Imam Mahdi Introduction

Re: Imam Mahdi Introduction

JL in order for your argument to work you need to show that:

  1. It is required for one to be a Prophet to recieve sustenance from Allah beyond one's natural lifetime. Ashaab e Kehf were not Prophets.

  2. It is required to be a Prophet to get some sort of communication from Allah. Bibi mariam wasnt a Prophet.

Both of these points have been mentioned earlier which you consistently neglect to answer.