Imam Mahdi (RA) and Hazrat Isa (AS)

[Ibn_Sadique]

Re: Imam Mahdi (RA) and Hazrat Isa (AS)

@Mr.Popat

If there are two different personalities, what if some Muslim follows Isa(as) and some dont follow Mahdi (as), one or the other ?

This is just a speculative question but I will answer it anyhow.

To be a Muslim is to follow both of them. They are on a Divine Mission – Like Muslims follow Prophet Muhammad (saw) and follow Hz. Abu Bakr as Saddique (ra) (Because Hz. Abu Bakr as Saddique (ra) is a true of Prophet Muhammad (saw).

@Mr.Popat

Also, according to you belief, will Mahdi claim to be a Mahdi (as) ? or will people recognize him ? Both the answer will raise many questions.. some of which are : according to your belief, door of revelation has been closed, therefore, Allah cannot tell anyone who is Mahdi. If the answer is that people will recognize him, then.. I’m afraid everyone will have their own favorite Mahdi.

The People of knowledge will recognise him from the signs and information given by the Prophet (saw).

The keyword is people of knowledge – they cannot be fooled just as Mirza Ghulam Ahmad could not fool the people of knowledge.

Only deviants or with limited knowledge will follow any Ahmads, Ghulams or Mirzas claiming to be mahdi/prophet/Krishna.

You have your Favourite mahdi, don’t you?

And mind you I don’t have time to be dragged into ongoing speculative question & answer highway with no end.

Read the following:

How hazrat mahdi (as) will be recognised?

Public » Askimam

@Mr.Popat

Answer these questions as I have way many questions but I’ll stop here. I asked straight forward questions and expect straight forward answers.

I have tried my best to answer your forward questions with straight forward answers.

@Mr.Popat

Keep all your other irrelevant statements to yourself. Thanks.

Truth hurts – when stumped for an answer – make other’s statement as irrelevant – typical!

Now allow me to put forward a straight question to you and expect a straight forward answer from you.

Which of the following statements of Mirza ghulam Ahmad you agree with:

“I do not claim that I am the same Mahdi who will come according to (words of Hadith) ‘from the son of Fatima and from my progeny’ etc.” (Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya V, Roohani Khazain vol.21 p.356)

"We admit this that several Mahdis may have come before and possibly will come in future as well and probably someone by the name of Imam Muhammad may also appear." (Roohani Khazain vol.3 p.379)
*
“It is possible and quite possible that at some time in future such Messiah may appear upon whom the literal words of Hadith(of Holy Prophet) fit, because this humble self has not come with the Reign and Command of this world, but with poverty and humility.*” (Izala-e-Auham, Roohani Khazain vol 3 p.197)

"It is possible that in future no Messiah may come. It is possible 10,000 more Messiah may come and one of them may descend in Damascus." (Izala-e-Auham, Roohani Khazain vol 3 p.251)

I got a lot more coming - let’s see how you deal with this initially.