Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

An interesting article by Walid Phares speculating that the Sinora government is about to be overthrown by Hizbullah in an armed coup. Sounds about right to me. Presumably this will lead to the eventual withdrawl of the UN forces, and round two of the Israel/Lebanon war.

FROM WORLD DEFENSE REVIEW
Published 13 Nov 06

Walid Phares, Ph.D.
World Defense Review columnist
Hezbollah’s offensive in Lebanon has begun
According to sources and contacts – as well as statements made in Lebanon over the past few weeks – all analysis indicates that Hezbollah is on the verge of an all out offensive in Lebanon to crumble the “March 14” Seniora Government and to seize strategic control in the country.
Following are few points deserving attention (a more comprehensive analysis will follow later)

  1. As predicted since July 12, (and posted on the Counterterrorism Blog), the aim of Hezbollah’s summer war with Israel, was to provoke a “strike-back” at the Lebanese Government and reshape the balance of power in Lebanon to the advantage of the Teheran-Damascus axis. Nasrallah and his allies across the sectarian divide aimed at shifting the issue of disarming Hezbollah and militias (according to UNSCR 1559) to crumbling the government, which is supposed to implement this disarming process.
  2. By mid-October, Hezbollah and its pro-Syrian allies had begun a political counter offensive aiming at “enlarging” the Seniora cabinet, as a way to paralyzing it further from the inside. The political discussions took longer than anticipated by Hezbollah. Hence, a decision was made in Tehran (and subsequently in Damascus ) to move forward.
  3. The perceived results of the midterm elections in the U.S. were read as positive by Tehran and its allies, in the sense that it froze vigorous reactions by the U.S. against any Iranian-Syrian move in Lebanon via Hezbollah. The feelings in Tehran and Damascus, have been that if in the next weeks and months a “thrust” takes place in Lebanon to the advantage of the pro-Syrian camp, Washington will be in no position to react or counter. Ahmedinijad and Assad believe (or have been advised to believe) that “lobbies” are moving in Washington and Brussels to restrain any strong deterrence by the U.S. against the “axis.” The theory is that the Bush Administration is too busy “negotiating” with the new leadership in Congress to “dare” a mass move in the Middle East. The analysis also predicts that strong lobbies within the Democratic Party are now positioned to block any serious response to a change in geopolitics in Lebanon. It is believed that the window of opportunity won’t be too long before the Administration and the upcoming Congress “understands” the Tehran-Damascus maneuver and create a unified response. Thus, the expectation is that Hezbollah and its allies were told to achieve their goals before the end of the year, and before the new Congress begin business on the Hill.
  4. Hezbollah has mobilized its forces from all over the country to position them in the capital and eventually use them in moves in Beirut, the central and southern part of Mount Lebanon, where most government institutions are located. Nasrallah can also bring into “battle” the supporters of General Michel Aoun, the Syrian National-Socialists, the Baathists, and the pro-Syrian Sunni militias, the Islamic Fundamentalists paid by Syria, the Palestinian radicals and the security agencies still under the influence of Syria. This “huge” army can – technically – defeat the thin internal security forces of the government. The Lebanese Army is an unknown factor, with Hezbollah supporters in control of the military regions in the south, the Bekaa, southern suburbs and other positions. In short, the “axis army” is ready to engage in battle in Lebanon. The issue is when, how, and with what outcome.
  5. The projected scenario is as follows: Hezbollah and Amal movement ministers will resign from the Government calling for the resignation of the Government. The next move is to have Hezbollah, Amal, and their allies in the Parliament also resign, thus creating “conditions” for what they will coin as new elections and a collapse of the cabinet. Most of these moves have already been accomplished or are on the eve of being implemented. The pro-Syrian President Emile Lahoud will declare the Government and the Parliament as “illegitimate,” and call for early legislative elections. The latter, if they take place will be under the smashing influence of Hezbollah’s weapons (a show of force was performed in the summer) and of the cohorts of militias and security agencies. Result: a pro-Syrian-Iranian majority in parliament, followed by the formation of an “axis” government in Lebanon. The rest is easy to predict: A terrorism victory.
    The question today is, how to stop this from happening? While it is very late in the process, the United States must respond in a strong bipartisan way, the Security Council should move immediately to chapter 7, and the Cedars Revolution to take the streets again. Short of these developments, the worse is to be feared on the eastern shores of the Mediterranean soon.
    HOAX.COM: unravelling the truth from fiction, past to present...

