Indian Catholics protest release of Da Vinci Code movie (muslims join - Merged)

This “The Da Vinci Code” movie with its controversial anti-Catholic message seems to be stirring up quite the storm in India. Perhaps the Indian government should take some form of action or stance against it, given that such a prominent minority is feeling offense to it.

Roman Catholics in the Indian city of Mumbai (Bombay) are taking part in worldwide protests against the release of the movie, The Da Vinci Code.
Hundreds of members of a Catholic group gathered outside a convent school in the Indian financial capital to protest against its release next week.

They say the film is an attack on their faith, and have warned of stronger protests if their demands are not met.

Catholics say they want the protest to draw the attention of the authorities.

“Catholic Secular Forum (CSF) activists will go on a fast unto death if the government fails to take action against anti-Christian movies,” CSF general secretary Joseph Dias told the BBC.

He said the Christian community has been tolerant in relation to the book-release of the Dan Brown epic, but an audio-visual medium would have a more serious and a more lasting impact.

“You can’t make fiction on a religious figure. Tempers are already running quite high and there’s no way of saying what could happen if the movie is released,” he said.

A press release issued by the CSF says: “The Da Vinci Code is offensive as it hit certain basic foundations of the religion.”

The group says it has also collected thousands of signatures for a petition calling on President APJ Abdul Kalam to ban the film.

The CSF has also called for the banning of a second film, Tickle My Funny Bone, which chronicles the life of a “sexy nun”.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

Nope, democracy allows the mocking of religion, be it Christian and Jesus or Islam and Mohammad.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

No, that’s American democracy. Try mocking Judaism in democratic Germany and see what happens…

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

You're not going to have a problem mocking Abraham, Isaac or Jacob in Germany MS.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

You can mock Judaism all you want in Germany.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

I do not think the movie should be banned. The genre is fiction, so why should anyone have a problem.
If one believes truly in his/her religion then the movie will not matter and if the movie matters then one does not have true faith. Then their faith is just a show.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

^^

Well said brother. This is something that would'nt be understood by some of the posters here.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

Here is a movie shown worldwide and there are some minor protests here and there. Though Indian christians around 5% of the population make enough noise to become a thread on a Pakistani website..
Though guppies on this website always keep telling us that they are being presecuted in India..
Indian government should take decision based on what is right.....

India: Christians, Muslims unite against ‘Da Vinci’

I am uncomfortable with a ban but I think this support to Catholics is something Muslim communities need to do all over the world..

MUMBAI, May 15: A powerful organisation of Indian Islamic clerics promised on Monday to help Christian groups launch protests if the authorities did not ban the screening of the controversial film, “The Da Vinci Code”.

Protest in India against the film have so far been low key, but several Catholic groups have threatened to stage street demonstrations and even to shut down cinema halls screening it.

Now, powerful Islamic clerics have joined issue with Christians, saying “The Da Vinci Code” is blasphemous as it spreads lies about holy Jesus Christ.

“The Holy Quran recognises Jesus as a prophet. What the book says is an insult to both Christians and Muslims,” Maulana Mansoor Ali Khan, General Secretary of the All-India Sunni Jamiyat-ul-Ulema, an umbrella organisation of clerics, told Reuters.

“Muslims in India will help their Christian brothers protest this attack on our common religious belief.”

“The Da Vinci code” is an adaptation of author Dan Brown’s bestseller by the same name that suggests that Jesus married his female disciple Mary Magdalene and had a child with her. The film is slated for release worldwide at the end of this week.

The Vatican condemns the book and the film, and has asked Christians worldwide to boycott “The Da Vinci Code”.

In India, leaders of the two communities met politicians and police in the western city of Mumbai on Saturday, urging the authorities to stop the screening of the film.

“If the government doesn’t do anything, we will try our own ways of stopping the film from being shown,” said Syed Noori, president of Mumbai-based Raza Academy, a Muslim cultural organisation that often organises protests on issues concerning Islam. “We are prepared for violent protests in India if needed.”

Several Indian Christian groups have said they would protest against the film, with one little known Catholic organisation even calling on Christians to begin a fast until death.

Last week, small groups of protesters marched in Mumbai and burned a copy of the book.

“We will picket in front of cinema halls that show the film. We are very hurt and very angry,” said Dolphy D’Souza, spokesman of Bombay Catholic Sabha, which has 40,000 registered members.

Christians form about one per cent of India’s 1.3-billion population, while Muslims make up around 13 per cent.—Reuters

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

Oh dear.. india is showing the world how to appease their minorities. The govt. have temporary stayed the release of Davinci code. This is getting rediculous every day. Today Muslims came in support for banning the movie as it is against their religious teaching too.
Why are they so insecure. Why was passion of christ not banned in any of these countries. :D. Pathetic!
Talk about insecurities.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

It was banned in a fair number of Muslim countries

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

yes, since those countries aren’t the places which work on freedom of speech. India works on freedom of speech… In India banning a moive is just crazy…
Its been shown in whole free world, in countries with Christian majority…
Its just sucks… :naraz:

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

indiana jones says hi

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

Nonsense! It was banned only in Kuwait. Other Muslim countries saw huge crowds going to see the movie. It fit in well in the villification of Jews, so wide lattitude was given to the movie.

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2004/04/01/MNGH35UO881.DTL

Re: India: Christians, Muslims unite against ‘Da Vinci’

Here is what I wrote in the thread in SS:

As if Indian muslims have nothing else to worry about, they are about to have sit-in and fasts with their Christian “brothers” to protest a movie. Masha Allah and Alhamdollilah.

What I find really curious is the comment by Maulana Mansoor Ali Khan where he says: “The Holy Koran recognises Jesus as a prophet. What the book says is an insult to both Christians and Muslims”. It makes me wonder it Maulana Khan even bothered to read the book, or is he just going by a synopsis given to him by a devoted yes-man. Its been a while since I read the book myself, but I don’t think the book suggests Jesus was not a prophet. It portrays a theory that Jesus married Mary Magdalene and had kids. Its unlikely that this will strip him, Naozbillah, of his Prophetic abilities. If anything, the book refutes the god-like status given to Christ by the Roman Church, which uses the crucifiction and sacrifice by Christ to get its own power over the masses. To the best of my knowledge, Quran is silent on whether Jesus married or not. How do the Indian maulanas jumped from point A to point B on this one is really interesting. Its more a case of I-scratch-your-back-and-hopefully-you-will-scratch-my-back-when-I-have-an-itch.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of anti-Christian movie

Vilification of Jews? Did you even watch the movie? It was not anti-semetic at all.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of Da Vinci Code movie (muslims join - Merged)

It's a movie. Lighten up.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of Da Vinci Code movie (muslims join - Merged)

Religious thugs trying to force their point of view down society's throats. If someone wants to make a film claiming Jesus was married so be it, if someone wants to claim the prophet was gay so be it. Is the faith of the followers so weak that they fear they will leave after seeing such films, reading such books? Why must they try and block out other viewpoints?

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of Da Vinci Code movie (muslims join - Merged)

This is exactly what I said before (post #6). The political parties have their agenda - Votes. The left parties in India have no vision. Somehow they will try to appease minorities (and different sections of the society) and get back to power - be it reservation issue, religious issue or whatever.

Re: Indian Catholics protest release of Da Vinci Code movie (muslims join - Merged)

These are unwanted publicity for the movie. Those who have read the novel would see this. Only people who will benefit will be the pirated cassete dealers. :D