Re: Hadith: Hazrat Musa (as) and the Stone - for Sheraz-CT
unfortunately for you guys, I had a little free time on my hands, so prepare to be bored...
DOES ANYONE ELSE RECORD THE AFOREMENTIONED HADITH OF ABU HURAIRA?
The hadith of Abu Huraira in al Bukhari about Prophet Musa bathing that was cited by Ibn Sadique is also recorded from Abu Huraira in whole or in part in...
Sahih Muslim
Sahifa Hammam ibn Munabbih
Musanaf Abd al Razzaq
Musnad Ahmed ibn Hanbal
Musnad Abd ibn Humayd
Musnad Ishaq ibn Rahawiyya
Sunan al Tirmidhi
al Nasai's Sunan al Kubra
Sahih Ibn Hibban
al Tahawi's Mushkil al Athar
al Bayhaqi's Sunan al Kubra
Ibn al Mundhir's al Awsat
... and others...
DO ANY OTHER COMPANIONS RELATE THE SAME HADITH?
It is reported by at least two other companions (as referenced by al Shawkani in Fath al Qadir)...
Anas ibn Malik: Recorded in Musnad al Bazzar and Ibn Mardawiyya
Ibn Abbas: Recorded in Musanaf Ibn Abi Shayba, Tafsir al Tabari, Mustadrak al Hakim (who authenticated it), and Ibn Mardawiyya
ONE EXAMPLE OF HOW THIS HADITH WAS RECORDED AND TRANSMITTED
As for the authenticity of the hadith... aside from it being in al Bukhari and Muslim, this particular report is an interesting example of a hadith that is not only recorded in what is probably the earliest extant hadith work (the Sahifa of Hammam ibn Munabbih) but also a prime example of a hadith passed from teacher to student in continuous written form...
-- On one occasion Abu Huraira dictated 138 hadith (the hadith of Musa bathing was one of them) in a single sitting to his student...
--- Hammam ibn Munabbih who recorded the hadith in a work available today in manuscript and as a printed edition (Sahifa Hammam ibn Munabbih - the hadith of Musa is #61 in the collection)... Hammam narrated the hadith to one his most famous students...
--- Ma'mar ibn Rashid, who recorded it in his al Jami' collection (available in print today as part of the following work)... Ma'mar reported it to his most famed student…
--- Abd al Razzaq, who recorded it in his work, al Musanaf, which along with Ma’mar’s al Jami is also available in print today…
So up to here we already have three published hadith works (all prior to al Bukhari) containing the report under discussion in which we see the hadith transmitted from the earliest time from teacher to student in a series of books...
One could also add that Abd al Razzaq's most famous student, Ahmed ibn Hanbal, also has his Musnad collection of hadith and this hadith is in there too…
al Bukhari himself recorded the hadith from the above personalities through another one of Abd al Razzaq's students, namely Ishaq ibn Nasr... as an example here is al Bukhari's isnad for the hadith at Vol.1, no. 277:
Ishaq ibn Nasr related to us, saying:
Abd al Razzaq related to us, on the authority of:
Ma'mar, on the authority of:
Hammam ibn Munabbih, on the authority of:
Abu Hurairah, from:
The Prophet (saw)
DOES ANYONE OTHER THAN HAMMAM IBN MUNABBIH REPORT THIS HADITH FROM ABU HURAIRA?
So do al Hasan al Basri, Abdullah ibn Shaqiq, Muhammad Ibn Sirin, and Khalas Ibn Amr...
THE MEANING OF VERSE 33:69
Five interpretations are given for 33:69 across the various tafasir... four of these are summarised by Ibn al Jawzi in his Zad al Masir fi Ilm al Tafsir:
- The one understood from the hadith cited above by Ibn Sadique
- That Bani Israil accused Musa of killing Harun
- That Qarun had a prostitute charge Musa with committing adultery with her
- That Musa was blamed for being a sorcerer and being insane
Another (fifth) possible interpretation is suggested by al Razi in Mafatih al Ghayb and by al Alusi in Ruh al Ma'ani...
- That Allah declared Musa blameless and innocent of their sayings: "So go you and Lord and fight, we will sit here" (2:24), "We cannot endure one kind of food" (2:61), and "We shall never believe in you until we see Allah plainly" (2:55)
Various commentators have related, discussed and preferred the above five interpretations as follows...
Al Tabari mentions #1 and #2 (Jami' al Bayan);
al Qurtubi discusses #1, #2 and #4;
Ibn Kathir gives #1 and #2 (Tafsir al Qur'an);
Tafsir Jalalayn mentions only #1;
al Baydawi has #1, #2, and #3 (Anwar al Tanzil);
al Shawkani has #1 and #2 (Fath al Qadir);
Ibn Abd al Salam gives #1, #2, and #4 (Tafsir al Qur'an);
al Nasafi gives #2 and #3 (Madarik al Tanzil);
al Tha'labi mentions only #1 - but leaves it open for other interpretations (al Jawahir al Hisan);
al Suyuti has #1 and #2 (Dur al Manthur);
IN CONCLUSION...
It is not far fetched to conclude, as indicated by al Tabari, al Qurtubi, and al Alusi, that we should understand 33:69 to mean that Allah declared Prophet Musa's innocence from each and every one of the above allegations...