Imaam Khoee smoking

Who would those be? :confused:

Of course it IS bad. Period.

It is also not the end of the world. i am just saying - he can be doing lots of good things on the side. Instead of picking on such a relatively small negative act, perhaps we can realize that there positive aspects of his character as well and in the end it is Allah Who will Judge him. Not me, not his parents, not his wife, not you, just Allah.

Lagta hai kafee impress hein nadia sahiba shiaism say and imam khamene sayy..

nahein un ki aadat hai kabhi kisi ko bura nahein kehtein, which is not always right.

Lagta hai aap meray baaray mai kuch nahin jaantay, Waqar Sahib. Aap apnay khushfehmian apnay paass hi rakhein. Bari mehrbani ho gi. Until you know me personally, do not ever presume to judge me. Aap ka bahaut shukriya :flower1:

Oye Islamabad, job shob nahin milti kia?
Koi constructive kaam dhoondo yaar. Ya tho Jhabra Shah ja kar koi ibaadat waghaira karo.

Its such a pain to see ppl like that with computers.

Re: Imaam Khoee smoking

i really dont think they are smoking, it could be either a pack of tissue as someone mentioned earlier.
Or could just be a work of photoshop i dont think i will believe these ulema smoke till i acutally see a cigarette in their mouth.

You know ..This is what is wrong with us Muslims today. We spent so much time discussing about things which allah wont ask us on the day of judgement. He will not ask if you think ulema should smoke or not smoke. or was he a good ulema or bad one. We as muslims have so much time discussing unessary things that has not outcome. and it does not benefit anybody. Do something productive. which has value on the day of judgement

True :k:

*Manfi-at ek hai, is qoum ka nuqsaan bhi ek
ek hi sab ka nabi, deen bhi eemaan bhi ek

Haram-e-paak bhi, Allah bhi Quraan bhi ek
Kuch bari baat thi hotey ju musalmaan bhi ek

Firqa bandi hai our kaheen zaatain hain
kia zamaney main panapney ki yehi batain hain ???*

[QUOTE]
Originally posted by Mobashirca: *
**You know ..This is what is wrong with us Muslims today. We spent so much time discussing about things which allah wont ask us on the day of judgement. He will not ask if you think ulema should smoke or not smoke. or was he a good ulema or bad one. We as muslims have so much time discussing unessary things that has not outcome. and it does not benefit anybody. Do something productive. which has value on the day of judgement
[/QUOTE]
*

sunnis like you are really pathetic..you really need to get a life..he smoked, big deal...its not haram nor its makrooh..keep your fatwas to yourself..Imam Khoi was one of the greatest shia scholer ever...he knew more about Islam than all of your 2 cent molvis combined..instead of opening up stupid threads you should blow urself up in a shia mosque

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Sheraz CT: *
sunnis like you are really pathetic..you really need to get a life..he smoked, big deal...its not haram nor its makrooh..keep your fatwas to yourself..Imam Khoi was one of the greatest shia scholer ever...he knew more about Islam than all of your 2 cent molvis combined..instead of opening up stupid threads you should blow urself up in a shia mosque
[/QUOTE]

I dont usually write messages here, but after reading this response I must. If these sentiments can come from some possibly well educated person... then may Allah help our nation, which is full of un-educated ones.!! I dont know who blew himself up in that mosque, but I dont think someone who truly fears Allah could have done this. If educated people start differentiating muslims on the basis of sects and point fingers at others and get emotional and have bad regards for others on the issue of an imam/scholar (not even a prophet) smoked or not... forget the rest of the issues... we will be ready to kill each other!!!

Well... I also agree... what does it matter if he smoked or not ? what is the point of this thread ? I agree.. we all need a life !... and that includes me as well... we are muslims .. we are all brothers... no hard feelings ok !!

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Master Chief: *

I dont usually write messages here, but after reading this response I must. If these sentiments can come from some possibly well educated person... then may Allah help our nation, which is full of un-educated ones.!! I dont know who blew himself up in that mosque, but I dont think someone who truly fears Allah could have done this. If educated people start differentiating muslims on the basis of sects and point fingers at others and get emotional and have bad regards for others on the issue of an imam/scholar (not even a prophet) smoked or not... forget the rest of the issues... we will be ready to kill each other!!!

Well... I also agree... what does it matter if he smoked or not ? what is the point of this thread ? I agree.. we all need a life !... and that includes me as well... we are muslims .. we are all brothers... no hard feelings ok !!
[/QUOTE]

cheif sahab, i am really sick and tired of some of these losers on gupshup..Ayatallah Khoi was no ordinary scholer...he was very respected among all of the muslims..so i will not appreciate if some lunatic try to teach him how to be a role model..and for ur kind information the person who blew up himself was not some hindu or jew..sipah sahaba and laksher e jhangvi consider themselves to be hardcore sunnis

:rolleyes: God. The world has more pressing problems than a freaking cigarette. Get over your narrow mindedness, folks, and divert this much energy instead into reading the Quran with understanding, or doing something charitable for someone else. Sheesh! Eik cigarette kai peechay aisay paRay huay hain sab - man, what do you guys think some Muslims politicians do ? Do they not smoke? Do they not lie? Do they not gossip? Ab shabaash jaldi sai post pictures of all the Muslim politicians who have a cigarette between their lips. :rolleyes: Jeez!!!

Great. Seyed Khoie passed away over a decade ago, when you guys were probably preschoolers (well waqar probably still is) and you remembered to bring up the issue now? There are quite a few Imams I know of that smoke. on top of that you're trying to jugde our beliefs on this? WoW. Seems like some people dont have anything better to do with their time. No wonder jhangvie has so many recruits. Lufan-gay.

70 excuses for your brother, this is also part of Islam.