Huddod Ordinance

[roadrunner]

Re: Huddod Ordinance

I’ve eliminated all the bull**** from your post and answered the important points.

@Sa1eem

If your answer is ‘No’ then my question is that according to ‘Hudud law’, what would happen to the rapists (criminals)? Can they be punished without four witnesses under Hudud law or go free?

YES, THEY CAN BE PUNISHED UNDER TAZIR. Finally you got it!

This is Second contagious issue, that hudud ordinance do not convict the rapists.

The Hudood Ordinance includes Tazir punishment and evidence.

Then my question is that, according to Hudud ordinance, if the raped girl cannot provide four witnesses of her rape, can anyone after that rape case (where she confessed that she was rape) sue her for adultery?

If your answer is ‘Yes’ then this is Third contagious issue, that girl that was victim now become accused (due to Hudud ordinance).

[If you answer is that, ‘no, she cannot be sued for adultery’ then go and read hudud ordinance again].

If a girl cannot prove a rape using 4 witnesses (if the trial is Hadd), or using DNA evidence/female witnesses (trial by Tazir), then she can face an adultery charge (which requires 4 witnesses to prove), so in 95% of cases adultery cannot be proven.

If an unmarried girl becomes pregnant (and claims that her pregnancy is result of rape), then can she be sued for adultery according to Hadud ordinance? [Yes or No]

The answer is no, because the girl is not married, so it’s not adultery, I guess.

As for you talking about Tazir that is a different issue. Tazir is there when Hudud law fails. As for Tazir, it cannot nullify Hudud laws nor override hudud laws. Judgment according to Tazir is largely dependent on judge discretion.

Under Tazir, all forms of evidence, including the woman herself is acceptable. It is not a case of a failed Hudood Law leading to Tazir. Tazir is a part of the Hudood Law. Read the Hudood Ordinance.

I was also mentioning injustices on rape victims due to this ordinance and help to rapists (as they go fee because of lack of four witnesses, while hudud law does not take into account other evidences). You should note that I am not talking about Tazir law (that applies when Hudud law fails and regardless, it is discretionary law)].

THE RAPISTS DO NOT GO FREE. IF 4 WITNESSES ARE NOT PRESENT, TAZIR EVIDENCE IS USED - This includes DNA evidence, the testimony of the woman herself etc.

Anyhow, my mails were for only those who can think so please I am sorry, I should have ignored your mails. I believe that those who think, my mails must be clear but exceptions will always going to be there.

Thus, if you understood what I wrote or if you did not, it does not matter. Purpose of what I wrote was not to argue for the sake of arguments :). My voice on the issue is just voice of my consciousness (that does not end here on this forum, to pent frustrations) . So, please do not get agitated or upset. Have some cold drink, forget and relax

It’s clear you havent got the faintest idea what you’re talking about.