[IN URDU] Will History repeats itself ?

[mfjkd]

Re: [IN URDU] Will History repeats itself ?

@omeriqbal

Assalamu Alaykum,

I will end this discussion by saying I have nothing to add here anymore. This verses are far more clear, if we are bent upon saying that birds are actually people, and we are bent upon saying that God did not (or cannot) make people die and raise them despite clear verse of Quran, what evidence can I bring?

Is God trying to fool me, by saying birds (tayr) when He actually meant men (naas)? Why not just say men?

Knowing Arabic, when I am standing in prayer, listening to the recitation of these verses, am I supposed to say, ‘wait – this is not what it is actually saying, there is this hidden meaning to it’. Even though it says tayr, and tayr is used in almost all of Arabic literature as birds and it cannot mean men, and it is impossible to conceive such a meaning of this word!

It is like saying in English: “I saw a bird, it was dead, but when I called it, it actually came flying!” but then, despite the clear words in English, one still insist on saying it was actually not a bird rather people!

Tayr means the same thing – good old flying bird, that’s about it. If you can bring me ONE Arabic dictionary that suggests that it can mean men, I am willing to continue discussion at least on this part.

Best Wishes,
Omer Iqbal

**[3:50] **And will send him as a Messenger to the Children of Israel with the Message, 'I come to you with a Sign from your Lord, which is, that I will fashion out for you a creation out of clay after the manner of a bird; then I will breath into it a new spirit and it will become a soaring being by the command of Allah; and I will heal the night-blind and the leprous, and I will quicken the dead (spiritual), by the command of Allah; and I will announce to you what you will eat and what you will store up in your houses. Surely, therein is a Sign for you, if you are believers.

Mind that! Jesus was called upon instead of Allah, by Christains when Quraan was revealed. Allah said ;

**[22:74] **O men, a similitude is set forth, so listen to it. Surely those on whom you call upon instead of Allah cannot create even a fly, though they should all combine together for the purpose. And if the fly should snatch away anything from them, they cannot recover it therefrom. Weak, indeed, are both the seeker and the sought.

So, there must not be contradictions in the sayings of Allah.