Husband and gifts

Re: Husband and gifts

no...don't do this.
don't interfere in his relationship with his friends. that's not your place.

Re: Husband and gifts

I understand your objection as far as technicality of sadaqa is concerned. But the way I'm looking at it is that if she has no control over his spending on his friends, or if she is unable to impact his decisions in this matter then she is pretty much helpless and in her heart she can consider it sadaqa. I'm certain that Allah will understand her desire to keep peace in her home until such time as she is able to show her husband the error in his ways.

I think to some degree many of us have had the same experience. I know that when we move it's always been my friends and family that have helped while his friends have been nowhere in the picture. Meanwhile when his friends move he is over there days on end.....helping them clear out....even being the last one to sweep up and close the door. The same with some heavy yard work that was done.....his friend, though living a short walk away was never over helping us but my husband felt the need to be there all day long to help out. Not much you can do about it until he wants to see what he's doing wrong. It's a long and drawn out process and sometimes only time can do the job.