India’s aid offer being considered

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

China's friendship from sincerity during Bhutto's era changed to commercial when dictators took over. China since selling its inferior products to Pakistan and Pakistan accept this garbage as it is also a partner to military supplies. It is a friendship of convinience only nothing more, Pakistan is loser at the end.

Pakistan should look beyond Uncle Sam and China. Friendly relations with India and Russia are in the interest of country. A free trade agreement with India will benefit both India and Pakistan, particularly in the field of iron and steel and railway industry. Before partition Railway was one, and India still running railway in profit or atleast not running like PR. Instead of doing business with China, India is the best option for improving Railway system iin Pakistan. However sanity instead of insanity should prevail while doing business with India. There are lots of insane people on bothsides which do thier best to keep India and Pakistan as staunch enemies to satisfy their ego and selfish desires.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

Would sooner drown then ever accept a penny from HinduStan...

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

:) Let's see when it happens in real life. The problem is that you are not the one who is drowning, poor Pakistanis are .

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

You have forgotten a key factor that is moulding china's foreign policy. Its no longer as isolated on international stage as it was couple of decades ago. Rather now it is someone everyone looks to.

Niden, trade with India even under the present restricted conditions is heavily in favour of India. So is with china. Instead of going ahead with MFN status to india, we need to restrict some of chinese imports that are affceting the local industry.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

$3 billions of goods cross over borders between India and Pakistan illegally. If this is made legal, Pakistan governmentcan can earn some revenue on this illegal trade. I still prefer India over China or anyother country in the world. Pakistan Railway is about to collapse at any time. Help from India in this regard might save this cheap and most used mode of transport by poor people of Pakistan. Again free trade with India requires trust and sanity.

Zia killed the self esteem of Pakistanis in his illegal tenure of more than one decade, Mush had already killed the Kashmir issue in his illegal tenure of one decade. Let the the trade relations should take legal path rather than illegal smuggling between the two countries.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

How much revenue will be earned and how will it affect the local industry, thats the question.

I will on the other hand go with china, she has been a crucial help on international stage. Indians are heavily anti-Pak and anti-muslim, can't trust them

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

I think india has done quite enough already .. thank you

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

My dear, Balochs are a creation of Pakistani estabishment. The habit of accusing India for Balochistan, water shortage shows your ill founded and devoid of facts arguments. Now some idiots have started saying that floods are creation of India. What else can we expect from a pauper and failed state.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

Englisg biscuits are way better than Pakistan bhiskoots.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

Funny, Pakistani share no common values with China other than your hatred of India. They are the biggest pork eaters of the world and consider Pork as poison. Pakistanis are devoutly religious and Chinese
are totally anti-religion. You do not understand each other's language, don't eat each other's food. IN fact common Chinese have contempt for Pakistanis.

So go figure.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

^They dont hate us like you do. China has been great help for Pakistan, specially in security council.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

Easy does it guys, no need to lose your temper. Instead of us answering this question whether we should accept 5 mil from India, why dont we ask a real flood victim - an 8 year old girl from charsaddah or old woman from sukkar who have nothing to eat or no shelter. Its easy to do politics when our stomachs are full and our kids are sleeping in comfortable bed.

Put politics aside, say thanks to every aid and accept it, use it for the real victims and focus on re-building Pakistan. This is no time for politics.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

Totally sensible comment and exactly! it's really easy for some here to talk when they're sitting hundreds of miles away in the comfort AC tummies full but those people that are the victims are mostly the poor, lower middle class that already couldn't afford many amenities and now with floods, homes lost, they're in even more hell :-(.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

Kaise yaar? How have they been of great help?

If anything, the guys you've wound conspiracy theories about, the US, have been of far greater help in your ability to combat terrorism, revive your economy and bail yourself out of a crisis.

And speaking of crises, we did offer you half a billion dollars, that's rite, half a billion, when the Kashmir earthquake struck in 2005. That was when we were poorer, you were, arguably, richer and the crisis was of far smaller proportion. That's about half the entire aid amount being offered now- from all countries, including the United States and China.

Sometimes I think, the Pakistanis are their own worst enemies. This aid don't come with no strings attached. We'd expect the same from you, if we were in a crisis.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

Half a billion is 500 million dollars, not 5 million dollars. And we are not comparing USA and China here, rather India and China.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

Apart from population size there isn't any...!!

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

What they teach in Indian schools is not logic or something that makes sense.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

Half a billion! WHy, you want to starve rest of bharat... What else your media tell ya? half billion of gas...LOL...
BTW I pledged $1B to bharat to feed its starving millions..

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

That's correct. India offered Pakistan $500 million in 2005.

You think there are still no people in the United States that starve while its government spends trillions of dollars on foreign wars? Or people in China, while its government spends millions of dollars on African aid projects?

Don't parade your ignorance. There is something called a contingency fund: part of a nation's forex reserves, untouched, even while the rest of a nation grapples with poverty.

India today is doing far better in dealing with its poverty. Read the World Bank report on how nearly half the millions of people that have been alleviated from dire world poverty in the last decade have been from India, with the rest being from China and a marginal portion from African countries.

A lot is changing and a lot has.

Also, I think it a little**** foolish ****to be bashing India on poverty, when your only saving grace is the fact that you have a far smaller population.

I won't berate the point. But aid need not be made a question of one's ego. Were we confronted with a situation of such magnitude, we'd've been happy to provide an opportunity for your magnanimity.

Re: India’s aid offer being considered

same goes for US, no?