was not revealed in one go, niether in any one situation. The ayahs were revealed at various times, many times highly significant to the situation at hand, other times not as much.

Hence your interpretation will depend on the amount of contextual knowledge you have. And with regards to that, no average joe interpretation can compare to someone whose whole life has been dedicated to the study of the meaning of the Quran. Therefore he can interpret as he wishes, but in comparison, it will be worthless.

The Quran also encourage to seek knowledge from those who have it,

'Are those who have knowledge and those who have no
knowledge alike? Only the men of understanding are mindful. " (Quran, 39:9)

Hadith in general, i agree is not considered on par, for the reason being it can be attributed falsely. But when found as an authority, it is relatively on par, as 1) as it will not be contradicting to the Quran, 2) The Prophet (saw) did not speak or do anthing contradictory to Allah (swt) will. Now which is hadith belongs to that category is for the men of understanding to differentiate according to their knowledge.

Peace Ma Mooli

JazakAllah Khair for a beautiful post. There is little more to say on this topic you have also responded to Seminole so I shall refer him to your post.

Just one extra piece of information could be that Qur'an is a guidance for those who are God-Fearing already. It also states that in some parables some people are misled and only those are misled who seek discord, early in Surah Baqarah.

I have written an article outside this thread which emphasises the nature of choice - Ikhtiyar. And to be sure the greatest choice one can make is to willingly submit to another. Presenting ourselves in slavery to God is by far a greater display of freedom of choice than conforming to our carnal instincts.