5000 years old culture for Pakistan?I will agree with you if you say it is a part of Indian culture and your other statemets are just futile attempts to make a camel to Jiraff.
All these 5000 years old sagas started after Pakistan was formed only.Even this was not a reason for the demand of Pakistan.Your 5000 years came as as a result by some historians ,who tried to shape some kind of independent identity to Pakistan,off Indian culture.But this will be futile exercise.Aslongas Pakistanis remain nostalgic for India,these exercises will not gain it's objective.
All these five thousand years is a part of Pak Educational curriculm to bring some sort of national sense in to students minds,so that they would not feel the ego when they grow up and also to get rid off Indian influence on Pak society.
5000 years old culture for Pakistan?I will agree with you if you say it is a part of Indian culture and your other statemets are just futile attempts to make a camel to Jiraff.
All these 5000 years old sagas started after Pakistan was formed only.Even this was not a reason for the demand of Pakistan.Your 5000 years came as as a result by some historians ,who tried to shape some kind of independent identity to Pakistan,off Indian culture.But this will be futile exercise.Aslongas Pakistanis remain nostalgic for India,these exercises will not gain it's objective.
All these five thousand years is a part of Pak Educational curriculm to bring some sort of national sense in to students minds,so that they would not feel the ego when they grow up and also to get rid off Indian influence on Pak society.
You are so incredibly desperate. Whatever happened in Pakistan is the history of the Pakistani people. Like I said, we didnt build a brand new identity in 1947, we continued with our 5000 year old Identity. I fail to see what this has to do with you, any other Indian or Colonial India.
1947 was Independence, not a frikin Steal-our-Identity-day.
You should consider throwing out the Colonial map btw.
what has the 5000 years, Pak identity theft etc to do with ISI and India worrying about it?
Actually as I write the question, the answer seems to be - quite a lot. It is because they are both same culture till 1947 and even after that in major parts, that ISI agents are able to blend in to Indian population so easily. This is a major major problem.
If Pakistanis looked, acted and lived very differently it would be easy to pick them out! But because they are the same cultural background they know how, for example, Gujratis speak, greet etc and what the difference with Punjabi and Haryanvi etc!
The worst aspect of it al is this: the ISI agents of Pakistan and their victims in India could be blood relatives just a couple fo generations ago and could easily be 2nd cousins!
You are so incredibly desperate. Whatever happened in Pakistan is the history of the Pakistani people. Like I said, we didnt build a brand new identity in 1947, we continued with our 5000 year old Identity. I fail to see what this has to do with you, any other Indian or Colonial India.
1947 was Independence, not a frikin Steal-our-Identity-day.
You should consider throwing out the Colonial map btw.
Noone is desperate here to prove anything .It evident that the so -called 5000 years old civilization came after 1947 only.It's because some people who wanted to deliberately cast Pakistan free from Indian identity.Even Quaid-E-Azam had not mentioned abt such a thing .I know your pain and your effort to make your statement sound ,but thats not enough.The way Pak curriuculm injected this theory is amazing ,but.At the same time,any student in Pakistan, who gains a considerable knowledge on this subject will very well come to know that this is just a piece of distortion of history.
lets talk abt this civilization in another thread.At the moment lets stick to the topic.You may open another thread for this. :)
Noone is desperate here to prove anything .It evident that the so -called 5000 years old civilization came after 1947 only.It's because some people who wanted to deliberately cast Pakistan free from Indian identity.Even Quaid-E-Azam had not mentioned abt such a thing .I know your pain and your effort to make your statement sound ,but thats not enough.The way Pak curriuculm injected this theory is amazing ,but.At the same time,any student in Pakistan, who gains a considerable knowledge on this subject will very well come to know that this is just a piece of distortion of history.
lets talk abt this civilization in another thread.At the moment lets stick to the topic.You may open another thread for this. :)
Your Insecurity is blatant. Pakistanis dont look over to India to find their history. Only Indians look over to Pakistan to claim their history. And you simply proved my point, that you cant have a history debate without bringing in modern politics.
Here is an idea, try finding something in your own country to be proud of (if you can).
indians..be thankfull ...we let u use the name of our civilization ...the real and true ancient india is pak ...ur history or ''culture'' if u have any is ofshoot of indus vally civilization and by that of shoot of pakistani culture...pakistan the name may be new but that dusnt change that ppl and land are connected to each other....whole logic of these indians is based on ...well indus valley was called ancient indian civilization by that and that and not pakistani civilization so we being carrier of the name india makes it ours.....wat next indian ocean is ur cuz it carries the name india.:D...
yeah tell that to egyptions...by ur logic they have no rite to their civilization cuz islam wasnt there in those days..dun try to be a smartass.. .:D..
indians..be thankfull ...we let u use the name of our civilization ...the real and true ancient india is pak ...ur history or ''culture'' if u have any is ofshoot of indus vally civilization and by that of shoot of pakistani culture...pakistan the name may be new but that dusnt change that ppl and land are connected to each other....whole logic of these indians is based on ...well indus valley was called ancient indian civilization by that and that and not pakistani civilization so we being carrier of the name india makes it ours.....wat next indian ocean is ur cuz it carries the name india.:D...
hussain, you are so funny. a friend of mine said everybody calls even Pakistanis as from Indian civilization because you guys haven't development your own
yeah tell that to egyptions...by ur logic they have no rite to their civilization cuz islam wasnt there in those days..dun try to be a smartass.. .:D..
ur ancestors were all hindus at one point of time :)...there was no such thing called islam untill 700AD
so tell me who are u.... are u the followers of prophet mohammad or the descandants of pagan worshipping men and women of indus valley???
the topic is “I.S.I. makes India worry!!!”