humans vs animals

I’m sure it must have been discussed before, but in my philosophy discussion group we often come back to this theme, and I decided to put the question to you guys.

What distinguishes humans from animals?

A lot of people have thought about it and I’ll give a few examples:

Aristotle suggested that a human is merely an animal that has been able to create a society/political climate around itself: he calls humans ‘political animals’. So clearly for him, the ability to reason was the distinguishing factor between humans and animals.

some psychologists have gone further and have suggested that humans have developed a language, which is the defining feature of humans.

I personally think these explanations are true, but do not hold to a long extent:

for example: persons with a mental disability cannot always develop language, yet are considered humans, and they possess traits that definitely distinguish them from animals.
An argument against Aristotle’s is that in rural Africa there are plenty of civilizations without a political climate that are humans as well (e.g. nomads).

My answer to this question about the distinction between humans and animals would be thus:

Extrapolating the two previous explanations and perhaps trying to find a common feature in them, I think what distinguishes humans from animals is the ability to think linearly, to think in time. Because of this ability which in innate in humans, and hasn’t been found to exist in animals, humans are humans. However, one can say that animals who go to sleep at night, and wake up in the morning have a sense of time as well, but I’d rather think those are instinctive reactions of their body to external impulses rather than an internally created behavioral process.

Don’t know if i make sense? :konfused: :smiley:

Re: humans vs animals

Human = Animal

There is no distinguishing difference. We are just smarter, more civilized, more organized and have a profound attachment to capitalism.

Re: humans vs animals

^ wrong :p

Humans are aliens on planet earth, most of animals are native

They belong to different worlds, so they are different

Re: humans vs animals

What makes you so sure that going to sleep and waking up are not instinctive behaviours for humans? Afterall, the human body tires and rejuvenates. It tells us when we've had enough physical activity and forces us to allow time for refreshment of resources. By the same token, it tells us when we are hungry.

Re: humans vs animals

Muzna, I fully agree with you that humans too have instinctive behaviour (perhaps the majority of human behaviour is instinctive or conditioned), however humans have the ability of 'behaviour that is thought about' next to instinctive behaviour. And this 'thought over behaviour' is linear in form. This last thing is what animals are lacking.

Interesting thing is that the ability to plan ahead and to think linearly is thought to be primarily a function of the frontal lobe (the front part of your brains, right behind your forehead). And the hypothesis is that it is exactly this part of the brain that is underdeveloped in animals (or overdeveloped in humans).

Re: humans vs animals

Sounds like a good theory to base your conclusions upon.
I'm fascinated by the fact that such a small portion of the brain will cause such major differences between us and those that we "choose" to alll animals.

Re: humans vs animals

^well the reality seems more complex than what I sketched above. The same part of the brain also seems to be pivotal in children suffering from ADHD.

Re: humans vs animals

Yeah...I read that somewhere....

Do you happen to know the co-relation to individuals that have been daignosed as autistic?

Re: humans vs animals

i began to read of extremely interesting on the topic, a kind of synthesis of reasearch on origins of humanity and the difference with animals, especially evolved animals such as dolphins, monkeys, elephants, etc....
but it's in french :"l'homme cet étrange animal" Jean françois Dortier

languages exist also among killer whales, dolphins, etc...
cultures do exist somewhat in some monkey species also: some tribes of chimpanzee have special nutritional customs that are different from distant tribes for example
so language and culture are not really what differenciate humans from animals.

regarding politics, i think it's mostly an extension of tribes governement that are themselves deriving from the hierarchy existing in any mammals living in groups: monkeys have power games where "bribery" seems common, lions have a hierarchy, wolves too, etc...there are chief and social roles, even gender roles attributed to any members based on the abilities and "intelligence" to get the power and keep it.
so i don't think "politics" is really special to humans

so what is so special about humans?
the ability to build stories, and dreams, to create myths and religions...
conceptual thinking and mental creations of worlds that do not exist for real...
animals have practical thinking, their intelligence makes them find more food, water, fight against predators, procreate as much as possible, etc..
human thinking is not only practical, of course human technology is more adaptative and cometitive than most animals technologies...but as you pointed it out nescio some humans don't have the mental capacities to grasp evovled technologies

BUT even the dumbest human can built dreams, stories, myths, lies, etc...
human are dreaming creatures, and it's the dream that pushes them to build starship to go to mars, submarine to explore deep oceans or internet to connect people all over the world.

Re: humans vs animals

What distinguishes human beings from animals is the ability to bit-h about things. To Roll their eyes when they don't like sumthing, and to tell others to shut up when they are being silly.

Re: humans vs animals

hmmmm, Muzna, to be honest I don’t know what the relation is, but from what I know of their behaviour autistic and ADHD children are actually quite opposite to each other:

the one is too focussed on one (trivial) thing, whereas the other cannot even focus on one (important) thing. Perhaps the exact opposite is happening in the brain of the one from the other?

Re: humans vs animals

Actually I didn't mean to compare autistic to ADHD.

Re: humans vs animals

U meant the co-relation between autists and animals then? :confused:

Re: humans vs animals

Have u ever noticed that in humans, the female is a lot more prettier than the male, while the males in animals have beautiful colors, patterns & exotic mating dances (e.g the birds of paradise). I've really admired birds & they are my all time favorites.