Hazrat Isa A.S.

[lethal_kamikaze]

Re: Hazrat Isa A.S.

@Mr.Popat

‘rafa’a’. It means exalted ones status, or exalted oneself in rank.
There is no mention of physical body taking up in that verse. There is no mention of heaven, nor is there any mention of even sky. It is your assumption that he went to heavens bodily alive. Where is it written? On the contrary, when Allah said "allah exalted him to himself’, it means exalted his status and have given death.

When the word ‘rafa’a’ is used anywhere in Quran or ahadith, it has always meant as in status. Please see the verses below and please do confirm it.

[19:57] And We** exalted him** to a lofty station. <<< this one is for Hazrat Idris (as).

Assalam o alaikum warahmatullah.

Peace Mr.Popat,

As you wrote above: (1) Exalted him to Himself (2) exalted him to a lofty station.

Can’t you see the simple and bold differentiate between these two verses? Exalted to a lofty station that is understood but exalted his status and have given death? Yeh konsi logic use kr rahy ho

and how ‘rafa’a’ means exalted ones status? 'rafa’a means exalted. From where this ‘ones status’ came?

Well If I translate as per yours then the transltaion of [19:57] will be: **“And we exalted his status/rank to a lofty station” **. I think we can’t use both ‘his’ and ‘him’ at one time, right. That translation doesn’t make sense as why his “status/rank” exalted to a lofty station? why not “him”? But if we translate the same verse by using “him” than it will be “And we exalted him to a lofty station” which means he exalted to a lofty station alongwith his status/rank. Right. He can’t leave his status/rank back there.

Allah SWT exalted Hazrat Isa a.s. to Himself same as Prophet (with his status and rank i.e. prophency) and whan Hazrat Isa a.s. will come back, means when he will descendent to this earth he will be descended alongwith his status/rank i.e. the same prophency. So there is NO new Prophet After Muhammad . Like you said earlier “We both consider him to be khataman nabiyeen, the seal of the prophets” If yu consider and believe Prophet Muhammad is ‘Khataman nabiyeen’ then there should be no doubt of coming back of Hazrat Isa a.s.