RSS oriented people have started a strange debate in India. They demand that in India all Christians must call themselves Hindu Christians, and Muslims to be Hindu Muslims so and so….
What shall we name Hindus in India,….just Hindu or Hindu Hindu?
He said "Hindutva was cultural nationalism while Hinduism was a religion encompassing all sections of society as stated in the saying Sarva Dharma Sambhava.
well i dont agree with this call for calling hindu christian or hindu muslim but i think the muslims and christians of the subcontinent must acknowledge thier hindu roots or hindu past.
we are not of arab descend or of turkish descend? yes 10% of us maybe yes but 90% of the muslims of the subcontinent are of hindu origin whoes ancesters have been hindus.
i think there is no harm in accepting this hard truth
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by kabir: *
well i dont agree with this call for calling hindu christian or hindu muslim but i think the muslims and christians of the subcontinent must acknowledge thier hindu roots or hindu past.
we are not of arab descend or of turkish descend? yes 10% of us maybe yes but 90% of the muslims of the subcontinent are of hindu origin whoes ancesters have been hindus.
i think there is no harm in accepting this hard truth
[/QUOTE]
What next, Juda muslims, sikh muslims, parsi muslims buddhist muslims, kafir muslims, muslim muslims....... LOL...
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Jagjeevan: *
I agree this 'prefixing' is idiotic. but the question does arise - why then do you have sunni muslim and shiite muslim?
[/QUOTE]
both sects belong to one religion. there is something called common sense!
how come there is brhaman hindus, and 3 others ..im sorry i forgot the rest why dont you update me on that.
both sects belong to one religion. there is something called common sense!
how come there is brhaman hindus, and 3 others ..im sorry i forgot the rest why dont you update me on that.
[/QUOTE]
no need to be sorry the other three are kshatriya, vysya and sudra. In addition there's also "The Hindu" which is a news paper.
so you think having multiple classes within a religion (whether the sunni/shiite muslim or the four in Hindusim) is ok. but classifying by a national origin is wrong? so what do you think about the name "Hindustan"?
What atmosphere RSS and BJP are creating, very soon the Muslims and Christians will definitely start thinking that they belong to some foreign lands.
That can be a victory for RSS, but will definitely be a defeat of India.
When Jinnah forwarded his demand of Pakistan, majority of Muslims in India new nothing of it, but the RSS people were roaming around and telling them that they (Muslims) were eating Indian bread and butter.
In fact RSS made it easier for Jinnah to go ahead with the plan of Pakistan.
