[quote]
In 1911 Sindh and the entire Pakistan was part of India so Sindh is part of Indian national anthem.
[/quote]
Excuse me, but there was no Sindh in 1911....it was part of the Bombay Presidency. If I recall Jinnah in his 14 points of 1929 called for the separation of Sindh from the Bombay presidency a point that didn't go down too well with the so called sympathizers of Sindh who now sit across the border.
Well said..
RajputFurry mian,
india has designs on sindh and hence has sindhi as a national language? good one there. any clue how many sindhis had to migrate to india? why do you think all the mohajirs went straight to camp at karachi and hyderabad, and not to lahore or peshawar?
your post is outstanding proof yet again to the fact that even for a pep-talk for pakistanis, the only thing that holds value is india-bashing - with or (mostly) without reason.
[quote]
why do you think all the mohajirs went straight to camp at karachi and hyderabad, and not to lahore or peshawar?
[/quote]
Excuse the people that you refer to as Mohajir are also settled in significant numbers in places such as Peshawar, Bannu, (in NWFP/Pukhtunkhwa) Lahore, Gujranwala and Layyah (in Punjab). No they are not from East Punjab.
Bombay Presidency included entire Maharashtra, Gujarat and parts of Sindh and parts of Karnataka too.
[quote]
Bombay Presidency included entire Maharashtra, Gujarat and parts of Sindh and parts of Karnataka too.
[/quote]
History books and Sindh associated websites seem to imply that all of Sindh was part of the Bombay presidency...care to elaborate on which parts of sindh were not part of the Bombay Presidency?
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by queer: *
why do you think all the mohajirs went straight to camp at karachi and hyderabad, and not to lahore or peshawar?
[/quote]
Who told you that migrated Muslims of India settled only in Karachi and Hyderabad, not in Lahore or Peshawar?
pt mujahirs are indian looking and you will know when you visit lahore.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by rvikz: *
pt mujahirs are indian looking and you will know when you visit lahore.
[/QUOTE]
Dude, I've been to Lahore. Some of our relatives settled in Lahore. Some in Karachi after partition.
Here's an Indian, sayin' migrated Muslims after partition settled in Karachi and Hyderabad, not in Peshawar and Lahore.
What Bull.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Pakistani Tiger: *
Dude, I've been to Lahore. Some of our relatives settled in Lahore. Some in Karachi after partition.
Here's an Indian, sayin' migrated Muslims after partition settled in Karachi and Hyderabad, not in Peshawar and Lahore.
What Bull.
[/QUOTE]
pt that what i heard from pakistani friend
rvikz u'v obviously never been to Lahore.. I know scores of families who migrated from North India and are now happily settled in Lahore..
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by mufakkar: *
The history there is a little different or are you forgetting the Mexican wars????
[/QUOTE]
I know but If tehre can be a New Mexico and Mexico, why cant there be a West Bengal and Bangladesh ?
[QUOTE]
I believe it had something to do with an idea that Jute would propel thier economy forward....when it turned sour less than 4 years later certain patriotic elements who fought in the "liberation" war....killed thier leader along with his entire family.....
[/QUOTE]
Perhaps you could be more truthful here and should have spoken the fact instead of your regular BAKWAS.
[QUOTE]
Excuse me, but there was no Sindh in 1911...
[/QUOTE]
And your point is ???? Are you suggesting that Ravindra Nath Tagore wrote 'Jana Gana Mana..' after sindh was created ??
That’s a good explanation. 
Did you communicate with your friend in Tamil or English language?
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by queer: *
RajputFurry mian,
india has designs on sindh and hence has sindhi as a national language? good one there. any clue how many sindhis had to migrate to india? why do you think all the mohajirs went straight to camp at karachi and hyderabad, and not to lahore or peshawar?
your post is outstanding proof yet again to the fact that even for a pep-talk for pakistanis, the only thing that holds value is india-bashing - with or (mostly) without reason.
[/QUOTE]
*india has designs on sindh and hence has sindhi as a national language? good one there. any clue how many sindhis had to migrate to india? why do you think all the mohajirs went straight to camp at karachi and hyderabad, and not to lahore or peshawar? *
Queer Mian,
Sindhi being a national language was ONE of the things. How about India being the prime benefactor of World Sindhi Congress, a grade A separatist organization. Arms being supplied to Jeay Sindh terrorists and lets not forget the hero's welcome for GM Syed. You said that India has designs on just Sindh, I say India has designs over ALL of Pakistan. Yes, I am quite aware of the Sindhi migration to India, but get real, no province = no language. The fact that theres a East Punjab and West Bengal may give cover to making those languages official but sorry theres ONE and only ONE Sindh. As for the Muhajirs, they settled in where ever they pleased, the fact that Karach was ONE of the focal points was because it was the capital of Pakistan at the time, and the ICS (Indian Civil Service) Muslims were largely from what became India. it was only natural for them to gravitate to a city where civil and government jobs were available.
*your post is outstanding proof yet again to the fact that even for a pep-talk for pakistanis, the only thing that holds value is india-bashing - with or (mostly) without reason. *
Say what you will but no denying the truth..Indians would sleep (safer) and sounder if there was no Pakistan. You see Pakistan has become a bogeyman, with Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh impotent, China giving a beating who else but Pakistan can you all dream of competeing against? Not withstanding population disparaities, you Indians believe that your prowess is greater...however look at the two countries and tell me if a fair comparison can be made? I have been following the developments in South Asia for a considerable period of time and I am saying something that you Indians KNOW is true and what many Pakistanis fail to admit. We know your playbook after all Chanakya was a Pakistani :)
Does any one know which assembly in Pakistan have passed Lahore resulation, and who presented this resulation in this assembly? Any one who post right ans I will pay him USD 10. Post your addresse too.
The Lahore resolution moved by Fazlul Haq at the 27th Session of the All
India Muslim League, at Lahore on March 23, 1940
[quote]
I know but If tehre can be a New Mexico and Mexico, why cant there be a West Bengal and Bangladesh ?
[/quote]
When the aid agencies are offering porridge you'd better get your share bhookay AND THEN reply. Your analogy would work perhaps if New Mexico was an independant country...read up on the Mexican wars.
[quote]
Perhaps you could be more truthful here and should have spoken the fact instead of your regular BAKWAS.
[/quote]
Oooh lookie Asif_k learned a new word today "BAKWAS" wow! Now if you can only stop dribbling we will give you some Dalia bhookay....so what am I lying about? The Jute? (Go read Shiekh sahib's speeches) or the fact that he along with his family except for Shiekh Hasina of course who was in India at the time was murdered by the "liberation fighters"?
[quote]
And your point is ???? Are you suggesting that Ravindra Nath Tagore wrote 'Jana Gana Mana..' after sindh was created ??
[/quote]
What I was TRYING to point to was your standard hypocricy....so Tagore wrote about sindh in "Jana Jana whatever" but at the same time you guys were against the separation of Sindh from the Bombay presidency.
BTW I do believe that Tagore was born sometime after the arabs designated a certain area as Sindh.
rvikz. My question is in which assembly in pakistan it is passed?
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Kinnare: *
rvikz. My question is in which assembly in pakistan it is passed?
[/QUOTE]
there was no entity as pakistan at that time let alone assembly
i think it is muslim league.may be you are reffreing to local sate assembly?
rvikz After pakistan was created in which assembly Lahore resulation was presented and by whom? After it offical name was Pakistan resulation.