"In my opinion..."-Well, your opinion does not matter, only QURAN and SUNNAH matters!

Asalamu-alekum!

Seening you guys debate with personal clames and statements such as “my mom says that if you do certain things it is good,” really makes me laugh and wonder if there are any limits to ignorence. Shia blaming Sunni and Sunni blaming Shia, pretty ugly, if you ask me. You are either a Muslim or your not, there is no such thing as Shia Muslim or Sunni Muslim. Naming your self with such sectarian names is not liked by Allah. See:[3:103 and 30:32 in quran.]

If we really care about being Muslims, we should spend time investigating everything about it in the light of Quran and Sunnah(example of prophet - which is found in Bukhari, Muslim and other sahi-hadiths books.) Most people start of their statements with phrases like, “in my opinion and I think…,” which is wrong, we should not apply our own opinions and thoughts when it comes to practicing Islam. We don’t care what your mom thinks if certain thing is good or not when we are talking about Islam. Only and ONLY opinion that matters is the opinion of QURAN and Sunnah(example of Mohammad). When we present some material regarding some belief of Islam, we should and always list the references. When you say, “in my opinion or I think…” the following statement automatical becomes void! Because, it might differ from quran and sunnah. Some people would tell you that certain things are ok in Islam, but when you study quran and when you study the sunnah, those things are not right and never were a part of Islam.

Its your responsibility as a Muslim, to learn the correct and authentic Islam. The best is to help your self and NEVER rely on such forums(BBS) to get the “correct” info, because most people here just list their personal clames and personal opinions which can be contrary to Quran.** I suggest that you buy a well translated quran and start to read in the month of ramadan, if possible buy a Tafseer of Quran. Also, buy some hadiths book, such as (sahi-bukhari and Muslim, etc.) and read them both(quran and hadiths books) and get the information you need. That is the best investment you will make (under $50-100)when learning something authentic about Islam. **
You can also buy Islamic software at: www.soundvision.com

**Islam is not a personal piece of clay, which you or your mom or your Imaam can mold in any way and its ok. NO, it does not work that way. Islam is complete set of rules and regulations, which Allah asks us in Quran to follow. There are limits which Allah has perscribed in Quran, which should not be approached!

*Allah has given us the Quran and the Sunnah to show us the way that which is good for us and that which leads our hearts and souls to true contentment. The best part of it all is that if we do things which are good for us (i.e. what Allah has commanded us) and we do it for Allah’s sake alone and according to the Sunnah, we get rewarded for it! ***This stuff I think is just amazing masha’Allah. Truly, Allah is the Most Merciful. He has given us so much. We will never be able to count all His blessings.

PS: When someone tells you that certain thing is ok in Islam, ask them for references from quran and Sunnah and than ask other people about that matter. Some people do not ask their Imaams if such and such practice is ok in Islam, because they think it might be like disrespecting them. Ask them with respect and dignity that you would like to see and read more about this could you direct me to verse from quran or hadith which tells more about this matter.

http://www3.pak.org/gupshup/smilies/smile.gif

Good Luck! Take it easy.

http://www3.pak.org/gupshup/smilies/wink.gif


V~V~VHe came, He saw, He conqueredV~V~V**


----*Priest-OF- Painful Truth*----

Hmmmm..... ok, lets not confuse the issue here.

This Discussion Board (BBS) is NOT an authentic resource guide for Islamic Teachings. The participants in this BBS are NOT (in all probability) Islamic scholars themselves. This BBS is what we make it to be. If we want to share opinions, our own or someone else's, there is no stopping it. Right?

If you and me want an authnetic Islamic opinion, we won't come to this BBS. We will go to a web-site like (islam-qa.com, or understanding-islam.com etc) and post the question to an authentic scholar.

The purpose one comes to this forum is to share information and opinions. If you provide references, fine. If you just provide your personal opinion, that is ok too. No one is asking you to follow an opinion blindly. You can ask for references, if you don't get them, just continue your research.

If we make it compulsory that no one can post anything here without a reference, I can assure you, this place will be all deserted except one or two participants, who will be quoting references from books not accepted by either of them.

Even the translations of Quran can be different, depending on who translates it. The explanation of Quran can be radically different based on the scholars who explain it. This is not something new. Even in the times of Prophet (SAWW) and immediately after him, there were occassional differences on how a particular ayat/verse can be explained. This is infact the beauty of Quranic Arabic. When you ponder over verses of Quran, you can find deeper and deeper meaning into every single word. At some time, I will, Insha Allah post the explanation of one of the shortest suras of Quran (Sura-e-Ikhlas). You will be amazed at how such a small sura can contain such vast messages and such depth.

So, lets put some perspective back here. This is a place to exchange ideas, references, opinions and our thoughts. Don't limit it to make it out to be something it is not.

Pristine, first part of your post, yes you are right. You are free to post your opinion, but in matters where Islam is concerned, we should all list the opinion of Sunnah(example of prophet) and opinion of quran only.

Islam is what Allah gave us in quran and what teachings of MOhammad taught us. There is no point in posting your own opinion where opinion of quran and sunnah is needed.

Again, you have the right to share your opinion and post it, but also keep the opinion of Mohammad and quran in mind.


*V~V~V*He came, He saw, He conquered*V~V~V*


----*Priest-OF- Painful Truth*----