India 'financed problems' for Pakistan via Afghanistan: Chuck Hagel

[Med911]

Re: India ‘financed problems’ for Pakistan via Afghanistan: Chuck Hagel

[quote=“mufaddal, post:14, topic:278676”]

@Med911

Religious affinity among Muslims is not the same as among other religions, owing to the nature of the Islamic faith.

That is incorrect. I dont see Muslims in Indonesia or Malaysia or Bosnia or the entire gulf for that matter going all ‘protective’ over injustices meted out to Muslims elsewhere.

Its just Pakistan, which feels it is the self appointed ‘Thakedar’ of Islam worldwide.

There is strong cultural link of sorts between the area that today comprise Pakistan, Afghanistan, Kashmir, and parts of India. You can see it in the Architecture, the food, the language, the traditions. Such is the nature of societies that live close to each other.

This is again incorrect, there is not much cultural affinity between the Baloch and the Kashmiri or the Sindhi and the Kashmiri, and very little between the Punjabi and the Kashmiri. Perhaps the Kashmiri’s have a greater cultural affinity with Afghans, and those in POK, but definitely NOT the average Pakistani.

Your posts raise more questions then answers. You dont seem to have thought your answer out.

What is all “protective” mean? How should they become all “protective.” How would protective Indonesians behave?

How do Pakistanis in your opinion demonstrate this “thekadari”? Can you give me some examples of Pakistanis exerting this thekadari over Islam in the global setting?

Can you prove to me there is no cultural connection between people in those regions you mentioned? Have you ever traveled in those areas? Can you explain to me how geographic proximity, has NOT created cultural similarity despite generations of cultural exchange between these closely linked societies? How empires that overlapped these regions over a millennia still managed to leave these societies isolated and completely alien to one another?