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

pardon my expression, but what a pile o 'orse sh1t.

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

This is the direct result of President Bush wrong foreign policy and Israel continued terrorist and criminal activities in the region. Before the invasion and mass murder in Lebanon Sinora government was strong and their economy was booming. The country was becoming a model democracy for the region. Enter Israel obsession to invade other countries and President Bush support for it, result many killed, moderates support lost and arming of militia, where they are not only strong but also have the political support were looking for.

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

Ohioguy still making his fanciful predictions, just like he foresaw Israel victorious over Hezbollah some months ago. :rotfl:

Re: Phares is a pro-zionist neocon clown

This clown Walid Phares is a notorious pro-zionist neocon clown. He writes for the right wing thugs in the National review magazine.

Nobody takes Walid Phares seriously and he is just b!tching cause his maronite christian community has lost its power and priviledge in Libnaan.

Libaanan was a part of Syriaaa during Ottoman times before the French colonlial thugs carved a piece of Syriaaaa and created Libaanan to protect the economic and political priviledge of the christian minority. The meronite were a minority but still 60% of the seats in parliament, the position of president and the army chief was reserved for them, which is an undemocratic act.

During the civil war the Pharanges Christians sided with Israel against their own fellow libaanese neighbors and when the zionist thugs were kicked out of libaanon the meronite pharanges christians lost their priviledge.

Libaanan should be a democracy !!! the Shiaa muslims are the majorty in Libaanon and as such should have the right to rule lebanon.

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

Ummm.

Hezbollah vows change in Lebanon

  **Leader scorns Cabinet talks, pledges, `This government will go'**

       By Liz Sly
            Tribune foreign correspondent
  
 November 15, 2006

BEIRUT – Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah has vowed to bring down the U.S.-backed Lebanese government and replace it with a new one, setting the stage for a showdown between America’s allies in Lebanon and the country’s pro-Syrian and Iranian factions allied with Hezbollah.

In comments published Tuesday in two Beirut newspapers and carried by Hezbollah’s Al-Manar TV station, Nasrallah said he does not plan to return to negotiations on the structure of the current Cabinet, and that the pro-Western government of Prime Minister Fuad Siniora will soon be gone, deepening the political crisis that has been building since six ministers from Hezbollah and its allies resigned over the weekend.

“This government will go. . . . A new government is coming,” Nasrallah was quoted as telling a gathering Monday of residents left homeless by Israel’s bombardment of Beirut’s southern suburbs during last summer’s war.

Nasrallah did not say how or when Hezbollah intends to bring about a new government, but his uncompromising remarks suggest he intends to press ahead with threats made late last month to force change by ordering his followers to take to the streets if negotiations failed to give Hezbollah a greater share of seats in the Cabinet.

Since the collapse of those negotiations Saturday, Lebanese have been on tenterhooks, wondering whether their country once again is to be plunged into turmoil that could risk provoking renewed civil war.

Following a recent warning from Washington that Iran and Syria are teaming up with their Hezbollah allies to prepare to topple the Lebanese government, Iran warned Tuesday that Lebanese should be prepared to challenge U.S. and Israeli ambitions in Lebanon, further raising fears that the country is falling prey to regional rivalries.

At a meeting Tuesday with Nabih Berri, a Hezbollah ally and leader of the Shiite Amal movement, Iran’s supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei told Lebanon “to prepare for all contingencies.”

“Lebanon, God willing, will be the staging ground for the defeat of America and the Zionists,” Khamenei was quoted as saying by Al-Manar. “The political situation in the world and especially the region portend a new era. The policies of America in the region have failed and we must take advantage of the opportunities presented to us during this period.”

The resignations of the six ministers, including all five Shiites, triggered a crisis that has called into question the legitimacy of what remains of the government.

