Indian Cricket biased for Brahmin EXCUSE or Critique?

AT FIRST I THAUGHT IT WAS EXPOSE OF A SCANDAL LIKE THE MATCH FIXING BUT WHY SO LATE THIS ONLY AFTER DISMAL PERFORMANCE OF INDIAN AGAINST nz & aUSTRALIANS ?

IT IS NO DOUBT THE BILLION PEOPLE MARKET THAT GIVES UNDUE ADVANTAGE TO ANY CRICKET PLAYER HALF HIS WORTH ,TENDULKAR MAKES MILLION DOLLAR FOR ENDORSING ANY PRODUCT B/C INDIANS ARE JUST TOO MANY IN ONE PLACE I.E. iNDIA :eek: :eek: :eek:
Mid Day

By: Pramod Navalkar
February 10,2003
Our country should not fear Pakistan, Bangladesh and China. We are quite a powerful nation and no one dare touch us.

However, we face an imminent threat from casteism. We just have so many of castes that we don’t stand united.

Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru aggravated the problem by creating states on the basis of languages. A further division was created by offering extraordinary sops to backward castes.

When Sushilkumar Shinde became the chief minister of Maharashtra, all newspapers screamed that a Dalit had got the top post.

If we continue to hold such a myopic view delivered by the lens of caste, it won’t be long before we witness another Partition.

One thought the situation would improve in the 21st century; instead, but the casteism is flourishing. No one wants to see how it’s damaging our nation.

Our politics is solely based on casteism. There is no other ‘ism’ or ideology that guides our parties.
When Shinde was declared chief minister, Shalini Patil said she wanted a Maratha chief minister.

I thought this poison is limited to politics. But after reading an article in a leading English magazine, I realise it has penetrated deep in our roots.

The writer, in his article in a World Cup special issue, discusses the castes of our players.
He claims Brahmins have dominated Indian cricket in last 30-35 years ************************************************************
aND THEY KEEP OTHERS AWAY
****************************.

He offers statistics to prove his claim and points that there were seven Brahmins in the ’70s team, five in 1983 team, eight in 1997, eight again in 2000, four in 2002 and six in the current World Cup team.

He has made some outrageous remarks in the article, insisting that Brahmins prefer cricket — no football or hockey for them — because the latter two are contact games and Brahmins don’t like others touching them.

He also claims that in cricket, one need not have a strong physique.

He says that Brahmins dominated this game as it was purely urban and he mentions Ganguly and Tendulkar as examples.

He says that no Dalit cricketer could play in the 20th century except Balu Palwankar and he, too, couldn’t play Test cricket.

He further claims that other castes, including the Sikhs, the Jats, the backward castes are forced to play hockey and football.

These comments are not only outrageous, they are objectionable. So far, our sports have never witnessed such casteist mindset. Our cricket administrators were accused of everything but this.

There have been allegations that there is a regional bias and that there is a monopoly of certain people. But this article goes beyond that and speaks of castes of the players.

If we allow this poison to spread, we may have to select all our sportsmen on the basis of their castes, and not on merit.

The government must take action, or else we will have controversy over the castes in space-age, too.

The guy who wrote this article is a known casteist. Really amazing to find what theories people come up and how far they can go to make their names famous with such loose talk.

By Imran Khan
Former Pakistan captain

It was a positive move by Sourav Ganguly to bat first against Australia.

Ganguly needs to inspire his side
Australia thump sorry India

If you can run up a big score batting first, you immediately put the opposition under tremendous pressure.

But if you bat the way India did, then the toss becomes irrelevant because the result would have been the same either way.

The captain should be leading by example, especially when the team are low on confidence.

But you cannot describe the way Ganguly batted today as a captain’s innings. It was a very irresponsible shot he played to get out.

How can he expect the rest of his team to fight against the Aussies when he plays like that?

If you look at the 1999 World Cup, it belonged to Australia captain Steve Waugh.

He lifted the spirits of the team whenever his country needed a big score from him. He always came good, playing vital innings time and time again.

Ganguly needs to follow Waugh’s example

The problem with India right now is low morale.

There is absolutely no self belief. They are still suffering from their devastating Test and one-day defeats in New Zealand.

Compare this with Australia, absolutely brimming with confidence and self belief.

They have depth in batting and bowling, capped off with a tremendous team spirit.

The Indians could claim their poor performances are because they are not used to the South African conditions.

Australian pitches are very similar to those in South Africa. They have plenty of bounce and movement, requiring greater technique from the batsmen.

Indian pitches are completely different. But this really shouldn’t be a problem becuase India have a very experienced batting line-up.

Many of the players are familar with the South African conditions and really there should be no excuses for a batting performance like that.

:flower2:

Okay Azad Munnay - I could figure out three Brahmins Zaheer Khan, Kaif and Harbhajan - Which are the remaining.

Mr.Ehsan the link for Imrans statement which i doubt any one would ask confirmation for is BBC SPORT | Cricket World Cup 2003 | Team Pages | India | Imran: Ganguly irresponsible

P.S. I might not check my mail so dont count onit for urgent matters .Plz post it in the thread …thank you.I am working on getting the URL for Mid Day statement about indian selection process:flower2:

It aint easy getting when you pass posted itemonothr forums that dont like you to get the original url in place of there site which Gup Shup would NOT allow (other site url ) making doubly difficult

For the Caste ism in selection process

:hula: Hula: :hula:

http://www.mid-day.com/columns/pramod_navalkar/2003/february/44341.htm

You have any proof that the author is lying?

Its the job of journalists to come up with truthfull credible charges.If there is nothing it wont go far .you know that but atleast such important mastter wont go unmentioned :eek: :k: :hula:

Moderator, I think this thread is for cricket, not for discussing politics! Pls do the needful. Also , this thread started without quoting URL ( against poliices of GS , I believe).

[QUOTE]
Originally posted by The_Indian_teen: *
Moderator, I think this thread is for cricket, not for discussing politics! Pls do the needful. Also , this thread *started
without quoting URL ( against poliices of GS , I believe).
[/QUOTE]

Vic

Evern a sophmore in highh school knows that pure casteism issue is Political.And you shoukld be Adult enough that the thread did not discuss cateism in isolationBUT as it Intersects with CRICKET & specially as important an issue as SELECTION of players from Billion people.

Now if you still think i want to discuss casteism ,do whatever you want but Cricket does not involve playing any more .As the world cup head kine screams IT ISNT ONLY CRICKET but finance rascsm as shown by British to refuse to play Zimbabwe ,Refusal of Indians to play Pakistan but ONLY willing to play in World cup with Pakistan ....

Yeah , I understand! But I would also understand that intent of he article had nothing to do with cricket. And I guess this is self explainatory. If you wish , you can write an article relating a tomato with an elephant. Ofcourse, I did not want to enumerate these points. All what I thought was this thread does not qualify for this forum. I m sorry , if I did hurt you anyhow.

Peace and love.

[QUOTE]
Originally posted by The_Indian_teen: *
Yeah , I understand! But I would also understand that *intent
of he article had nothing to do with cricket. And I guess this is self explainatory. If you wish , you can write an article relating a tomato with an elephant. Ofcourse, I did not want to enumerate these points. All what I thought was this thread does not qualify for this forum. I m sorry , if I did hurt you anyhow.

Peace and love.
[/QUOTE]

Actually now that i am aware of your sensitivity ,Victotry can yopu suggest where this post should go

** What you posted here is already posted in another thread at KK**

Mod.


Ehsan

:kiss:

What is the thread at KK…Which one ??? Plz mod i forgot my post i need to know what i posted & continue discussion!!! :cool: