inspired with nakaabwali

[Crescent]

Re: inspired with nakaabwali

@SolarOceans

Hmmmn. That’s no true in Florida then. In fact, I know of at least three masjid’s down here with Sunni Imams that have no problem with music. Yet, according to you, music is haraam. How would you explain that? ? ?

Simple, Ask them if they are of Isnad, and if they have Ijaza. I know PLENTY Imams of masjids that have very crooked views. They admit they do not have isnad of the Prophet pbuh. Scholars do have it. Majority of them prohibit Music.

The main imams in Saudi disapprove of it. You must know which SCHOLAR you refer to. ANd you have to know if he is reliable or not.

Imams are Imams..they aren’t necessarily scholars.

btw. Isnad = Lineage to the Prophet in tradition of knowledge.

Ijaza = permission from a greater Ullema.

@SolarOceans

Originally Posted by nikaabwaali
agreed evryone has a right to there own belief and should be respected

Even in the old times the Holy Phrophet PBUH let others come and pray in the mosque

In his time there weren’t any ahmedis, shias, agha khanis

Your reply indicated that you believed that the Prophet PBUH would not have let others (shias, agha khanis, etc) come into his masjid to pray. You’re right, Shias came after the prophet so we will never know if he would have or not. That’s all I meant by that.

Shias, Agha Khanis, Ahmedis, etc all came after. You can debate Sunnis came after too, but thats a weak debate because Shias themselves can concur their political movement occured at the time of the Caliphate decision.

And Ahmedis believe in a prophet today…

And my post had nothing to do with whether he let “them” pray in his mosque.

The jews had access to the masjid. So I don’t know what you meant.