If you believe that everybody in Hell would have the same physical body as they have on this earth, then you should also come to conclusion that the same kind of water would be used to burn the body. But water can't sustain even for a second in a temperature exceeding million degree centigrades. Before it would be pour on the body of the inhibtants of hell, it should immediately be evaporated.
Secondly All the examples you gave from Holy Quran of putting life in dead donkey and birds coming to life are all metaphorical. It would be a great mistake to take them literaly as it makes Holy Quran a book of wizards and magic, which it isn't.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by fatehahmad: *
......
Secondly All the examples you gave from Holy Quran of putting life in dead donkey and birds coming to life are all metaphorical. It would be a great mistake to take them literaly as it makes Holy Quran a book of wizards and magic, which it isn't.
[/QUOTE]
I thought Quran was clear as it says in its verses, may be you know more than that, or perhaps you read a lot between the lines.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by fatehahmad: *
....But water can't sustain even for a second in a temperature exceeding million degree centigrades. Before it would be pour on the body of the inhibtants of hell, it should immediately be evaporated.
[/quote]
Kindly point that out where in hadith it said that water will be boiled to more than million degree centigrades. BTW, you must have heard about "Superheating".
Can water sustain its current form in extreme high termperature. For example, million degree centigrades. It should immediately be evaporated. It water is already evaporated how can it be pour over somebody.
And Yes I know about superheating. But in case of superheating the temperature difference is only minute. In Microwave, water can become superheated at temperature of around 101 degrees. Just 1 degree above the normal boiling point. But here we are talking about million degree centigrade.
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by fatehahmad: *
...But here we are talking about million degree centigrade.
[/QUOTE]
I asked you before, who is talking about "Million" degree?
Mr. Changez_like:
I think you got confused everything. Original poster said that boiling water would be poured over the bodies of the inhabitants of Hell. I answered back that as temperature of the Hell would exceed million degree centigrade, it is not possible to water to sustain as it should already been evaporated in less than a second.
The poster and you are trying to make Hell a physical place and assuming that the inhabitants of hell would have the same physical bodies that they have in this world and those same physical bodies would be tortured by fire and boiling water and many things else.
I disagree to that!