Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

**SUKKUR: **Parveen has to deal with an angry husband every time her brother has a fight with his wife. She has to make sure her mother and brother don’t do anything to shake the volatile situation she has at home.

It’s been three years and Parveen continues to walk on eggshells just like she did when she was a newly-wed. Her marriage to Ashiq Ali was arranged at the same time as her brother Arbab set to marry his sister as watta satta, a custom of exchanging siblings in marriage.
“Believe me, I always try to live up to my husband’s expectations,” she said. “I don’t argue and do whatever he says but all my effort go down the drain when my husband starts to hit me and blame me for what my brother does. If my brother is not taking care of my sister-in-law my husband hits me.” She added that she was four years old when her parents decided on her marriage to Ashiq. Parveen is one of the many women who have to suffer a lot of domestic abuse because of watta satta marriage. Her neighbours know her as a caring, sensible woman but the fact that they know she’s part of a watta satta marriage, means they know she will be humiliated or beaten up every now and then.
Village elder Mouran is strongly in favour of the watta satta system. “This custom has been a part of our culture for centuries,” she said. “Watta satta marriages guarantee protection of both the girls involved as the families would have to think very carefully before taking any action.” He added that there were times that a girl would be mistreated by her husband and in-laws, especially in such cases. According to Mouran, it was a matter of honour. “We marry our daughters into someone’s house in exchange for their daughter,” she said. “In some cases where people don’t have daughters they pay a certain amount.”
Mirzadi, 65, is the mother of eight children and had a watta satta marriage. “Even today my husband beats me,” she said. “When his sister faces any problem at my mother’s house or if my brother is being difficult, then I have to suffer.” She added that she was married at the age of 14 and doesn’t remember a single day she was happy in her marriage. She claims that she received her first beating three days after she was married because her brother scolded his wife for breaking a glass.
“I have never been to school but I know about equal rights,” she said. “Parents seldom ask a girl about the man they select for her to marry. So why do men have the liberty to choose their bride? We claim to live in the 21st century but we still are living in the stone age.” She added that it was a pity that parents got promised their children in marriage even before they took their first step.
“I will not marry my daughter off to a man without taking a girl in exchange,” said Ghulam Ali. “If I get her married without a watta satta then how will her interests be guaranteed?” He added that watta satta was a good way to create a lasting bond between two families.
He gave the example of his own children. “My son-in-law and his parents will never harm my daughter,” he said. “If they do, then they know that their daughter will suffer.”
Human rights activist Jamila Mangi strongly opposes watta satta marriages. Such marriages not only ruin the lives of girls but can take two families to war, she said, adding that even if one girl takes good care of her husband, children and in-laws, she will be blamed for everything wrong in her sister-in-law’s life.Published in The Express Tribune, June 7[SUP]th[/SUP], 2014.

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

Do you people in favor of this painful system,seriously it is hurting these days to see my maid suffering from this watta satta system, she is innocent, may Allah help her, who will teach them?who will make them understand, Allah knows how her days and nights are, since her nephew divorced her sister in law(one who was in her exachange) she is extremely depressed and full of fear...where this meaningless system came from? why these innocent woman suffer a lot?
o Allah guide them ameen...afsos yeh hota hay na deen hay na duniya ki taleem...!

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

Watta Satta is for people who're too jahil to treat their dils with kindness and respect. The fact that you need some kind of guarantee for humane behaviour is proof enough. If a village starts a new tradition of never beating up the women in their homes their sons will see the positivity and emulate them and this generational cycle will continue the positivity instead.

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

Watta satta is usually a cause of problems unless the couple is sane enough to not let problems in the other siblings marriage destroy your marriage.

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

I know of two sisters married to two brothers, so I guess that would be watta satta marriage....although in their case, it wasn't set as a condition. MashaAllah se they're happy. I do not favor the imposing of such an arrangement. However, I suspect that the abusive husbands in this article would have mistreated their wives even if they didn't have a watta-satta marriage. Look at the quoted example. Assuming the glass was broken by accident, that doesn't warrant a scolding from your spouse. It's easily replaceable. To physically harm your wife when the other guy merely scolded his sister is not only unjust but too severe of a reaction. Both men...the scolder and the hitter...lack control of their tempers. So they might behave this way with their wives irrespective of what kind of marriage they have. Though, yes, a watta-satta (like cousin marriages) can make relationships more delicate.

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

Yes becuase in this case,if one is divorced, it will be demanded to divorce the other as well, why one of two suffer just because of this system, nobody suffer only those two girls suffer who are in exchange! May Allah grant them understanding ameen

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

I am not in favour of watta satta as it usually results in issues

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

I understand that. Yes, watta satta can strain marriages. While on one hand it's thought to bring greater security, it makes those same relations more delicate as well. But what I mean is that if the husbands in this article struggle with controlling their ghussa...(and it seems they do) then they'll have issues in non-watta- satta marriages too... But yes this type of marriage comes with aggravates matters more.

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

pata nahi shadiyun ko tu ajj kal bari nazar lag gayi hay:teary1:…may Allah grant us goodness and protect us from evil ameen

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

Nothing holy about it, culture which still pass on to the next generation

Sane and ok couple can too break up because of parents or extended family members

Dying down but still common in rural area especially punjab and happens outside pakistan too

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

It seems tribal, never heard of this before.

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

Watta Satta is how two families use two females as leverage.

more often than not i have seen this. Very few successful watta satta.

Re: Holy matrimony: Watta satta - your daughter in exchange for mine

. One man in our village broke his wife's arm because his sisters arm was broken in a fight at her inlaws. They had a watta Satta marriage. Just imagine the mental ability of these buffoons.