India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/1524610.cms

WASHINGTON: India emerged as the top vote-getter in Tuesday’s elections to the newly established UN Human Rights Council, a massive victory that is seen to augur well for New Delhi’s bid for a permanent Security Council seat.

In what was described as the largest-ever polling exercise in the UN, India won 173 out of 191 votes in a secret ballot to elect the 47-member Council. It was the biggest tally for any country, surpassing Japan (158) and China (146) in Asia.

“It is a vindication of India’s long history and tradition of democracy and plurality, for the kind of international causes we have straddled,” a delighted Nirupam Sen, India’s Permanent Representative to the UN, told TNN. “It shows that we can mobilise not just two-thirds but even three-fourths of the world as we move towards the larger objective of a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.”

The new Human Rights Council replaces the 60-year old, largely discredited Human Rights Commission, which was elected by a smaller 54-nation Economic and Social Council and most contenders ran unopposed after nomination by regional blocs.

The Commission was disbanded after a number of countries with dubious human rights records manipulated elections to win seats and began to work as a bloc to defeat resolutions critical against any one of them.

Not that this election was without flaws. The US initially opposed even this Council and declined to run for a seat citing inadequate correctives. But it participated in the process that at least expanded the election process to involve all 191 members and set a benchmark of at least 96 votes (50% votes) to win a seat on the Council.

Despite this, several habitual rights abusers won seats. The New York-based Human Rights Watch identified Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, China, Cuba and Russia among the worst elected. Much to Washington’s delight, Iran and Venezuela failed to win a seat on the Council.

Separately, the human rights group UN Watch published a list of 28 countries it described as human rights abusers unfit to sit on the council. The General Assembly voted for 17 of these countries, including Cuba, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Russia, China and Indonesia. The six are also among those designated as “not free” by the democracy watchdog Freedom House.

Despite such infamy, Pakistan rejoiced at being elected with 146 votes, a third of which came from the Islamic bloc.

While a victory by such a huge margin and unsullied by any strictures will be gratifying for India, a seat on the Council will bring its own responsibility.

The Council will be required to conduct a regular review of the human rights record of all countries beginning with those serving on it. Sen said India was ready for it, pledging to make the newly established forum a strong, effective and efficient body “capable of protecting fundamental freedoms across the world.”

The Council will have its first sitting in Geneva on June 19.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

Congrats

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

I think the amount of times that India has violated human rights is enormous. but I guess this isnt the first mistake the UN has made. Just like when Libya became the leader of the human rights commission....

Whats next, Saudi Arabia hosting a conference on religious freedoms or Iran hosting a forum on new ways to stop anti-semitism and Israel bashing??

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

Just like Pakistani newspaper articles. Cannot take out emotionalism from journalism....

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

:rotfl:good one!

but I & P are not that bad in HR are they?I know there are problems and some disgusting practices but who doesn’t have such baggage you tell me

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

This is more evidence that no one is buying the Pakistani position. India is an open society, it airs its dirty laundry in the public spot light. The world accepts that, and sees any violations as a result of Pakistani terrorism.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

:eek: since when were Gujarat massacre seens as Pakistani terrorism? Maoists as Pakistani violence? Come’on, don’t use your hate to write every violence/violation to Pakistan’s name :hoonh:, you are proving to be worse than Modi now.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

You know these Bharatis will not quit pasting and repasting even trivial things. OK few more votes than China and even that in a Human Rights area? hahahhaha. Another good joke from Bharatis.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

Infinity, why do u want to post such stuff here. Some of these guys sees everything differently. Some may even go to the extent of saying that India manipulated the vote. Just leave it.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

By the way, what good has UNHRC (commission/council) has done so far? What good is this org for?

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

Hi Vinesh, if I can post a thread on Sati condemning the act, then I will like to post a thread on some of India's achievements as well :) . Good or bad, its my motherland and it's much better than what some people would like the world to believe :D.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

Thanks :).

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

itni to ladkiyaan bhi nahi jala karti hain....

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

, kabhi to sharam kar liya karo thodi si???

NOTE: Do not twist anyone's nick!

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

The NHRC or national human rights commission is a part of UNHRC or atleast draws inspiration from UNHRC. The NHRC has been quiet effective in india. But i dont know about UNHRC very much.

As an indian, it's good that india managed to get so mant votes here....but there nothing much to be proud of.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

Gujarat riots were sectarian clashes. Pakistani myopia sees only Muslims killed, but Hindu and Jains were killed as well. Chalk it up to backwardness, but there was no conspiracy. Modi, a bit of a bad politician, didn't turn the religions against each other, and he is only accused on inaction, nothing else.
On a broader level, Pakistan really has no right to speak of human rights. Pakistanis have long relegated their minorities. Theocracies by definition violate rights and so do dictatorships.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

Hey Captain1,I know that UNHRC has not been the most effective human rights organization, but for that matter neither UNSC has in it's area, and you know how covetted a membership in that organization is. But it's still an achievment (over 90% of votes) and I as an Indian feel proud of that.
Will you not feel the same if Pakistan had achieved 173 votes yesterday??
Even with all it's faults, India is being respected in the world.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

I disagree, in my opinion Modi was responsible for the post Godhra riots, he could have put an end to the riots but he did not as he wanted the public to vent off their anger from the Godhra train carnage.

I agree.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

anyways on a serious note this is an accomplishment for both countries, and I hope that both would have respect for this new responsibility and help in domestic as well as internatonal affairs.

I do have an issue with how the article portrays US though. My understanding is that US had real concerns and wanted this to be more than a toothless entity big on talk and less on standard, guided action.

Re: India wins big in UN Human Rights Council vote

Ok sir :), but I really liked that twisted nick.