well, that’s what it is. it’s just like no matter how good a person you are but you do NOT accept the constitution of a country and do things against the country, what would your judgement be against that person?
we are humans with limited knowledge. Allah knows best. if we call ourselves Muslims then we must believe in Islam in it’s entirety. we can NOT pick n choose according to our whims, likings, preferences, knowledge. either you and i accept what’s in the Qur’aan or we may refute it. choice is ours. we’ll be the losers if we are wrong.