India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

http://www.hindustantimes.com/specials/cricket/world-cup-2011/India-can-t-win-World-Cup-Dean-Jones/iccworldcup2011-dontmiss/SP-Article10-672984.aspx

India can’t win World Cup: Dean Jones
Press Trust Of India
Melbourne, March 13, 2011First Published: 19:17 IST(13/3/2011)
Last Updated: 19:21 IST(13/3/2011)

Given their weak bowling and unimpressive fielding even the high quality batsmen cannot save India’s World Cup campaign, feels former Australian batsman Dean Jones who says winning the coveted trophy will remain just a dream for Mahendra Singh Dhoni’s men. "The three main common denominators consist

ent with all World Cup champion teams are: Your top four batsmen must be of a high quality. They must have the technique to play the new ball, as well as have the power and stroke play during powerplays. Your top four bowlers must be of high quality, able to absorb pressure and bowl defensively in powerplays. If you can’t field, don’t bother turning up!" Jones said in his column for ‘The Age’.
“All this taken into account, I do not believe India will win the World Cup with its current form. Tell Dhoni, he’s dreaming,” wrote Jones in his article.

Jones said that despite the presence of Sachin Tendulkar and Virender Sehwag in the team, who can rip any bowling attack to shreds, India cannot win the World Cup.

“Everyone here has a huge regard for the Indian team. They have the batsmen, no doubt. Tendulkar and Sehwag can rip any attack to shreds. But that alone doesn’t win the World Cup for India. He is dreaming,” he said.

The former Aussie cricketer said that Dhoni’s bowling combination comprising Zaheer Khan, Ashish Nehra, Piyush Chawla and Harbhajan Singh doesn’t match the standards of any of the line-ups of the previous teams.

“Captain M S Dhoni has admitted some of his fieldsmen are very slow. But Dhoni believes he will win the World Cup with this bowling line-up: Zaheer Khan, Ashish Nehra, Piyush Chawla and Harbhajan Singh. Dhoni must turn to history to see that this bowling attack will not win a World Cup.”

“Dhoni wants seven specialist batsmen and four specialist bowlers. Having seven batsmen tells me that India doesn’t trust its ‘engine room’ to make the runs required. By having four bowlers, it means that everything must go right or they are in deep trouble. What happens if one is injured? Or one gets smashed?” Jones questioned.

Jones pointed out that India’s main weakness is the form of spinners Piyush Chawla and Harbhajan Singh.

"Chawla is being smashed and was brought in by the strong backing of Dhoni after two years in obscurity. There are three leg-spinners who have won World Cups: Mushtaq, Warne and Brad Hogg. Is Chawla as good as those three? No, he isn’t.

"The Indian skipper has other problems in Harbhajan’s form. Harbhajan has struggled in all World Cups and has only take six wickets in eight matches against the Test countries at an average of 58. His 10 overs are going for around 50.

“Chawla must be replaced by Ravichandran Ashwin. Harbhajan needs to get in opponents’ faces more,” he said.

He added that India’s best bowling line-up is Khan, Nehra, Harbhajan and Ravichandran Ashwin, with Yusuf Pathan and Yuvraj Singh splitting the fifth bowler’s duties.

“The team needs the attitude to get wickets and not just defend. Getting wickets always stops the run-rate. Its fieldsmen must look for run-outs and want the ball in the field.”

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

and pakistan will!!!

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

^^ Inshallah tau bol liya karain aap!!!

:insh:

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

Dean Jones has enough time to waste in writing for a team like india, that conclusion he gave is so obvious and true! india can’t win! :k:

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

^^ Personally Dean Jones is not really a cricket great or even very well respected today...Remember his famous loose comments about Amla a few years ago...

Ultimately all the group matches are there for each team to work out its weak points before the KO stages....
India's chances are good just becuase of their deep and strong batting...yes they need to work out how to use their bowling against a top side in the KO stages...

If you look at it....Saffies are the strongest team as far as balance....they deserve to win specially after yesterdays performance...however what it all boils down to is who plays better cricket on a given day....

Considering the top 8 teams, Can Any of these top 4 or 5 teams guarantee a fired exploding performance on 3 straight matches?
I think not and that is why it will be very very interesting until its really over...

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

Dean's article is just a way to use typical Aussie Psyche out tactics to make way for Aussies team just incase they face Aussies in any stage of the Ko phase let alone the final.

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

He admitted himself that he has a BIG MOUTH....