The ruling coalition won a clear majority of seats in the parliament in the last election. But under the rules of Lebanon’s consensual democracy, all major sects must be represented in the Cabinet, and the resignations leave the government without any Shiites, the country’s largest Muslim group.

The depleted government on Monday approved a draft UN resolution establishing a tribunal to bring to justice those responsible for assassinating former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri in February 2005, but the opposition has labeled the decision unconstitutional because no Shiites were present.

The current government is composed of the Sunni, Christian and Druze factions who united to push Syrian troops out of Lebanon in the wake of Hariri’s assassination, which they blame on Syria. Government officials have accused Hezbollah of walking out of the government to block the investigation.

In his speech, Nasrallah denied that, and he accused the government of knowing in advance of Israel’s plans to wage war to destroy Hezbollah and of encouraging the Israelis to “prolong” their offensive.

The allegation of government complicity in the war that killed an estimated 1,000 Lebanese and left tens of thousands of people homeless, most of them Shiites from the south and from Beirut’s suburbs, is likely to exacerbate Shiite antagonism toward the government and escalate sectarian tensions.

Nasrallah addressed civil war fears, taunting those in the government over their claim that they represent a majority of Lebanese but also promising that he would not provoke violence.

“Some warn of a civil war,” he said, according to the daily As-Safir newspaper. "If they claim to be in the majority, how come they are so terrified?

“This is our country, and we have given tens of thousands of martyrs, wounded and prisoners to protect it and preserve its glory and dignity,” he added. “We will not waste these sacrifices and we will strive to maintain civil peace and stability.”
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi-0611150102nov15,1,4804780.story?coll=chi-newsnationworld-hed](http://www.chicagotribune.com/images/clear.gif)

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

^^i dont think the current regime is meant to be anything but a puppet of the US. this however didnt stop mr sinoiras government from stopping the revisit of condi as she was not welcome by anyone. hezbollah will wait for the next elections i think, although theres nothing wrong with increased participation before then.

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

of course hezbullah want a different gov, preferably one that is less hostile to the org that saved its ass, but theres no military coup' about this. they are protesting politically with ministers resigning and peacful protests and i dont think thats a 'coup' by any standards. Seyed Nasrallah has always maintained the protests will be peaceful. and they have every right to do so.

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?


Saved its ass?!! You mean initiated a conflict that almost destroyed her. Your beloved Hezbollah is nothing but an extremist, violent proxy of Iran that uses religion to justify hate and violence disguised as a charity organization.

The assination today is further proof of the benevolence and 'peaceful protests' of this terrorist group.

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

:rolleyes:

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

I dont think Hezbollah has any thing to do with the assassination of the Minister. My 2 cents are most likely French or Iranians. Lets see how it plays out. But I m sure there are celebrations in Washington and Tel Aviv because this is a step forward in the Civil War direction. that means more NATO troops in Lebanon which is strongly opposed by Syria. Hopefully something good will come out of it. but lets not hold our breath.

Syria has nothing to gain from it, nor do the Israeli's. Most to gain from this incident are Iranians and Europeans.

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

Sure.

8 of the past politcal Assasinations in Lebanon were Anti-Syrian. And Hezbullah is supported by whom? What border do the weapons come over?

Sure, Hezbullah is white as a virgin.

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

very weak case you have og. it wouldnt stand up in court.

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

and Virgin = Israel

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

I don't have to take this case to court. We will all know soon enough if Hezbullah decides it can be an effect part of a government, if if it wants to be the government. Political parties do not have militias that are more heavily armed than the army. Political Parties do not snatch neighboring countries soldiers as hostages. Hezbullah, through foreign money has bought an army, and bought loyalty, they think they are the government already. That will mean a war again with Israel, as Hizbullah has nothing on it's mind but further conflict. They suprised the IDF once, that will not happen again. The IDF will be working night and day to counter the tactics of Hizbullah.

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

:omg:

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

Laanat tujh par.

Hizbollah Zindabad!

Re: Hizbullah Coup in Lebanon?

I dont think ohioguy is pakistani, he must be an american. I have never even seen him type in our language...