Re: Hazrat Yazid Ibn Muavia (RA) First Sermon as an Amir ul Momin
[quote]
Maybe i need search but the point here is that majority of sahaba and tabain did bayaat of yazid and remained stick to it. Even after the martyrdom of hazrat hussain.
[/quote]
What sahaabis and what bayaah? After Abu Bakr passed away there was NO bayaah. He chose Umar, Umar chose Usmaan and then came Muawiyaah who then chose Yazid as his successor. There was never a bayaat.
[quote]
As far as hazrat hussain bin ali is concerned, even bani hashim and bani abbas did not supported the hazrat hussain as they don’t think it right and legitimate. So he had to seek the help of kuffa to get some power who were very famous for their tricks, indiscipline.
[/quote]
This made me laugh. First, Bani Abbas was already cruel beforehand, I don't believe they would support Imam Al-Hussain in one way, or the other. As for Bani Hashim, all of Bani Hashim was gone during that period! All of Hazrat Abdul Muttalib's children had passed away. The only remaining members were Imam Hussain, his sisters and children. Now tell me, were they not in Karbala?
[quote]
And then incident of karbala occurred. Majority of the reliable sources indicates that hazrat yazid had nothing to do wid the martyrdom of Hazrat Hussain. He simply asked to stop hazrat hussain so that they cud not reach kufa.
[/quote]
Wow, then explain to me, who really killed Imam Hussain? And while you're at it, please show me those ahadith.
[quote]
It is said that the war started by the brothers of Hazrat Muslim Bin Aqeel who was disgruntled on the death of hazrat muslim bin aqeel and wanted to take revenge of his death………… as per the arab tradition. Fight lasted only two or three hours and that’s it
[/quote]
Now this is just..wow. There are a handful of ahadith about Karbala and the purpose at the BIRTH of Imam Hussain. Who ordered the killings of Muslim ibn Aqeel, his brothers and sons/nephews? I'm pretty sure it was Ibn Ziyaad who was Yazid's chamcha.
Narrated Umm al-Fadl daughter of al-Harith
Umm al-Fadl went in to see Allah's Messenger (peace be upon him) andsaid, "Messenger of Allah, I had an objectionable dream last night." Heasked
what it was and she replied, "It was terrible." He asked, "But what wasit?" She replied, "I seemed to see a piece of your body cut off andplaced in my
lap." He said, "You have seen something good. If Allah wills Fatimahwill give birth to a son who will be in your lap." Fatimah then gavebirth to
al-Husayn who was placed in her lap as Allah's Messenger (peace be uponhim) had said. One day she went in to see Allah's messenger and placed
him in his lap. She turned round, and noticing tears falling from the eyes of Allah's Messenger, she said, "Prophet of Allah, for whom I would give my
father and mother as ransom, what is the matter with you?" He replied,"Gabriel came to me and informed me that my people will kill this sonof mine."
She asked if he really meant this one and he replied, "Yes, and he brought me a piece of red earth." (Tirmidhi, hadith 1639)
[quote]
It is important to note that hazrat umro bin saad ra who was commanding the yazid army was the son of Hazrat Saad Bin Ibi Waqas – the conquerer of iran. Few traditions says that umro was was a sahabi and few says he was a taabi. So the bottom line is that it was a political event rather a war between kufr and islam. Same like siffin and jamal.
[/quote]
Umar, not Umro. Political event lol, wow. Explained above.
[quote]
I think few historians have unnecessarily made the karbala incident as a religious one. In order to make their view strong they started to scandalize the personality of hazrat yazid. In effect karbala was purely a political event.
[/quote]
Allahu Akbar.