Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

India probes ‘sale of war plans’

Gohar Ayub Khan made his allegations in a Pakistan newspaper
The Indian army says it is looking into allegations that an Indian brigadier sold its war plans to Pakistan during the Kashmir conflict in 1965.
Gohar Ayub Khan, son of an-ex Pakistan president, said on Monday the brigadier was paid 20,000 rupees (now $335).

Mr Khan did not reveal the brigadier’s name but said he was still alive. He said the officer wanted to fund his wife’s hobby for canning vegetables.

But on Wednesday an ex-Pakistan army chief said it received no such plans.

QUICK GUIDE

Kashmir dispute

Mr Khan, a former Pakistan assembly speaker, made his allegations in an interview with Pakistani newspaper, The News, on Monday in the run-up to the publication of his autobiography.

He said he would give clear indications in his book to expose the officer’s identity.

Mr Khan said the officer had now retired after achieving a high position in the Indian army.

Doubt cast

Indian army chief Gen JJ Singh, said on Wednesday: "The army is doing an in-house verification on whether there is any truth in the allegation.

The 1965 war was the countries’ second over Kashmir

“It is not correct to jump to conclusions or to speculate on a matter like this.”

Indian Defence Minister Pranab Mukherjee has also announced a government investigation, but said: "I am afraid it is difficult to believe that an Indian brigadier would divulge military secrets for money.

“The way the news item has come up will require detailed analysis. Not to speak of a brigadier, nobody would have the detailed implementation plan.”

Echoing Mr Mukherjee, one Pakistani general told The News: “It is almost inconceivable that a brigadier alone had complete knowledge of the detailed secret plan of the Indian army to attack Pakistan in 1965.”

The newspaper said senior Pakistani army figures believed the disclosure could be a “publicity stunt” ahead of the autobiography’s publication.

Former Pakistan army chief, Gen Mirza Aslam Baig, told an Indian television channel the 20,000-rupee figures was too small to be believed.

“For a secret war plan, the amount should have been 20 lakh rupees (2m).”

Gen Baig said the Pakistani army had received no such war plans from India.

“The only information that we got was from a dispatch rider from Jammu that the Indian army would launch its main offensive from the Rabi and Chenab region. It was a very small plan.”

In his allegations, Mr Khan said Pakistani agents exploited the brigadier through his desire to satisfy his wife’s whims.

Thousands of troops died in the 1965 conflict, which ended in a stalemate and a UN-mandated ceasefire.

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

In 1965 the salary of an Army Brigadier used to be 1500 Rs, hence 20000 Rs was not a small amount.

And this is the intellectual level of BBC correspondents….

Gohar Ayub Khan, son of an-ex Pakistan president, said on Monday the brigadier was paid 20,000 rupees (now $335).

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

I think Goher Ayub should have kept his damn mouth shut,…which he couldn’t,…What a cheap publicity stunt for his book. These kind a things happens,…on both sides,…lets wait for an indian to write his book and name pakistani military officer.

BTW,…
Then in 1965,..the dollar exchange rate was different than today,…
I think then One US dollar = Rs 5

Today one dollar = Rs. 59.70,…as calculated by BBC source,…:slight_smile:

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

Tariq, you are in haste to defend the BBC correspondent. BBC must calculate the amount as per 1965 exchange rate, otherwise it looks like a mockery.

20000 was in fact a huge amonut in 1965, near about 13 times more than the salary of an Indian Brigadier.

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

I don’t think I was defending anybody here,…I tried to correct the dollars amount then and now,…
Anyhow,…If he got 20000 Rupees or 2 Million,…what he did was wrong,…also,..what Goher ayub is doing is wrong too.

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

What do you mean wrong…Gohar is an idiot. Just imagine that Indian Brigadier not only took money from Ayub, but also informed him that he would spend money for purchasing juice cannes and vegetables for his wife.

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

I think both are,…(Indian Brigadier ) & ( Goher Ayub ),…no question about it,…:eek:

It happens,..who knows how many more black sheeps are out there,..on both side of the border,…

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

So, you have accepted that revelations of Gohar are true and not a mere publicity stunt for his forthcoming autobiography book?

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

I bet this a$$wipe of a commander was a sellout and was paid off by the Indians.

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

No so fast buddy:eek: …If those allegations are true,..??? Right now,..everyone is guessing,…we are all reading the tea leaves here,…:rolleyes:

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

could it be that some potato peeler (it could be one of my distant relatives who calls himself a retired brigadier, but was actually a potato peeler) from the IA sold ayub khan a load of bull and got enough money to buy his wife her own canning equipment?

Re: Indian Brigadier sold secrets in 1965 to Pak

right queer…Ayub was an idiot. He must have compelled the Brigadier to purchase canned juices and vegetables from Pakistan as a condition to the deal. After all trade is trade!