MatineeSiren.....seems like you took it very personally! but the thing is if you say dress according to Islamic values then yes....anything other than proper hijab is against the teachings or lets say preferences laid out in Islam....
I was asking about ideas...which one is more liked by guppans ova here...., did I ask opinion on how to celebrate.....If I did...I am sorry for doing so and tender my apology for that part!
I got your point, but if one really mean to follow Islam in true letter and spirit and do not twist its interpretations according to one's own needs to justify their way of dressing then yes....buqa..or abaya is what one should wear in public...so as we will be going out to different people's homes therefore burqa was the right choice...wasnt it?
So I do not understand why you got flared up so much!
If you're celebrating an Islamic holiday, you FOLLOW what Islam says and dressing in a specific manner is an Islamic OBLIGATION. It's called integrity. If you're going to call yourself a Muslim, freakin act like one.
Islam says we have to do purdah from all Na mehram, irrespective of the occassion...so what is the point of discussing any further.
And don't be rude about your inability to see the difference between fawning over one's pride and someone simply asking another to act like a Muslim when celebrating an Islamic holiday.
Don't like Islam says about how to dress? Don't celebrate EID, because you're not a Muslim.
Simple.
Thank you for your decision on who should and should call themselves Muslims, and if I go by your statements, whosoever is not complying to the dress code laid down in Islam is non believer......
AND if you're THAT ignorant of what hijab means, then you have no right telling anyone what they should wear. You don't need to wear a damn burka to follow Islam. Just don't wear a plunging neckline , tight and short pants, and sleeveless gowns (like the pictures in this thread).
Come on, be an adult.
Even a bare single strand of hair is against the dress code laid down in Islam......I know that...and I think you know that too, so relative acceptance (and this could be huge debatable issue as well....as something bold to me might not be bold to you) of modern clothing is not in sync with what our religion teaches....
I hope that we can discuss the religious and personal perspectives in other forums like Religion & Scripture then Fashion & Beauty.......then it would be better.....
I am not going to comment any further as to what is acceptable for Eid or not, but would like other members to give their opinions on which one is "better"....and not necessarily "right" according to their opinion!