Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddique r.a

[Ibn_Sadique]

Re: Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddique r.a

@Surdar_Asif

It is speculation on your part to think that way. There were dozens of people with the name Umar in Arabia. For example Umar ibn Abu Salama was a strong companion of Ali. Imam Ali is recorded in the books to have named one son of his as Uthman in memory of Uthman ibn Nath’un who was a companion of the Rasool Allah and later on of Ali’s. As for Abu Bakr then that is kuniyat and not a real name meaning the father of Bakr.

No, sorry it is other way around – It’s sheer speculation of some later day Shia author trying to wiggle out and ‘find’ some excuse for Hz. Ali (ra) naming his son ‘Abu Bakr’.

Any authoritative reference showing any narration attributed to Hz. Ali (ra) stating what you claimed?

But him naming his sons ‘Abu Bakr’ and ‘Umar’ shows deliberate intent on preference for these names.

If the name was just Abu Bakr then one would say that it’s just a name but getting the names Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman in one go is no coincidence but a deliberate intent on preference for these names.

Now your scholars have to dig another obscure person around Hz. Ali (ra) named ‘Umar’ or ‘Uthman’ to be awarded the honour of having child named after him.

Yeah, this is called speculation.

If the names Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman were good enough for your infallible Imams to name their sons with then why is so abhorrent for Shias.

This shows that Shias don’t follow the deeds of their ‘infallible Imams’ but whims of later day ayatullahs.

@aqeel123

If asking for reference can offend people here then i dunt think its the best idea to discuss his personality on this forum anymore.
PS: None of ur posts relate to what i was asking, I wanted a source for a hadith that was mentioned in opening thread… It was provided sources but technically they rnt same, as wording was different in sources provided.

Brother Aqeel, no offence was taken – but just that your query smacked of ‘I-don’t-believe-it-show-it-to-me’ sort of attitude.