How would you be different if you were born in different faith?

[phoenixdesi]

Re: How would you be different if you were born in different faith?

@diwana

What classic tactics?

I only interpreted your own posts. Read below please.

Please show me where I called you infidel or warn you of God’s wrath. I am perplexed here.

What are my ASSUMPTIONS?

I posted based on your post. And you made assumptions about me first that whatever I said was based on what a mullah would tell me.

Why did you drag an unknown or even non existent mullah in to the discussion when you could easily talked to me what I wrote and had problem with?

**Isn’t that an obvious and interesting… that you or many others on this forum just love to drag an unseen Mullah… and ALL Mullahs are evil creation of Allah who are there to misguide Muslims?
**

So you do agree that you have this question on judgement of Allah being unjust because he is the one who made 5 Billions born in to Mushrik and Non Muslims families.

Then why blame me in interpreting your thoughts as being one sided and biased?

According to you, Allah made 5 billion born in to Mushrik/Non Muslim families and hence CAN be considered unjust EVEN for the sake of philosophical discussion. Fine.

But how about the scenario being reversed?

**Answer me honestly!

Do you think the same logic (of being unjust) should be applied to Hindus. Christians and Jews and the God(s) they worship to?
**

Contradiction here.

If religion was not important to Allah then how come everyone would be treated based on his/her (different) belief?

Please explain.

Sure, Allah can treat anyone the way he wants or wishes. But that is not what is asked here.

**He is free to do whatever he wishes to and he can even backtrack what he has said to mankind through his messengers or scriptures.

**
But, the thread was NEVER about what ALLAH would do, rather what we as human would do.

You brought the concept of him being unjust without even trying to negate it. Read your own posts above.

whatever makes you happy…all i am saying that if someone thinks about his religion, into which he was born by god without his choice, in a certain superior way and considers it be the only and rightist code of conduct, then he is unintentionally putting his respective God in a tough spot and hence that is not the right way to think about the religion…the contrary view that i presented seems more logical, **as I see it. **

Thanks for your viewpoint…much appreciated…you gave me some good points to think about and I hope i did the same. we have laid out our cases in detail…any further discussion at this point would mean that at least one of us is either intellectually bankrupt or intellectually dishonest…so lets just stop here.