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

Dean jones is crap

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

Do not agree with big mouth Dean Jones. World Cup is wide open. Any of the top 8 teams can still win it incl. England. Even after yesterday's performance, RSA not outright favourites IMO. It comes down to many factors. How you play on the day (for Pakistan how you bat esp. on the day), mental strength/ability to absorb pressure, luck/umpiring decisions and bowling display. Pakistan won the world cup in 1992 despite a weak batting line-up and despite abject fielding. I still remember 1 or 2 comical misfields in the outfield esp. by Aqib in the final. Both Aamir Sohail and Ramiz Raja were decent rather than great. Imran was essentially an all-rounder who promoted himself to 1-down to guard against a batting collapse. Only Miandad among the top 6 was a great batsman. Inzi had only just arrived on the world scene. Salim Malik was woefully out of form in that tournament, almost a liability in the team. We won the world cup mainly because of Imran-inspired self-belief in the team/mental strength, Miandad, Inzi and Imran's batting in crucial games and our attacking bowlers - Wasim, Mushtaq and Aqib. Fielding is something both India and Pakistan cannot improve beyond a certain level no matter what (history has proven that). But if they work on the other issues, they still have hope

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

^ GA, Excellent analysis, as always. Wide open tournament, IMO.

Recent history has also shown in terms of bowling, India cannot improve beyond a certain level. So need to do things better in departments we can control - better running between wickets, not giving too many dot balls, not treating landmarks like 100 as something special and wasting too many deliveries to get there - (ViV Richards just played to win - of course he is out of this planet).

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

Ohhh Dean has said it.Then it should be true… :hehe:

re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

Mods please change the title of the thread to "can not" from cant!

Re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

India is well set to reach the final and they deserve it too. Although I dislike the arrogance of BCCI towards Pakistani cricket and would really like to see Indian supporters suffer the same pain as in 2007, but for one man Tendulkar, I would root for India if they reached final. The guy has given so much to cricket world that his farewell should be like Imran Khan. Rest of 1B Indians can celebrate and get more arrogant than ever, I don't care.

Against top 4 teams, Pak will totally rely on their 100% performance which comes 33% of the time only. So I don't see Pakistan in final. QF, SF and final are three games and its not in Pakistan recent trend to perform in all three high profile game consecutively.

India with 3 times smarter captain than ours, know his weaknesses and can overcome them by playing to their strength. As someone said, there is a limitation in certain departments which cannot be fixed. In ODI batting and fielding win matches, we are poor in both. While India is excellent with bat for last decade and has consistent record in recent past.

Re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

Agreed. Batting is the key in ODIs i.e. one day internationals are won mainly by batsmen. If you score 300 +/-, even with a modest attack you can defend 80-90% of the time. But if you consistently fail with the bat and labour to pathetic 200 +/- totals, you would lose 90% of the time no matter how good your bowling attack is. As for fielding, no point discussing it as both India and Pakistan cannot improve it beyond a certain level (and both know it very well)

Re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

I think Dean Jones is smart, this is the only way he can increase his viewership...

Re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

Yep since their is no Viewership on hand he can dish out his “precious words” … so had to resort to this :smack: … i had a lot of respect of Ian Chappels commentary but this guy seems to be in denial that all conquering Aussies are no more and it’s quite embarassing to listen to his apologetic choice of words when he sees aussies misfield/drop catches/play stupid shot or get run out :smack:

Re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

aapke munh mai ghee shakar Dean Jones ! :hugz: I forgive him for this terrorist comments (which I remember feeling overblown at the time anyway)

Re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

To Dean Jones' statement I would add this - India cannot win the WC, **if they continue to play like this. **But watching the SA-Ind game, I am not so sure that SA can win it either given the way they played. Australia had a pretty labored victory over Kenyta. Infact none of the top teams have really demonstrated that they are heads and shoulders above the others. IMO, the WC is wide open. India lost against SA not because SA played brilliant cricket but because Indian team made a few bad decisions.

Re: India cannot win world cup- Dean Jones

Ofcourse the WC is open and due to the format, any of the teams can show up with a big performance by two people and change the outcome.

But if we have to analyze past performance and come to some projections based on that, I think Dean is more right than wrong. 338 and 296 are reasonable totals and our bowlers could not defend it.

But even worse than bowling is I am not sure how Dhoni decides on matters such as who will bowl the last over. Doesn't he understand that any pacer or medium pacer can give away runs, particularly being ineffective through out the day? With 13 runs to score, isn't better to have a slower bowler that can turn the ball or googly, better? we had Sachin, Yuvraj and even Bhajji - yet he went to Nehra. That more than the bowling is what cost us the match against SA.

That said:

in terms of class India is higher than most other teams - wish class always translated to performance....it doesn't